5 ms·
As always, blame the market for a failure of government. Government caused the crisis, and it was aided and abetted by the wealthiest people on Wall Street. A
by SwellJoe 18y ago
As always, blame the market for a failure of government. Government caused the crisis, and it was aided and abetted by the wealthiest people on Wall Street. And, with the bailout, we've insured none of the people responsible will face negative consequences for bad business practices.
And, to boot, it's being used as an example of a failure of markets. The whole sub-prime fiasco has nothing to do with markets. In a free market, government does not guarantee that a risky investment will be repaid (as has largely been the case in the home lending market since 1999). We're simply not talking about a free market. We're talking about government programs gone horribly (but predictably) awry.
- nazgulnarsil 18y agoI would go so far as to call this a false flag event. The american people are being called to rally around a stupid idea with the threat of catastrophe if we don't.
- jmtame 18y agoThe future generations will look in the history books at "societies that were greedy" and instead of advancing technology and efficiency, they stifled and discouraged it because it went against established corporate profit motives. This is about greed, and you're right in saying that government programs have caused this. The greed takes over your logic and diligent decision-making, and we end up trying to make a lot of money on things that are nothing more than speculative. And so now look at what we're doing from 40,000 feet: we're trying to instill confidence by TAXING firefighters and school teachers all over the country? Are we actually creating value? Are corporate profits going up because value has been created in the market? Is there anything really coming out of this? Is this a reason to be more confident? Is there an economical justification for "bailing out" these firms that have made poor investment decisions? Are the toxic mortgages going to magically "pay for themselves" after all of this money gets circulated? What really have we solved from any of this?
- mhartl 18y agoThis is a familiar tune. Take a heavily regulated market with massive government intervention, watch it get tied in knots, and then declare that the "free market" has failed. The most dramatic historical example is perhaps the U.S. economy leading up to the Great Depression, but we've seen plenty others in recent years: the "deregulated" energy markets in California, "free market" healthcare, and now the subprime meltdown. I'm beginning to suspect people will never learn.
- jmtame 18y agoThe US is going to need to go through a complete meltdown. A Great Depression probably wouldn't make people angry and organized enough to cause the change that we need. My prediction is that the United States won't stick around for too long (if you take a history textbook perspective on this, which you can see other failed societies have made the same mistakes that we are now repeating). I think we have a fighting chance to create the desirable society that eliminates corporatocracy. Did you know the planet contains 13,000 zettajoules of geothermal energy? The entire world uses 0.5 zettajoules of energy per year. And we can harvest this, but there are patent wars to suppress this from easily happening. Let's look at the other resources available, which cost us nothing at all. Wind? 3 states of wind energy can power the entire United States. Water? The UK alone could be powered by water/tide energy alone. Solar? One hour of thermal energy in the day could power the United States for an entire year if we harvested it properly. Travel by plane? Who does that when you could travel by AT3's mag-lev trains, which can reach speeds up to 4,000 MPH with zero moving parts and zero emissions. Oh, and it uses about 10% of the energy of an airplane. Yes, they work in land and water. What happens when technology replaces humans? You no longer need to work. In our capitalistic society, it's called unemployment. If you look into the Venus Project, it's called you get bored and start thinking about space exploration. Once people figure out that we don't really need these corporations, we'll never have this type of problem come up again. The corporations are holding us back and creating scarcity (real or perceived) at every opportunity. Like I said, I don't think the United States is going to get it right, we're in far too deep over our heads. And the attitudes and apathy of the American people never ceases to amaze me (in a bad way) as an undergraduate.
- lacker 18y agoIt's not like if you outlaw corporations, suddenly a new form of organization will appear where nobody is greedy any more. It's not like "the corporations" are sitting on the secret to infinite wind energy and they're just afraid of change. Corporations are made up of people. They are not perfect because people are not perfect and organizing large groups of people is hard. Outlawing corporations will not solve either of those problems.
- ardit33 18y agoFirst of all Fannie Mae, Freddy Mac are not the main and only contributers to this mess. You also have a lot of private capital being lost, that never went through Fannie or Freddy. AIG is not goverment's mess. They decided to insure insane amount of CDO, which are not regulated, and being used not for hedging, more like bets in the market. Lehman Bros/Bear Stearn are not governments mess. They decided to leverage themselves at an absurd 1/30+ ratio. The goverment has been staying away from them, and look what happened. Also, if you noticed, that there are banks that are actually doing really good, mainly because were smart enough to stay away from this madness. And there have also been major crashes (1929, or 1873) where the gov. was almost non-existent, and the dollar was backed by gold. For some reason, just like in reddit, there is always post "Blame the goverment about everything for over-regulating". How about blaming the individuals for taking too much credit card debt, and too many loans(may they be greedy or stupid), and the people that led these companies to ruin for once.
- SwellJoe 18y agoAIG is not goverment's mess. They decided to insure insane amount of CDO, which are not regulated, and being used not for hedging, more like bets in the market. Lehman Bros/Bear Stearn are not governments mess. They decided to leverage themselves at an absurd 1/30+ ratio. The goverment has been staying away from them, and look what happened. I don't disagree. At least not entirely. Where I disagree is in the distinction between what government should and shouldn't do, and how the "didn't do" played out in this particular disaster. If government is to take part in a free market economy, it's purpose is to enforce contracts, prevent fraud, and come down hard on those that lie, cheat or steal: trust is the most important currency in a market economy, and when it's lost, nothing works anymore. Pyramid or Ponzi schemes are illegal in the United States. Seems to me that a very strong case can be made that CDOs are merely the modern equivalent. At the very least there was significant deception happening at the point where junk debt was re-branded as quality debt, and that claims that this junk debt was "insured" against loss were simple fraud. We have laws for all of that, and in a just world, there would be consequences. But, we're talking about some of the wealthiest people on earth...consequences aren't really their style, and our government agrees with them. I'm not saying the finance industry, or a large percentage thereof, is free of blame. I'm saying it's like bike theft and the New York and San Francisco black market: it's a wholly unpunished crime, and so it is rampant. For the kind of people willing to do anything they can get away with to make money, the US government extended an open invitation to lie, cheat, and steal your way to a few million or billion bucks.