45 ms·
A new method boosts wind farms’ energy output, without new equipment
- adrianN 4y agoUsing global control instead of local control seems like such an obvious improvement that I wonder why it hasn't been used earlier. I wonder whether the real difficulty lies in getting the simulations accurate enough to make useful predictions.
- rocqua 4y agoI suspect actually interfacing with the windmills is the hard part. Especially if you want to support many different types of devices. Local control, and no need for a global coordinator, might be so much simpler as to be worth losing some efficiency / not going into integration hell.
- maxerickson 4y agoA typical wind farm will have 1 or 2 types of turbine.
- bluGill 4y agoAll the wind turbines in any given windfarm come from the same manufacture, and they all have monitoring and control from the utility's main offices in whatever city (at the very least they have enough control to prevent damage when the weather gets bad, I don't know what else they can do). As such all that is needed is a software update from the manufacture to give the central office more control. The utility might own wind turbines from different manufactures, but they are not in the same wind farm. I suppose there might be places where two wind farms border each other that you want different devices, but for the most part you can optimize each wind farm individually with no need to worry about manufactures.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI don't know that any of that is true. Farms can have different makes and models. I also think that there is a lot of on board control.
- bluGill 4y agoSure they can, but the reality how wind farms are built is they won't buy more than one make on any given farm. They place an order from some factory to deliver, getting a into the factory order stream is a large part of the process. Of course it does take a couple years and so there is plenty of opportunity for the factory to change internals in the middle, but the manufacturer is locked in before the first turbine goes up. Shipping is also rather expensive, so your are probably going with the nearest factory for everything. (each blade needs a semi with an oversize load permit, and "chase cars" both in front and behind with the right lights and signs) Of course if a turbine fails in 5 years (I don't know what the warranty is, so I'm going to use 5 years) they might replace it with one from someone else, but that isn't common. I don't know how much is onboard controls. However someone is feeding the weather instructions in, and when demand is low someone is telling a few to shut down. They also do remote monitoring for issues that maintenance needs to fix. That connection just needs an upgrade, along with some new software for the onboard controls and it can be done offboard. (this may not be easy, but compared to a turbine it is cheap)
- s1artibartfast 4y agoIm guessing you are thinking of very different farms than I am. At the extreme, I am familiar with farms that have been expanded over 25 years and have a huge variety of builds. I am also aware of a number of farms that have at least 2 different sized turbines.
- bluGill 4y agoI count an expansion as just putting up a new wind farm next to a previous one, which happens often. At least in my experience the expansions often get a different model (visually different), but I count that as a new wind farm. I'm reasonably sure that all wind turbines in my area come from Siemans. (they have a factory in my state, any other make would be shipped in from a considerable distance)
- a_shovel 4y agoIt's a 1.2% overall improvement. That's the kind of number where it's worth doing in general, and worth using if it's been developed, but not nearly worth the development effort and headache for a wind farm operator trying to invent it on their own.
- asojfdowgh 4y agoconsidering it amounts to 1.2% over a period, I wouldn't say "obvious improvement" local maximizing presumably already deals with the effects from upstream turbines, global (also presumably) only adds consideration for downstream turbines
- convFixb 4y agoIt has been done earlier; multiple times, by every serious manufacturer. :-] The real difficulty lies in: 1) Noise in the on-turbine wind speed and direction measurements and/or robustly (see point #2) operating LIDAR or met masts in front of the farm to try to avoid said measurement noise. 2) Actually arriving at a robust, operational in real-world conditions, fully closed-loop control system. A commercial wind farm has to operate 24/7 for 25 years without a bunch of engineers and scientists babysitting it, which is what is likely to end up happening if the cool control system relies on offline simulation results, topographical data, and/or human-supervised calibration & tuning. It's not all doom and gloom: Ongoing improvements in sensor price/quality will probably make these kind of global control systems more and more practically feasible in the future.
- 7952 4y agoHaving off-site control of configuration and sensor information seems desirable and obtainable regardless. And once that is in place it is just a commercial decision. If spending x on cloud modelling delivers a multiple of x then its a simple decision.
