12 ms·
There aren't that many uses for blockchains
- voz_ 4y agoGood little writeup. There really is no real world use case for them. Glad to see the crypto fad ending.
- seibelj 4y agoCrypto has been rallying like all speculative assets. If crypto was like beanie babies (as HN group think says) it would have crashed years ago and stayed dead.
- vkou 4y agoIt's not beanie babies, most of it is more like a ponzi scheme, which tend to be financial perpetual motion machines.
- voz_ 4y agoThanks for accusing me of group think! To turn the tables around, the burden of proof is on crypto to be useful, not on me. Stuff is not useful by default. So, instead of stooping to your insults, let me ask you - what use does it have? Also, I found you online, you work for crypto, pretty dishonest of you to not disclose that before commenting.
- petesergeant 4y ago> it would have crashed years ago Markets are capable of staying irrational a very long time
- timdaub 4y agoHN has stayed irrational longer than crypto that's for sure
- koonsolo 4y agoI saved this especially for people like you: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31998722 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31998722
- lern_too_spel 4y agoThe law could easily shut him down, so crypto isn't a solution either.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- koonsolo 4y agoSure, a law could state it's illegal, but that surely wouldn't shut him down.
- tim333 4y agoIs it ending? It kind of has a habit of not actually doing so https://99bitcoins.com/bitcoin-obituaries/ https://99bitcoins.com/bitcoin-obituaries/ Crypto actually works kind of great as a speculative casino. If you think that isn't a real world use case then you may have a rather rose tinted view of the world.
- russnes 4y agoThe blockchain is the solution to a specific problem Bitcoin has, so when people and businesses were saying "we like blockchain but not Bitcoin", it just didn't make any sense. The problem is how to be able to synchronize an ever-growing database across an unlimited number of peers, and the answer is "through chunks we call blocks".
- anton_ai 4y agoThis, blockchain is crypto and crypto is blockchain. It is a clever way to bypass a central authority and trust the crowd.
- TomSwirly 4y agoNo, thank you, I'd rather put my trust in elected officials who are at least answerable to the people than to an anonymous crowd.
- tromp 4y agoBlocks are not needed to sync a growing transation database, as exemplified with Mimblewimble blockchains, whose sync just downloads the UTXO set and list of all transaction kernels.
- influxmoment 4y agoCorrect. Blockchains are for validation not data storage
- bmitc 4y agoI’m not a fan of crypto currencies and markets, but is there not a use case for a distributed ledger? It is my understanding that that’s all a blockchain really is.
- olalonde 4y agoThe thing is you can't have a decentralized ledger without a native currency. Without a native currency, you lose the mechanism that secures the ledger (mining).
- ETH_start 4y agoThe remittance example doesn't even touch on use of stablecoins, which at the moment, are substantially easier to do international remittance with than bank deposits. I wrote a list of other use cases where blockchain-based systems are clearly more efficient than centralized ones: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32393892 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32393892 With respect to stocks, yes companies can maintain their own list of shareholders, but publishing that list to the blockchain standardizes the process of third party verification. The ERC20 token standard is widely adopted with tens of millions of installed wallets, and major blockchain explorers, that can interact with any ERC20 token contract. The activity the author briefly touches upon - trading - can also be made massively more efficient with a public blockchain. Being able to swap between any two tokens in the world using nothing more than Uniswap and your browser-based MetaMask wallet, is in most aspects a major UX improvement over the status quo, and thus it's perhaps not surprising that Uniswap has overtaken the top centralized exhanges in liquidity depth for several major trading pairs: https://uniswap.org/blog/uniswap-v3-dominance https://uniswap.org/blog/uniswap-v3-dominance I suspect the author has never used stablecoins, or Uniswap, and if they had, they would come away with a completely different take on the potential utility of blockchain-based systems. The big risk for blockchain based systems right now is the prospect of governments massively restricting internet freedoms to stop end users from transacting freely and privately without intermediaries. The US Treasury placing an autonomous software program - Tornado Cash - on its list of sanctioned entities (a list intended to comprise people and organizations, not software), and thereby making it illegal for any American to interact with this smart contract, was the dramatic opening salvo in such a war on internet freedoms. To think that any US based person sending ETH to the TC smart contract from their MetaMask wallet, to gain privacy for their blockchain activity, now potentially faces years in the US prison system for that action, is extremely disturbing. And this sort of draconianism is ultimately what the large public sector entities need to resort to keep their income-tax-dependent system alive in the age of distributed financial systems. The question is whether the public will accept their argument that crypto is so evil, that these sorts of curtailments of internet freedom are a price worth paying to stop it.
