3 ms·

I don't. I want a protocol oriented network. If you're using web apps, you are already using a gazillion apps, you're just using tabs as a taskbar and one full

I don't. I want a protocol oriented network. If you're using web apps, you are already using a gazillion apps, you're just using tabs as a taskbar and one full screen window at a time. The browser becomes the OS. You're just changing where the abstraction happens, and creating a more hostile UX. Consuming content is not the only focus of the web. In my opinion, it would be better to have an application to read documents, a different application to stream media, and if there's any complex interaction it warrants its own application, so things like chat, git GUIs like github, social interactions all warrant an application. It used to be like this, you had IM, IRC, a web browser that just delivered HTML documents, things were less user hostile and easier to implement. If we had continued along with this paradigm instead of cramming everything into http and web browsers I think we would have a better web today. For one, it wouldn't be impossible to implement a do it all browser from scratch, and you'd have a more open web than we have today.

vlod 4y ago
> The browser becomes the OS. You're just changing where the abstraction happens. That's probably correct. For me, I think (for me) it's about control of content. I detest using an app for newssite-A and another for newsite-B (I don't do this), especially if they bombard me with ads, popups and dark patterns to generate their objectives. e.g. Twitter constantly messing with their stream, instagram going more towards videos. It's a cesspool and I don't know how the average (not techie) finds it acceptable. Cable TV went this way and for me unwatchable. With a browser, I can remove obnoxious ads, disable popups and fix css to my liking. Not sure if we need to have protocol per content-type. The browser kinda does this already and gives me the control.
- vlod 4y ago
  Here's an e.g. [0] of the BS that apps do: FTA: "Meta, the owner of Facebook and Instagram, has been rewriting websites its users visit, letting the company follow them across the web after they click links in its apps, according to new research from an ex-Google engineer. The two apps have been taking advantage of the fact that users who click on links are taken to webpages in an “in-app browser”, controlled by Facebook or Instagram, rather than sent to the user’s web browser of choice, such as Safari or Firefox." Sigh [0] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2022/aug/11/meta-injecting-code-into-websites-visited-by-its-users-to-track-them-research-says https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2022/aug/11/meta-inje...

vlod 4y ago

> The browser becomes the OS. You're just changing where the abstraction happens. That's probably correct. For me, I think (for me) it's about control of content. I detest using an app for newssite-A and another for newsite-B (I don't do this), especially if they bombard me with ads, popups and dark patterns to generate their objectives. e.g. Twitter constantly messing with their stream, instagram going more towards videos. It's a cesspool and I don't know how the average (not techie) finds it acceptable. Cable TV went this way and for me unwatchable. With a browser, I can remove obnoxious ads, disable popups and fix css to my liking. Not sure if we need to have protocol per content-type. The browser kinda does this already and gives me the control.

vlod 4y ago
Here's an e.g. [0] of the BS that apps do: FTA: "Meta, the owner of Facebook and Instagram, has been rewriting websites its users visit, letting the company follow them across the web after they click links in its apps, according to new research from an ex-Google engineer. The two apps have been taking advantage of the fact that users who click on links are taken to webpages in an “in-app browser”, controlled by Facebook or Instagram, rather than sent to the user’s web browser of choice, such as Safari or Firefox." Sigh [0] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2022/aug/11/meta-injecting-code-into-websites-visited-by-its-users-to-track-them-research-says https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2022/aug/11/meta-inje...