3 ms·
My objection to "the semantic web" is: 1. Semantics only have meaning in a given context. 2. "Global context" is an oxymoron. And most of the song-and-d
by jerf 15y ago
My objection to "the semantic web" is:
1. Semantics only have meaning in a given context.
2. "Global context" is an oxymoron.
And most of the song-and-dance routine about how wonderfully fantastic the semantic web will be implicitly assumes the creation of a global context, in which we all reasonably precisely agree on all the semantics of everything, and that's total pie-in-the-sky.
Recommended reading (which has the advantage of being a war story and not an exercise in theoretical handwaving): http://reprog.wordpress.com/2011/04/19/semantic-mapping-is-hard/ http://reprog.wordpress.com/2011/04/19/semantic-mapping-is-h... Also, follow those first two links down too ("the MARC format" and "Dublin Core") for full comprehension. You can't even get agreement on being what an author is between two contexts, and you think you're going to build a glorious semantic web‽ The semantic issues aren't going to get easier after that attribute....
- SoftwareMaven 15y agoGreat comment. I worked in the library industry for a very short while. An industry whose specialists are all trained metadata experts can't figure this stuff out. Of course, that is also part of the problem, but it isn't going to get easier in industries where people don't understand metadata. I lost interest when the OP hand-waved managing the metadata as just a trivial practical concern that somebody would surely magic into existence. These problems are why companies like Attensity[0] exist today. [0] http://www.attensity.com/ http://www.attensity.com/
- irickt 15y agoThis is a red herring. The shared context of two documents is the schema that they both declare and nothing more. The promise of linked data is that a lot of the relations will (and does now for example in music) allow discovery of interesting relations. As for library science, yes, it is a hard problem.
- jerf 15y agoIf declaring a schema meant that the two documents actually shared a schema, rather than just claiming they shared a schema, I wouldn't have had to post my comment, because the problem would have been long since solved and we wouldn't be awaiting the Semantic Web because it would have been here for about 10 years now. Semantics is about more than slathering tags and attributes on things; semantics is about actual, factual agreement. Merely claimed agreement isn't enough when it's generally not true. If professionals in library sciences can't get it right, the closest thing to a discipline devoted to the study of metadata, who can or will?