3 ms·
IPFS isn't fit for purpose. It needs censorship-resistance added. It needs user privacy added. Both of those could be enabled by combining data blocks semi-r
by londons_explore 4y ago
IPFS isn't fit for purpose.
It needs censorship-resistance added. It needs user privacy added.
Both of those could be enabled by combining data blocks semi-randomly. Ie. rather than downloading the data you're looking for, you download a block of data containing what you're looking for and some other data. Then nobody knows what it was you were looking at. Some combined blocks might contain a few bytes of data from thousands of files.
For censorship resistance, rather than users pinning individual files, the network needs to assign them blocks they must store (or be kicked off the network). Some of those blocks will be combined blocks which contain a few bytes some users may not wish to store - and that's fine, it means IPFS isn't for them.
Remember that data can be encrypted by content hash, so there is no way to know what you're storing unless you go scouring the public internet for a key to decrypt it.
- sneak 4y agoipfs is a transport, not a storage system. you don't store things "on ipfs" any more than you store things "on http". http and tcp, other transport systems, also do not have censorship resistance. it's the wrong place for it. you can use ipfs to build a censorship resistant system, just like you can with tcp, but that is the purview of a higher layer.
- londons_explore 4y agoA new version of IPFS would be both transport system and storage. I don't think it's possible to reasonably to maintain layering while adding privacy and censorship resistance.
- vorpalhex 4y agoThis is sort of being upset at your mop because it makes a bad vacuum. These goals are not directly part of ipfs.
- hickimsedenolan 4y agoOr you could just use Freenet, thus not re-inventing the wheel.
- trumpablehump 4y ago> you download a block of data containing what you're looking for and some other data That IPFS does NOT put data I did not explicitly requested on my storage is exactly why I feel comfortable using it compared to some other distributed storage systems where I might end up with horrific data on my system.
- londons_explore 4y agoExcept you'd only have the keys for your data... And encrypted data you don't have the key for is indistinguishable from random noise. 'Combined' blocks that you don't know which partner blocks are necessary for decoding are likewise useless. You're being like a mailman handling mail - you can't look into the mail, so you can't know if you're delivering love letters, junkmail, or terrorist propaganda.
- sliken 4y agoWhile true, if the government downloads objectionable/illegal data and they detect that 10% of that data is coming from your IP address you'll likely have a very bad day. Sure weeks or months later you might convince a judge and/or jury that you had no access or control to that data, and you might even get your laptops, desktops, and external storage back. ISPs and USPS have common carrier protection, by default a home user does not.
- acdha 4y agoThis is such a key point that people forget: this isn’t some academic game theoretical debate but rather a question of how your actions will be perceived by society. If your IP is used to serve illegal content, saying “well actually, …” isn’t a defense and it most likely means you’re getting charged as an accessory to whatever that stranger did. Even if you can avoid legal penalties after years and significant expense, your reputation will be linked.
- risyachka 4y agoI am not a legal expert but shouldn't the prosecutor prove that you knew about the content? Because if yes, this is basically impossible.
- k__ 4y agoIsn't Filecoin Protocol Labs' solution to the cencorship problem?
- chriswarbo 4y ago> that's fine, it means IPFS isn't for them. This sentiment also applies to your argument, i.e. IPFS isn't fit for your purpose; and that's fine, it means IPFS isn't for you. There are a whole bunch of censorship-resistant, plausibly-deniable systems out there (e.g. I run FreeNet from time to time)
- ajconway 4y ago> Both of those could be enabled by combining data blocks semi-randomly. Ie. rather than downloading the data you're looking for, you download a block of data containing what you're looking for and some other data What you're looking for is Oblivious Transfer or Mix Nets. Unfortunately, no practical solutions currently exist (except for Onion Routing). > Remember that data can be encrypted by content hash, so there is no way to know what you're storing unless you go scouring the public internet for a key to decrypt it. Censorship does not work this way. First, content that requires censorship resistance is usually public, otherwise one can employ a number of p2p or centralized solutions to share content directly. Public content is easy to find, so step one: you find and identify the list of nodes that serve the content. Step two: you block the nodes on a level that's available to you (depends on the country). Step three: your users are unable to use the network effectively, because half of the nodes don't work, and revert to using Facebook.