- linhvn 4y agoAs the old say, the devil lies in details. Writing a global control is no means an easy task, as 1. You need to recognize the opportunities exist in the first place. 2. You need a global controller that can aggregate and optimize for a global solution (and the global solution might not necessarily simply to maximize the aggregate throughput, but there might be other factors into account), which may involve some algorithmic design (in some cases, you need to design new algorithms). 3. You need to justify that global controller gives you a superior solution compared to locally greedy solution. As in this article, a global solution gives you about 3% improvement compared to the local controller, and the local controller algorithm is substantially easier to write. Background: in my previous job at Meta, I wrote such a global control algorithm for controlling the rate of data going in and out each data center. It involved some really interesting algorithmic design.
- mlyle 4y agoI think the real thing that's difficult is-- every installation is different, in the geometry of the turbines, turbine sizes, terrain shape, etc. Even if you have a perfect implementation of this, and you don't need to deploy new networks, etc, and you put in a lot of NRE to make this easy deploy... how much engineering effort is still needed to start squeezing 1-2% out of a wind farm?
- mhb 4y agoIt's very hard to believe that this wasn't already standard.
- Silverback_VII 4y agoFor common sense nowadays you need at least 10 scientists and one big expensive simulation.
- ben_w 4y agoYou are severely overestimating "common sense". Joe and Jane Average (and by extension various stages of planning permission in certain locations) are still saying "but what about when theirs no wind!?!? lol" as if transmission lines don't exist.
- deelowe 4y agoJoe and Jane Average are not designing windmill farms. There are clearly some very very smart people working on these systems.
- ansible 4y agoEh, not it is not hard to believe. The research was definitely worth pursing. A 1.2% overall efficiency gain is not nothing, and is indeed significant enough that I think people will want to implement it. On the other hand, without doing some extensive research, it wasn't clear what the magnitude of the improvement actually was.
- hirundo 4y ago"But in the new system, for example, the team has found that by turning one turbine just slightly away from its own maximum output position — perhaps 20 degrees away from its individual peak output angle — the resulting increase in power output from one or more downwind units will more than make up for the slight reduction in output from the first unit." I assume that this could also increase the speed of a cooperative convoy of sailboats, that have a good reason to stay close. I wonder if the fleets of sailing ships of Admiral Nelson's time took advantage of this. A few extra ergs of force in a sea chase could make a large difference.
- rocqua 4y agoThe idea here is 'stay out of dirty air better'. It isn't a real gain for the downwind turbines, just less of a loss. This concept has long been known to sailors. And I presume that sailing in convoys took this effect of dirty air well into account.
- scrivna 4y agoYou see this in competitive dinghy racing. One person will intentionally starve their competitor of good air, so they know and could do the opposite if they wanted. Lots of sports deal with this “dirty air” concept like Formula 1 especially, regulations were changed for this season so the car in front produces cleaner air off the back so cars behind can follow better (which provides a better chance to overtake/better viewing spectacle).
- koheripbal 4y agoThis only impacts wind farms when they are arranged such that the wind front passes over multiple turbines. Often, wind turbines are arranged in a line across the usual wind front, so turbulence isn't typically an issue. So, in this case, when wind passes over multiple nearby turbines serially, then there is a 1.2% gain on efficiency. Still a worthwhile deployment if the model is accurate. Needs to be tested.
- rocqua 4y agoThe 1.2٪ figure was a month long average from a real-world test. In certain conditions they got 32% higher efficiency. Presumably those are the conditions when the wind is blowing sub-optimally. Unrelatedly, from personal experience both onshore and offshore windfarms seem to be packed much tighter than in a line.
- briffle 4y agocompletely anecdotally, I have noticed in the midwest, its very common to have a large grid of windmills. But out west, some (not all) of them are placed along ridgetops in a wide line, with none behind each other.
- dylan604 4y agoWhy go anecdotally? Here's photographic evidence: https://www.google.com/maps/search/wind+farm/@32.3343137,-100.4444907,16289m/data=!3m1!1e3 https://www.google.com/maps/search/wind+farm/@32.3343137,-10...
- koheripbal 4y agoThese rows are spaced far enough apart that I don't think the OP research would help as much. Even where they are clustered, they are at different elevations.
- dylan604 4y ago
- lizardactivist 4y agoWhy are wind turbines constructed like reverse propellers? Would they not be more efficient if they were shaped like an actual turbine with a deep spiraling blade, placed inside a cylindrical or conical encasing?
- jackmott42 4y agoI believe that if you consider the money it takes to add the conical casing, and instead just make a bigger tri-blade without a casing with that same money, you come out ahead.
