5 ms·
> How does monetizing a public good for your own selfish social standing to the detriment of everyone else become freedom of expression to begin with? I'd like
by watwut 4y ago
> How does monetizing a public good for your own selfish social standing to the detriment of everyone else become freedom of expression to begin with? I'd like to know who those campaigners are.
Freedom of expression includes that and it was done for years. Photographs taking pictures or videos of public spaces and monetizing them is nothing new nor outrageous. There are local limitations, in Europe often about your ability to center other people in your pics or videos. But afaik, in USA you are free to take pictures of people or public spaces full stop.
> Somehow this has become blurred.
This was never as clear as you make it up to be. The primary difference is that too many people do it in current form and they do a lot of repetitions or include music.
Freedom of expression or speech or whatever never included the requirement to "not be selfish". Also, the limitations that EU or USA tend to put on places basically never deny specific platform. You might have to pay extra for ability to take pictures. You might be unable to use flash. It might be flat out denied to play music at some place (requirement to be silent). These are fairly normal restrictions, that dont care whether you are personally outraged over tik-tok or youtube - which is actually what makes sense.
- MichaelCollins 4y ago>Freedom of expression Even in America, you need permits in many places to film for commercial reasons. People who are making a job out of being an 'influencer' are obviously filming commercially, so I don't see anything wrong with making them get permits.
- hef19898 4y agoAnd follow all the other rules aroind commercial content creation, e.g. getting model consent before publishing. Something all pros do, and again a way where disruption is actually just another way to say that rules don't apply to you. The trickey question is so where the threshold for "commercial" activities lies.
- watwut 4y agoUSA has looser rules around taking photos of strangers then other places (like European countries tho rules there differ). In general, if it is public space, you can legally take pictures of people and use them even when they are fairly prominent in pic. The privacy limits tend to be stricter in EU, usually to Americans comains on HN. But, in the article in question, other people were not issue. More of too many repetitions and activity changing feel of the place.
- watwut 4y agoSo? How does that contradicts anything I wrote? Freedom of expression is name of a group in Nepal pushing for their things. America is utterly irrelevant (but actually public photography in America allows quite a lot). Note also how those permits literally never state "your intentions must have pure interest in place itself" as person I responded to assumes. Instead, they tend to be commercial and protecting monetary value of the place. Once you pay for permit you do whatever you please with it, unless it divides between commercial and non commercial. And they never limit platform - there are rules around flash or noise or time spend etc - you are quite clear on them from the start. Which is literally what the disagreement in article is about. Note also I disagree primary with nonsensical comments that projects their outrage over media not targeted at them existing and young people putting serious effort in them then with Nepal authorities trying to trial-and-error rules that will work.
- soco 4y agoFirst of all that "freedom" is a US constitutional thing, not defined anywhere else as such so maybe some expectations should be tuned down a bit. Secondly not even in the states does freedom of expression equate "freedom to do whatever and wherever I want" - try yelling nasty things at a biker gang and see where that gets you. But you know what is defined pretty much everywhere else? The right of property - which includes the right to ban from it whoever you feel like, without bothering even to give an explanation.
- bawolff 4y ago> try yelling nasty things at a biker gang and see where that gets you I mean,maybe they beat you up, but then they go to jail and you get a bunch of money as compensation, so i don't think this supports your point. > The right of property - which includes the right to ban from it whoever you feel like, without bothering even to give an explanation. That's generally not true. Try banning <insert specific race here> and see what that gets you. However banning obnoxious photographers from your commercial business is of course reasonable.
- drugstorecowboy 4y ago> That's generally not true. Try banning <insert specific race here> and see what that gets you. I can't speak for other countries, but in the US you are free to ban any race you like from your private residence for any reason or no reason, with or without explanation. A business has different rules but its not entirely "private" in the eyes of the law. Also I don't know where you live but were I to insult a biker gang and get beat up in the US, I would not be expecting to be compensated outside of very unusual circumstances ( the "biker gang" is composed of dentists and doctors ) you simply aren't going to be compensated by anyone for something like that aside from your own private insurance (maybe). Even if you sued this biker gang and won, collecting it would be difficult, the justice system might include restitution of some sort in the sentence but it certainly wouldn't be "a bunch of money".
- samatman 4y agoCould you explain the root of this notion that the limits of a legal right are determined by the willingness of criminals to assault you for practicing it? It doesn't make a lot of sense to me.