4 ms·
It started decades ago. It was predicted decades ago. We're living a predictable outcome. It's in the second paragraph: since 1950. So 70 years of structural pl
by ggm 4y ago
It started decades ago. It was predicted decades ago. We're living a predictable outcome. It's in the second paragraph: since 1950. So 70 years of structural planning failure to manage this problem. Across the same interval of time Italy had multiple financial and political crises, the red brigades, the resurgence of the northern league, Mussolini's daughter becoming a political reality, Berlusconi and bunga-bunga..
And the amazing saga of the seawall and how it turned into yet another giant tax dodge crime related boondoggle.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/oct/15/venice-controversial-barriers-prevent-flooding-for-second-time https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/oct/15/venice-controv...
Really, each decade there was a significant decision they could have made, and didn't: limit access and provide structural support to residents. They just decided not to decide. There were half-arsed attempts, but pretty much none of them worked. If they did rent controls and financial aide to locals at scale, they'd see a return of the venetian diaspora and probably make the problem worse.
Here's one nobody wants: move a significant amount of the relocatable artwork to Mastre, and make people want to go there. The impact of tourism spreading more widely will boost the Mastre economy, and relieve pressure inside Venice proper. That would mean construction investment, in an economy which is notoriously corrupt especially in sectors like construction.
Here's a second one which they already tried: tell the cruise ships to fuck off, and really make it happen.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/jul/13/italy-bans-cruise-ships-from-venice-lagoon-after-unesco-threat https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/jul/13/italy-bans-cru...
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoIt's like the resource curse except the resource is tourists.
- ggm 4y agoIf they sold cheap tickets at the railway station at 3am, and charged anyone else 100x the door cost they could limit the burden, alienate lots of middle class people, and create an industry for the unemployed touting the tickets. Local restauranteurs are already doing their part, charging EUR300 for speciality fish dishes and one cocktail. Everyone I know who has been to Venice enjoyed it somewhere between a bit, and immensely and none of them want to go back! Meanwhile, there is a woman's prison farm on Giudecca which I think is pretty amazing. It's like somebody took Rykers Island, and converted it to hipster organic food produce. Maybe NY state could learn a trick. The resource curse and the success overload failure are interesting problems to have. A lot of eco tourism has gone directly to gated entry. Yosemite has entry limits, so maybe we have to treat Venetians like Bison.
- rospaya 4y agoOn the other side of the Adriatic in Croatia whole cities are empty during the winter and swell 500% in population during the summer. There are no jobs except in the service sector and there's no incentive for anyone to do anything else since they can just rent apartments to tourists or open a cafe. Tourism accounts for a quarter of our GDP. We are one tanker spill or bad weather season from economic collapse.
- hedgehog 4y agoI liked Venice a lot the one time I visited, and hope to go back at some point. It would be hard to be motivated to actually move to a small town that is on a short clock to being submerged by sea level rise though, especially if moving entailed tying up money in property there. To really come back it seems to me some combination of a new non-tourism industry and a real commitment to protecting from sea level change would both be required.
- michael1999 4y agoThe city doesn’t regulate the cruise ships. The region likes the dock fees, and the city pays the price.