9 ms·
Vegetarian women more likely to fracture hips in later life
- giantg2 4y ago"About 90% of hip fractures are linked to falls, which are more common in older people" Well, some believe that some of those falls are actually the result of the hip fracture.
- somewhereoutth 4y agoIt appears incontrovertible that it is harder (but not impossible) to have a nutritionally complete diet without meat, and particularly without dairy either. It appears also incontrovertible that the additional components required to complete such a diet are expensive to produce (in terms of energy and high quality arable land) and likely cannot be scaled to any significant proportion of the population.
- spicymaki 4y agoVegetarian diets are not expensive even with meat/dairy being subsidized ($38B/year in US). Vegetarians need to make sure they exercise and consume high quality plant proteins: vegetables, nuts, legumes, beans and whole grains and keep a normal BMI. Meat eaters have the opposite issue: too much protein and fat leading to heart disease (#1), cancer (#2), stroke (#5) and diabetes (#8). Hip fractures do not even chart.
- jononomo 4y agoAlmost everyone thinks this, but I don’t. I have come to believe that a person’s risk for heart disease, cancer, stroke, and high blood pressure will all be reduced by switching to a 100% red meat diet. If anyone actually cares, they can read The Big Fat Surprise by Nina Teicholz to learn about nutrition science.
- spicymaki 4y agoThere is a good reason why everyone thinks that. The evidence is overwhelming that consuming meat increases your chances of heart disease and stroke[1]. Nina Teicholz does not have any medical or nutrition science training or credentials[2]. Even if she did she would need to amass an extreme amount of evidence over long periods of time. Red meat is considered carcinogenic.[3][4] Red meat is directly associated with high blood pressure[5] Low fiber diets e.g. 100% red meat is associated with constipation, irritable bowel syndrome (IBS), diverticulitis, heart disease and some cancers (including bowel)[6]. [1] https://www.nih.gov/news-events/nih-research-matters/eating-red-meat-daily-triples-heart-disease-related-chemical https://www.nih.gov/news-events/nih-research-matters/eating-... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nina_Teicholz https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nina_Teicholz [3] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2121650/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2121650/ [4] https://www.cancer.gov/news-events/cancer-currents-blog/2021/red-meat-colorectal-cancer-genetic-signature https://www.cancer.gov/news-events/cancer-currents-blog/2021... [5] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2658466/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2658466/ [6] https://www.betterhealth.vic.gov.au/health/healthyliving/fibre-in-food https://www.betterhealth.vic.gov.au/health/healthyliving/fib...
- jononomo 4y ago
- ziddoap 4y agoThis is news to the medical establishment, have you published a paper? CDC, Mayo Clinic, NIH, etc. all claim that the exact cause of Type 2 diabetes is unknown, although it is known that lifestyle and genetics both play roles. While what you said might be partially related, it is most certainly not "entirely caused by eating excessive bread and sugar".
- jononomo 4y agoThis is not news to the medical establishment, although not everyone in the medical establishment is fully caught up on the news: https://reversingdiabetesmd.com/ https://reversingdiabetesmd.com/
- ziddoap 4y agoYeah, that definitely stacks up against the literally thousands of doctors in the establishments I mentioned, and the dozens to hundreds of peer-reviewed papers on the subject. Hard pass.
- jononomo 4y agoIt was hundreds of years before doctors stopped using leaches...
- ziddoap 4y agoThe standards and methodologies which led us away from using leeches are the same standards and methodologies that have led to the overwhelming conclusion by every reputable health organization that type 2 diabetes is not caused solely because you ate too much bread. That argument works in my favor, not yours.
- mixedCase 4y agoProtein and fat causing those issues is baloney. Metabolic heart disease is caused by small LDL particle size creating plaques , and a low carb diet fixes that. I'm not going to blame carbs on that one, but cutting them out does either directly or indirectly help. Nitrites and nitrates used for cured meats are the carcinogenic you have to worry about, not meat. It is a good thing to point out, not an argument against general meat consumption. No idea about stroke factors, won't comment on that. The mere suggestion that something with the glycemic index of meat causes diabetes is laughable.
- neuralRiot 4y agoPerhaps if 80% of edible crops weren’t feed to livestock and subsidies were removed from animal agriculture then those will be no-issues. I find appealing that anyone on HN being a progressive and open-minded public with an objective opinion would be promoting an environmentally destructive industry like the animal AG.
- somewhereoutth 4y agoMost animal feed is in fact not edible - that is my point, animals are very good at converting stuff you can grow anywhere (like grass), stuff that wouldn't give you much nutrition beyond carbs (wheat?), and stuff you wouldn't like to eat anyway (like left overs from the brewing industry). Replacing animals in our food chain without mass starvation/malnutrition would appear to be impossible.
- neuralRiot 4y agoAnimals are not “magic machines” the protein on their bodies comes from the food they eat. The only magic machines are plants that turn water, minerals and light into food. http://ussoy.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/consumption-1.jpg http://ussoy.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/consumption-1.jp...
- jononomo 4y agoWhat's your point? Humans can't eat grass, but cows can eat grass and then human's can eat cows. Think of a pasture as a "lab" and a cow as "lab-grown meat" if it makes you feel better.
- neuralRiot 4y agoHonestly, do you think that 2 billion cows can be fed grass only? There’s no viable way to keep meat consumption at the current levels feeding them grass.
- 4y ago
- User23 4y agoHeavy resistance exercise, for example power lifting, is an excellent way for women (and men too!) to significantly increase their bone density. I've personally confirmed this with a DEXA scan as has everyone else I lift with that got a DEXA scan too. I don't see why the same effect couldn't be achieved on a vegetarian diet, if nutrients and micronutrients were adequate.
