13 ms·
Old-school pencil-on-paper vector piloting is key to crossing the Gulf Stream
- Kon-Peki 4y agoThe takeaway is that you are sailing your boat perpendicular to a very strong current. Modern technology will try to fight/overcome it; the suggestion is to let nature exert her forces. Don’t point the boat at your destination!
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoFeels like a missing optimization in the navigation software to me. I'm assuming they already take account of predicted wind?
- nicwolff 4y agoActually the best popular software for routing that gives you course-to-steer based on wind and current is called PredictWind – the subscription that adds that feature starts at $250/year.
- jmole 4y agoThis is one of those articles where a map or graphic would speak well in excess of 1000 words.
- nicwolff 4y agoAt least the online version of the article would be brought to life with links to show the Gulf Stream https://www.windy.com/-Currents-currents?currents,25.760,-78.989,8 https://www.windy.com/-Currents-currents?currents,25.760,-78... and the current wind direction and speed https://www.windy.com/?25.760,-78.989,8 https://www.windy.com/?25.760,-78.989,8 so you can "play along" and imagine planning a crossing right now.
- melony 4y ago
- Test0129 4y agoAttaching -phobic to everything is really an injustice. The author makes no effort to say they are afraid of technology. Nor do they really hint that they are old school. Just that the technology being USED is old school. Often times, what works best for you is what you should do. There are many more complications that make flying a plane more comfortable with technology. However, we have been circumnavigating the globe without ipads for what, over a century? Sometimes pencil and paper is all you need. If it gets you home, there's no sense in learning to use fragile easily broken technology. Especially out at sea, where weather conditions could easily destroy such conveniences. You might be surprised at just how many hobbies and jobs use simple pencil and paper to do their business. In fact the article is fascinating strictly because it shows just how unnecessary bags full of the latest greatest tech are. This is no different than how programmers work. I am not language-phobic because I don't want to learn the newest greatest framework. I simply work with what gets me the best productivity.
- goodcanadian 4y agoHowever, we have been circumnavigating the globe without ipads for what, over a century? Sorry, I couldn't resist the nitpick. It is more like FIVE centuries: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magellan_expedition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magellan_expedition
- rocketbop 4y agoFrom the context, it seems clear the parent was referring to flight.
- maccard 4y agoUs doing something one way for 500 years doesn't inherently mean we should continue. Horses were the primary means of transport for 3000+ years, so should we go back to them? (We should use bikes really) An abacus worked for a similar amount of time, should we go back to that because it worked? I have no skin in the navigation game, but something working in the past isn't a good enough reason to not change.
- upsidesinclude 4y agoIn the same way that having contacts in our phones has prevented people from memorizing numbers or using digital maps weakens spatial orientation and reasoning, using autopilots and computers in navigation over time will dumb down the herd. Eventually we come to the point where no one will be able to do this simple calculation. Fortunately, for much of the professional maritime industry plotting navigational charts by hand is still standard practice
- Shorel 4y agoI have a contacts application in my phone and I memorize a few numbers still. Mainly my own number, which I actually never dial. So I had to use the contacts app to check it, and after about the fifth time, I had memorized it. By surprise, as I did not intend to do it.
- samatman 4y agoI've never had difficulty finding a number with personally mnemonic substrings. Example: my latest number has (of course) the state area code, then three numbers which are the same as my area code growing up, followed by the two-digit year I got the number, leaving me two digits of pure entropy to memorize. Do I have any other numbers memorized? Lol, I do not. It would be a good idea to memorize one number I could call from jail (things happen), but those have to be land lines, and I don't think I know anyone with one of those anymore.
- cameronh90 4y agoI remember my own number for much the same reason, but I don't remember any others. Interestingly I still remember the (long dead) numbers for my childhood friends, grandparents and parents house.
- bennyelv 4y agoThe new set of dangers that are introduced by electronic navigation should be well understood, so nothing in this article should be news to anyone who’s learnt how to navigate. That said, navigation is now so “easy” that you can get complacent. As demonstrated by this professional crew in 2014 in one of the most prestigious ocean races when they hit a reef in the pacific because they hadn’t zoomed in enough on their plotter to identify the hazard: https://www.yachtingmonthly.com/sailing-skills/electronic-charts-and-grounding-a-cautionary-tale-31042 https://www.yachtingmonthly.com/sailing-skills/electronic-ch... This is a set of circumstances where the UX of the modern device is subtly far worse than the old pen and paper way, with some quite spectacular results. Ultimately the blame falls on the navigator and the skipper, but I can’t help but feel sorry for them.
- pm215 4y agoOn a similar note, last year the UK's Marine Accident Investigation Branch published a safety study on electronic chart system use: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/application-and-usability-of-ecdis-safety-study https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/application-and-u... It's based largely on structured interviews with people who actually have to use the system, and it flags up some of the UI problems that they run into. I'm neither a mariner nor a UI designer, but I thought it was a pretty interesting report.
- LeifCarrotson 4y ago> This is a set of circumstances where the UX of the modern device is subtly far worse than the old pen and paper way, with some quite spectacular results. I understand why, when helping a user navigate from one side of a dense city to the other, a mapping app might not draw in small alleyways that would make the big picture illegible. But why in the world are tiles/pixels on the map that, if zoomed in, contain navigation hazards, shown to contain no hazards?!? Take a look at this Google Maps view of the shoals in normal view, with pale blue everywhere: https://maps.app.goo.gl/2K27Bfp9C5YN7cDu7 https://maps.app.goo.gl/2K27Bfp9C5YN7cDu7 Maybe you see two tiny landmasses, maybe your screen doesn't show them. Zoom out far enough to 20 mile tiles and they go away completely. Zoom in close and see a tiny stripe of tan land. Then turn on satellite view...Does it match what you expect to see? If the map is already as dense as possible, it makes sense to simplify the least relevant details - it should be obvious that zooming in would be useful. But if it's almost featureless, there's no reason to simplify it to be completely feature-free, that implies there's nothing at any scale! > Ultimately the blame falls on the navigator and the skipper, but I can’t help but feel sorry for them. Certainly the proximate cause and liability for the grounded vessel fall on the navigator and skipper, it was in their hands and is their responsibility, but this is an easy and understandable mistake that will be made by someone else again if the root cause - bad UI on the chart plotter - is not also addressed.
- longbrass 4y agoPrudent practice with a digital plotter includes reviewing the most current chart datum on paper or digitally and inputting potential hazards and waypoints in advance. In navigation, you can plot hazards and assign vectors as “danger bearings.” These are commonly NLT or NMT for No Less/More Than so that you know where not to point the bow when you are in the vicinity of a specific hazard. I suspect those of us who grew up using substantially worse UI in digital plotters may be better off than those completely reliant upon them.
- bryanrasmussen 4y agoTitle and subtitle are: Seamanship: How To Plot Your Course Across the Gulf Stream Old-school pencil-on-paper vector piloting is the key to crossing the Gulf Stream. But I figured the subtitle would probably be of more immediate interest to the HN crowd.