- mynegation 4y agoNot an expert, but that rings true. Probably environmental impact of a huge volume of air sucked into the cone and fed into a high-speed grinder should be factored in as well.
- deelowe 4y agoIt's not that. It's because they are optimized for low pressure differentials.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI'm sure both are true. It doesn't make physical sense or economic sense. Encasing the entire turbine with a shroud the diameter of the blades would be astronomically expensive. However, there is no rule in physics that you can't 10x the windspeed with a focused inlet. Natural mountain ranges around some farms have a similar effect to improve power output, but we would never consider building a natural mountain to improve turbine efficiency
- 5d8767c68926 4y ago> but we would never consider building a natural mountain to improve turbine efficiency Maybe we could? Mining operations already produce huge volume of material from tailings and overburden. Not an outrageous idea to be more strategic in how and where that material is placed. Could create some artificial ranges with better wind properties.
- jmartrican 4y agoSerious question here. Why I see all these breakthroughs coming from MIT? Are they really heads and shoulders above everyone else or do they have great PR/marketing?
- marktangotango 4y agoProbably both, it is a top research university in the world, with a lot of smart people and funding. Also note the "T" in MIT stands for technology, they do tend to focus a bit more on practical applications and not just theoretical knowledge.
- gostsamo 4y agoAt least in this case, it seems that MIT is only tangentially related to the research. The lead researchers are from Spain and India with financing from Siemens.
- RosanaAnaDana 4y agoIts good marketing and I would keep an eye on what accounts are submitting these. Its practically a trope on HN at this point. Not to say that MIT doesn't do cool stuff, but there are few institutions as good at self promotion.
- photochemsyn 4y agoIf you look at the paper it's actually a collaboration between MIT researchers, Caltech researchers, a Spanish Siemens groups, and an Indian power company. MIT just has a more effective marketing division, it seems. Here's the Caltech press release for comparison. https://www.caltech.edu/about/news/tweaking-turbine-angles-squeezes-more-power-out-of-wind-farms https://www.caltech.edu/about/news/tweaking-turbine-angles-s... > "Collectively, wind farms generate about 380 billion kilowatt-hours each year in the United States. If every U.S. wind farm were to adopt the new strategy and see efficiency increases similar to those found in the new study, it would be equivalent to adding hundreds of new turbines capable of powering hundreds of thousands of homes to the nation's power grid, says Caltech's John O. Dabiri (MS '03, PhD '05), the Centennial Professor of Aeronautics and Mechanical Engineering, and senior author of a paper on the project that was published by the journal Nature Energy on August 11."
- deelowe 4y agoThis makes me wonder if it could be optimized further if mechanical design changes are explored. It's common practice in aerospace to minimize dirty air in certain cases. I wonder if there are opportunities where different turbine designs could be deployed depending on the windmill density.
- rr888 4y ago> Virtually all wind turbines, which produce more than 5 percent of the world’s electricity, are controlled as if they were individual, free-standing units. I refuse to believe this, every wind engineer would know one windmill affects the next. Its not as clear as the picture either where they are lined up. In most locations wind changes direction so for some flows they'll interact different to others.
- calt 4y agoWind engineers know this, but the software control work is non trivial and, apparently, simply hasn't been done. A few years ago I was talking with a family member who is in wind power research. They were trying to convince me to start writing turbine control software because it is massively inefficient and naive. I was shocked at some of the optimizations they are lacking.
- linhvn 4y agoVideo illustration: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UP2yJqGQ2FU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UP2yJqGQ2FU
- jacquesm 4y agoInteresting development, but quite a few of these concerns are normally dealt with during wind park development and siting, taking care of the 'wake effect' in the prevailing wind with all machines operating is pretty much standard. The upside of this - if I understand it correctly - is that it will try to find another optimum when the wind is not from the 'ideal' direction that the park was originally designed for. So it will depend very much on how variable the winds are in a particular locality whether this will give an advantage. I'm curious how it will play out in practice when they start using it on large offshore installations for instance.
- jordz 4y agoCool. We have worked with a customer on this exact thing and deployed an edge and cloud controller that orchestrates control changes based on the all the turbines. Such a great project!
- zeristor 4y agoSiemens is the commercial part of this research group, will they restrict the use of this software to Siemans installed windows farms? It has been standard practice in most industries to co-opt any improvement into increasing the company’s stickiness. It would be a shame if it did.