- sokoloff 4y agoI wonder to what extent the standard American diet results in obesity results in on-going, daily power-lifting as people just move about and if this effect is strong enough to appear as “vegetarians more likely to fracture hips”.
- jononomo 4y agoIt would be easy to observe this if thin meat-eaters broke their hips as often as vegetarians do. In fact, people who ONLY eat red meat will find it LITERALLY IMPOSSIBLE to be overweight. Try eating only steak, eggs, and sardines for a year and then check the state of your six-pack abs if you’re curious.
- gassiss 4y ago> In fact, people who ONLY eat red meat will find it LITERALLY IMPOSSIBLE to be overweight. This is such an absurd statement. There's many factors around gaining weight, but it all boils down to simple how many calories you spent vs how much you eat. There's no magical "eat however much you want" diet that it's impossible to gain weight on
- jononomo 4y agoYou’re just wrong on this. The calories-in-calories-out thing doesn’t work since the nutrient profiles of different kinds of calories effect the body’s calorie-burn-rate. But you wouldn’t be the first one to tell me I’m wrong without actually trying the diet and seeing for yourself whether you gain or lose weight on it. Also, consider the fact that some calories will result in hormonal signals in your body that increase your hunger, whereas other calories will result in hormonal signals that decrease your hunger. Your body needs nutrients, not just calories — that’s why we can’t just drink gasoline and call it a day. Actually, that’s a good question for you — why is it that people can’t just drink gasoline, since it contains calories? Do you think a person would gain weight if they only drank gasoline and didn’t exercise enough? Do you think a person would feel hungry again just a couple hours after drinking some gasoline?
- coldtea 4y agoIt's not like they weren't warned
- jononomo 4y agoI consumed exactly zero plant-based calories during all of 2021 — no alcohol, no plant-based cooking oil — NOTHING from a plant. I ended the year in about the best shape of my life — and now that I understand nutrition better I plan to get back on that plan (trying to be “moderate” this year has been underwhelming). Basically, meat makes you healthy and plants make you fart, give you dry skin, and don’t do anything at all for your musculature. All the vitamins, minerals, and micronutrients are more highly available in animal-based foods than they are in plant-based food, and the macronutrient profile is basically ideal for human health as well. It honestly makes me sad that so many people incorrectly think that red meat is not healthy. Red meat is in fact the most nutritious food you can eat and it is an ABSOLUTE TRAGEDY that this is not more widely understood.
- FrankyHollywood 4y agoSo no vitamine c intake? Wouldn't recommend it on the long term https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scurvy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scurvy
- jononomo 4y agoI have addressed this point elsewhere in this thread, and it has also been explained ten thousand times on forums such as https://reddit.com/r/carnivore https://reddit.com/r/carnivore The long and the short of it is that fresh meat contains vitamin C and the carnivore diet also reduces your body's need for vitamin C because vitamin C is used for the synthesis of collagen and you will be getting collagen directly by following this diet. You can read more here: https://www.kevinstock.io/health/do-humans-need-vitamin-c/ https://www.kevinstock.io/health/do-humans-need-vitamin-c/
- FrankyHollywood 4y agoAh never knew meat contains vitamin c, seems to be mostly in the liver. Well it's an interesting experiment going on meat and see how the body responds.
- Mildlypolite 4y ago*carnivorous humans more likely to destroy their planet through climate change.
- lock-the-spock 4y agoInteresting study but the authors themselves highlight many limitations which the journalists sadly did not take note if, e.g. https://bmcmedicine.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12916-022-02468-0 https://bmcmedicine.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s1291... > The single questionnaire administered at recruitment was the only method of assessing diet and lifestyle information; therefore, we could not account for changes in the diet group or covariates over time. Additionally, food and nutrient intake in vegetarians in recent years could differ from when data were collected at recruitment due to changes over the last two decades in the availability of vegetarian food products, such as increases in the number of available meat substitute products [49]. Consequently, the generalisability of our findings to modern-day vegetarians is reduced. But for me more striking are some things that are not explicitly checked, e.g. they excluded from their data those that had prior hip problems and the meat eaters were on average significantly older - could there be some selection? Also studies seem to get somewhat different results depending on the exact data: > Other epidemiological studies have found that adherence to diets low in meat consumption, such as the Mediterranean diet and Alternative Healthy Eating Index, was protectively associated with hip fracture risk [33, 34], and adherence to Western diets in which meat consumption is high was positively associated with hip fracture risk [35]. Conversely, total meat intake has been inversely associated with hip fracture risk [21]. These results cannot be fairly compared with risks in vegetarians and non-vegetarians, which no other study has directly assessed. Most interesting is this table: https://bmcmedicine.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12916-022-02468-0/figures/1 https://bmcmedicine.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s1291... What is not clear to me is how the final % is reached as those that died during the 20 year study period are taken into account up to their death. So a woman died of cancer at year 10 gives 10 years of 'no hip fractures to the pool of years while a woman that lived throughout the study If I do a simple division of cases divided by person years I get the following "annual chance of hip fracture": * Regular meat-eater: 394 / 252610 = 0.1559‰ * Occasional meat-eater: 247 / 145639 = 0.1695% * Pescetarians: 80 / 74077 = 0.1079% * Vegetarian/vegan: 101 / 84042 = 0.1202% In words: pescetarians have the lowest annual chance of hip fractures (11/10.000), followed by vegetarians (12/10.000). Meat eater have the highest chance of fractures, with occasional meat-eaters (17/10.000) having a higher chance than regular meat-eaters (16/10.000). Unless I read this data VERY wrong the chance of fractures is much lower for vegetarians and vegetarians than meat eaters.