4 ms·
There are approx 5.7M vacation homes in the US. There are also approx 550,000 homeless people in the US. A system which allows such misallocation is fundamental
by kelseyfrog 4y ago
There are approx 5.7M vacation homes in the US. There are also approx 550,000 homeless people in the US. A system which allows such misallocation is fundamentally broken. If this is what effecient resource allocation looks like, then I want something else.
- californical 4y agoOne can argue that those homes wouldn’t have existed in the first place without wealthy people to commission them for vacation homes. After all, homes aren’t just built for no reason, but because someone is willing to buy it
- kelseyfrog 4y agoHow does that argument lead to more unhoused people having homes?
- marcinzm 4y agoHow does having fewer homes in total lead to more unhoused people having homes? In these comments you seem more concerned about lowering the number of vacant homes than lowering the number of homeless people. I feel that's the wrong approach.
- junofan 4y agoThe argument is that vacation homes wouldn’t exist without vacationers, not that demand for vacation homes would lead to homeless people owning houses.
- deepsun 4y agoBroken compared to what? Homelessness is an ancient problem, noone was able to solve that yet. We need to look and take lessons from systems that at least somewhat helped the problem. Of course, adjusting for the US situation, which might be just different. Compared, to, say Eastern Europe, I feel like US can just afford having so many homeless (e.g. free food and medicine for homeless in California). In many other countries homeless would not be able to survive, so in some weird sense we can call it a luxury, not a problem.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoI find it hard to believe that unhoused people would find solace in those words.
- jlmorton 4y ago> Homelessness is an ancient problem, noone was able to solve that yet. Out of curiosity, you do realize there are lots of countries without homelessness, right?
- deepsun 4y agoInteresting, I can only think of three cases: 1. Homeless were killed (e.g. nazi germany). 2. It's a family honor matter, like in Caucasus countries. There are no retirement homes as well, as every family takes the burden of taking care of their elder, because it would be very unhonorable. Although I still doubt they have 0.0% homelessness. 3. Official numbers don't reflect reality. Really curious to learn other ways to solve the problem. What those other countries you mean?
- marcinzm 4y agoEven the USSR had homeless and it was both illegal and everyone was provided housing. Crappy housing but housing nonetheless.
- carapace 4y ago> Homelessness is an ancient problem, noone was able to solve that yet. No, it's a fairly recent and entirely cultural phenomenon. For one thing, there was no homelessness at all in North America before the Seventeenth century or so.
- krschultz 4y agoAs an owner of a vacation home and a large donor to homeless charities: this is completely divorced from the reality on the ground. It's a false dichotomy proposed as a way to block solving the problem of limited housing where it's acutely needed. My ski house in Vermont does absolutely nothing for the homeless people in my neighborhood in New York. If you put someone in that ski house what would it do? Sure it would put a roof over their head, but there are no jobs, no soup kitchens, no homeless resources. They would need a car whereas in New York they can walk and use mass transit. The town in VT is already strapped supporting many in their community (I do charity there as well, and let me tell you it's more dire than much of the New York area). The solution is to house them here in the New York area where they are (and in fact New York does a better than average job of this). As for it being a misallocation, I own a $1M apartment in NYC and a $300K house in Vermont. If I just owned a $1.3M apartment in NYC my bills would be exactly the same, there would be 1 fewer "vacant house", and the homeless would still be unhoused. The real misallocation is how much I get paid as a software engineer relative to other professions of similar difficulty. I happen to spend my fun money on a ski house instead of a boat or a bunch of vacations, but there's no moral difference between a vacation home and other leisure spending. So really you are arguing that some people shouldn't have such a surplus when there are homeless people. Maybe that's true, but it's one of the most unpopular positions in American politics and if you are an ally of the homeless it's not a fruitful argument to make.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoYou seem to be focused on navigating the effects of the current system by relocating people. I'm not sure where you got this from. I'm interested in modifying the system which allows for such outcomes, not managing the outcomes themselves. Please take a systems-level approach that seeks root-cause adjustment and not simply an amelioration of symptoms.
- rewq4321 4y agoThe root cause is primarily housing policy. Let developers build many apartments, and let them build small apartments. Zoning laws that make it a years-long process to just get a permit, or that force developers to build apartments with minimum square footage, or prevent large families living in a "small" apartment - these are all luxury laws forced upon poor people so that rich people can be more comfortable. I count myself as progressive but am almost disgusted by how many progressives try to muddy the water here because they don't like to face the fact that they have to give something up to make their neighbourhood more accessible to those who are well-off people. Anyone who doesn't take housing policy seriously on the issue of homelessness is either naive, or doesn't actually care about the issue and instead is trying to use it to push some other agenda.
- marcinzm 4y agoCapitalism is very inefficient overall so it's sort of obvious that there'd be waste in all segments however at the same time it leads to better human quality of life overall than other systems we've tried. Or in other words if you waste 25% of 100% more than you're still ahead by 50%.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoSorry, but I'm not interested in engaging with capital-realists. "The best of all the bad systems" platitudes doesn't really anything for people without homes.
- marcinzm 4y agoNeither does your complaining about capitalism with no actually usable solutions to the problem of homelessness. Like I said in another post you seem to care more about hating capitalism than helping the homeless.