5 ms·
> There are ideas that are not allowed here. It would be more accurate to say that some ideas require more work here. The reasons why are open to debate.
by walterbell 4y ago
> There are ideas that are not allowed here.
It would be more accurate to say that some ideas require more work here. The reasons why are open to debate.
- spoonjim 4y agoThere are definitely ideas that are not allowed here.
- superturkey650 4y agoI can't think of any non-rulebreaking comments that would get you banned just for expressing a distasteful idea. Can you give some examples?
- mulmen 4y agoThe ideas that break the rules.
- superturkey650 4y agoThere aren't any ideas that break the rules though. Just structure, tone, and context of comments/posts.
- zmgsabst 4y agoI don’t think that’s true. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32432564 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32432564
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 4y agoTrying expressing certain looked down upon ideas politely and with a good structure, gentle tone, and within context, and see how far you go...
- NERD_ALERT 4y ago“non-rulebreaking” implies that there are rules stating that certain ideas are not allowed.
- superturkey650 4y agoNo it doesn't. The rules can be based around the effort, structure, and tone of your comments. Not the ideas expressed within them. I think the only "idea" not allowed is asking for violence and I've even seen those allowed.
- Retric 4y agoPolitics as a subject is strongly discraged on HN. It isn’t about Republican, Democrat, or Libertarian ideas it’s about their red button talking points. So you can discuss say taxes or abortion as long as you don't bring politics into it or get repetitive. What most often confuses people is you can get heavily downvoted or upvoted for expressing the same idea depending on who shows up to a given discussion about say Nuclear power, Bitcoin, etc.
- spoonjim 4y agoNo I can't, because my account would get banned. Probably under the pretext of the stated rule, "Eschew flamebait. Avoid unrelated controversies, generic tangents, and internet tropes."
- superturkey650 4y agoThose seem to be based around the relationship of the comment to the post it is in rather than any specific idea in the comment itself. As if any comment flagged for those reasons could have the same idea expressed in a relevant post and not be flagged.
- codefreeordie 4y agoThat is what the text of the rules say, but not how they actually operate.
- codefreeordie 4y ago
- codefreeordie 4y agoI tried to give you an answer. It only took about 90 seconds for my post to get deleted.
- nemo44x 4y agoI’m not sure there are ideas that aren’t allowed so much as the way you speak, structure, and present them. I’ve tested many different ideas on topics here and some have received far more positive feedback than I’d imagine and some have been buried too. I think so long as you follow guidelines generally and don’t outright attack individuals then you’re mainly ok. The community might downvote your idea to invisible but that doesn’t mean it wasn’t allowed - just that not enough people thought it was good. That’s fair.
- drusepth 4y ago>The community might downvote your idea to invisible but that doesn’t mean it wasn’t allowed This might be a nitpick, but this depends on your POV of who's allowing/disallowing content. HN itself allows a lot of comments that the collective HN community does not allow -- by downvoting them into invisibility.
- nemo44x 4y agoRight, but I do think there’s a general fairness. It isn’t as biased one way or another as any places I feel.
- zmgsabst 4y ago@dang has been explicit that they deem certain topics “inherent flame wars” and ban discussion because it upsets people. Certain ideas aren’t allowed here — even when calmly stated and cited with evidence. For example, citing the clip of the BLM founder saying she’s a “trained Marxist” would get you banned: HN was in flat out denial, even though it was her own words on film [1]. She is literally answering a question about the ideology behind BLM. Unfortunately, that kind of censorship enabled BLM to commit the fraud they did [2]. [1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YM5zUwiCTzw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YM5zUwiCTzw [2] - https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/amazon-boots-black-lives-matter-off-amazonsmile-as-scrutiny-intensifies https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/amazon-boots-black-l...
- ajross 4y agoWhat's hilarious is that this is still up three hours after posting with not even a reply. So much for censorship. You're totally allowed to post that here, even while conflating one charity with a continent-wide protest movement, one leader's out of context quote with the goals of that movement, and one enforcement action by Amazon Smile with an accusation of "fraud". For those interested in whether there's any truth in those links (there is! though maybe not nearly as juicy as promised), Wikipedia has a great overview as always: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Lives_Matter_Global_Network_Foundation#Criticism_and_disputes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Lives_Matter_Global_Netw...
- tacocataco 4y agoMaybe because it's relevant to the discussion in the thread. How many other times do you think it'd be appropriate to bring up the same topic? Probably very few, and it would get deleted if not.
- mulmen 4y agoIt was flagged and dead almost immediately then zmgsabst made another post [1] linking to the dead post and someone vouched for the dead post you see here. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32432791 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32432791
- bawolff 4y agoIf someone did a show HN, for their murder for hire app to connect assains to clients, i imagine it would (rightly) go over poorly. At least i would hope...
- acheron 4y agoDepends, did they write the website in PHP?
- iopq 4y agoUnless they wrote it in Rust, in which case it would be received with great praise
- aaaaaaaaaaab 4y agoVery funny... But have you considered the countless lives that were lost due to bugs from memory-unsafe languages over the past ~70 years? A murder-for-hire app in Rust would still cost us less lives overall, if it increases the popularity and adoption of memory-safe languages elsewhere. It's a just cause, one could say. I, for one, am very happy with how the assassination story of Rust is coming along!
- dklodh 4y agoRust has rusted all of your brains. It really does what its name says!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- geodel 4y agoI mean it makes sense. Memory safety >> Human Safety.
- rjbwork 4y agoI think it would actually probably hit the top spot if it was a legitimate attempt that used crypto, E2E, provable security, maybe TOR. There's only one example in history AFAIK and it only lasted a short while. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assassination_market https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assassination_market
- jv22222 4y agoHere's an HN bubble aspect. You can't use any title you want, for example, they will regularly edit the title and thus effectively change the general meaning of the submission as read by most folks who just skim titles. Which has the knock on effect of making the post less (or more) desirable for users to read/upvote. For example titles starting with "How I ..." are auto stripped to "I ..." there are quite a few other similar auto editorial changes. There is no way round this that I know of, so those parts of an idea are non-negotiable and not re-workable. I have seen instances where this practice completely ruins an otherwise excellent submission that would have been #1 on HN in days of old.
- swores 4y agoI'm not convinced the title rules on HN are having a major impact on which stories get upvotes on a frequent basis, but that's just my intuition and you may be massively right. In which case I urge you to, when you see an example where you think the policy has indeed had a negative effect (which I'd also suggest isn't quite as basic as "did it lower the expected number of upvotes" but also "and not because it removed clickbait from the title"), either comment mentioning dang's name and saying why you feel that, or send him an email to the same effect (hn@ycombinator.com) Not only have I often seen him engage in discussion and be open to changes for a submission when people felt a title shouldn't exactly fit HN's usual rules, but I'd also expect him to be open to changing the rules themselves if your feedback leads to his agreeing that there's a trend of submissions having the meaning of their title unfairly changed due to the generally good rules. All that said, it's not really an example of a "HN bubble", nor of an "idea" that isn't allowed on HN.
- jv22222 4y agoSuper helpful reply, thanks! I'm not on the site too much these days but will send any that I notice!