- RandomLensman 4y agoOne of the users of TC was an affiliate of the DPRK, was it not? So this isn't just about "transacting freely and privately without intermediaries". If you want to change sanction policy, might need to go down the policy route, I think.
- rapsacnz 4y agoI'm waiting for a nice github repo called "You might not need Blockchain". I kind of am actually. I heard someone trying to convince a credulous interviewer why blockchain would be the perfect solution for a bike register to prevent theft. The whole time I was thinking this could be solved by a plain old database hosted by a trusted third party.
- numtel 4y agoBlockchains are an alternative pricing model for data hosting. Instead of a monthly bill, the transaction fee gets the data stored forever-ish. As scaling techniques are implemented, this makes more applications suitable for storing data on chain. https://newgeocities.com/webmaster/blog/applications.html https://newgeocities.com/webmaster/blog/applications.html
- petesergeant 4y agoTo what do you attribute the fact that this isn’t widely used? Simply inertia?
- influxmoment 4y agoProbably a scam. Blockchains aren't for storing data
- atemerev 4y agoWell, there is one use: money (private irreversible transactions in adversarial environment). Which is good enough for me.
- petesergeant 4y agoWhat use do you currently have for private irreversible transactions in an adversarial environment, or is this simply short-hand for illegal money transfers?
- hef19898 4y agoAll transaction should be, at least legally and after a court decision, reversible. All those blockchain transactions are also covered by local law, including taxes. Bein "annonymous" means that those laws can be circumvented. Seems to be a feature, even if I see it as a bug.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- olalonde 4y ago"What use do you currently have for encrypted HTTP, or is this simply short-hand for illegal file transfers?"
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- atemerev 4y agoI can work as a consultant with clients anywhere in the world, for example. It is significantly more difficult to be employed by a company in another country (and many “remote” and contractor positions are increasingly becoming “US-only” in the current conditions). So yes, I have quite a lot of uses for crypto money in adversarial environment, and I expect it will have to use it even more, for perfectly legal work.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- littlecranky67 4y agoMy personal stance on why Blockchain is often not required is that a core feature of the Blockchain - decentralization( based on a lack of trust on a single entity) is not needed in the business world. In business, trust is an essential factor by which you pick your partners and suppliers, and often businesses reject cheaper offers in favour of business partners they know and trust based on past cooperations.
- hansworst 4y agoIsn’t this an argument for blockchains? If you could rely on blockchains instead of trusting based on past cooperation, you could save money and thus add more value. Obviously blockchains have a cost, but in some cases the cost savings you could achieve may outweigh that.
- rullelito 4y agoBitcoin can't make up for lack of trust in your business partner.
- konschubert 4y agoThe blockchain can prove that I bought the car and own it now. But that has never been the problem. Trust is still required because I need to trust the seller that the car isn't a lemon and he didn't put explosives into the back seat. The blockchain solves none of that.
- whatisweb3 4y agoThe author falls into the same trap as many others who write about blockchains: “people will build centralized apps on top of the decentralized protocol, so there is no need for the decentralized protocol in the first place!” A better way to understand blockchains is as a base settlement layer: they are a shared, permissionless and open source protocol that is resistant to takeover by a single entity. What this means is that a company, like Meta or Coinbase or even a US bank, can build a centralized platform that lets users manage their crypto assets. But as long as users can still withdraw into a non custodial address, they have the option to escape to that neutral base layer. This is a different design than what we see currently in the web and banking sector. You can hold ETH or an ENS domain with nothing but a private key. But with a .com domain, if you want to withdraw from GoDaddy, you will be forced to transfer that into another centralized service like Namecheap that will also extract rent. There is no “neutral base layer” with traditional digital assets.
- adament 4y agoAssuming you are allowed to transfer into the base layer. Most currencies and finance have a similar decentralized base layer: Cash. However in many jurisdictions your ability to transfer into that base layer is severely restricted due to money laundering, anti-terror-financing and / or currency-control regulation.
- derefr 4y agoThis is not guaranteed as a general property of blockchain systems, but can be guaranteed on a case-by-case basis by the immutable nature of smart-contract systems. I.e., if a centralized system sets up a lockup contract such that value can be forcibly unlocked by making a request on the blockchain side, and the centralized system just has to observe the event and deal with that — then for the company running the centralized system, that contract becomes an immutable part of "the way things are"; they can't decide to later renege on it, keeping people's funds locked up, because nothing can change the working of the [non-upgradable] contract once deployed — it just "is what it is." By deploying such an immutable contract to be the custodian of customer funds, such an entity is essentially making a hard/inescapable precommitment to doing for users, whatever the contract happens to do. In a sense, the central entity's owner is not the true custodian of people's locked funds; rather, the contract itself is, and the contract can be independently audited by anyone who cares, before anyone begins using it, to prove that it will only ever be able to act in the public interest, rather than in the corporation's interest.
- SkyMarshal 4y agoGood writeup. It's amusing to me all the VCs and developers running around trying to find the "killer app" for blockchains, somehow not realizing that reinventing money is the most killer app possible.
- blaaaaa99a 4y agothe killer app for VCs is flipping tokens for 100x profits onto retail investors. for everyone else, the killer app is bitcoin.
- yashg 4y agoVCs know blockchain has no use case. They are only in it to flip the tokens to starry eyed idiots and make most of their money back without a real IPO or dilution.
- Joel_Mckay 4y agoHyperledger can offer a chain of authenticated data ownership transfers, and has several use-cases outside the classical database approaches. It does however solve key logistics issues with distributed inventory ownership transfer involving 3rd parties. For example, Walmart has successfully deployed a blockchain system, and reported good performance of the technology under high-volume stress. This is one of those edge cases most will never encounter unless they are handling millions of transactions an hour. It's a good problem to have though... =)
- konschubert 4y agoCan you explain to me why Walmart could not have used a normal database? They don't need trustlessness, they have a root source of trust.
- MisterBastahrd 4y agoWalmart is one of the world's most sophisticated supply chain management companies. They use a private blockchain network to automatically reconcile invoices and payments. There are entire companies that make REALLY good money today that basically reconcile invoices for trucking fleets. Their blockchain technology does all that work for free, and as a result, they spend far less human hours chasing down data to ensure that the invoices are correct. It creates the paper trail for you automatically.
- majewsky 4y agoOkay, but what does the blockchain do exactly? You can have all that with traditional databases and asymmetric signatures. My suspicion is that all these benefits were just from traditional process improvements, but the suits only approved the expense once someone slapped "blockchain" on the Powerpoint slide to sufficiently bamboozle them.
- konschubert 4y agoThe Matt Levine Theory of Blockchain
- chrstphrknwtn 4y ago“despite the passage of time, Bitcoin and blockchain technologies have a kind of permanently nascent feel to them - as though widespread adoption is forever just around the corner” This perfectly describes how I have felt about VR since the late nineties.
- onion2k 4y agoI don't think you can judge the validity of an idea, or a technology, or anything really by looking at its (perceived) failures. The fact you don't think blockchains don't work for bank transfers, shares, currency, contracts, or whatever else doesn't mean they aren't useful. It just means no one has found a use that you think is appropriate yet, or they haven't persuaded you that you're wrong about any of the things you don't like. The one thing that gives me a ray of hope about blockchain is git. A git repo is a very similar to a blockchain. It has blocks, and each block has a payload, and they're all chained together in a way that allows distributed additions. git looks, walks, and quacks like a blockchain. It's just lacking the consensus bit really. As someone who would gladly apply git to practically every problem in tech it makes me think that blockchains could be really damn useful if only people would stop trying to pretend they're the future of money.
- qaq 4y agoI think you actually outlined the main problem outside of crypto there are very few use cases where you need actually need the "consensus" bit.
- thraxil 4y agoAlso that "the consensus bit" isn't a small thing that you just tack on to an existing system for very little cost. That bit turns something really efficient and widely applicable like git, merkle trees, etc. into a vastly more complicated and inefficient system.
- qaq 4y agofor 0 gain in 99% of use-cases
- TomSwirly 4y ago> I don't think you can judge the validity of an idea, or a technology, or anything really by looking at its (perceived) failures. What a really strange idea. Of course you can. What better way is there to judge a technology other than its failures and successes? > It just means no one has found a use that you think is appropriate yet, It's been 14 years. Cryptocurrencies are only eighteen months younger than the cell phone. We've had 14 years of promises and so far, nothing. Why would any rational person believe you?
- jaimehrubiks 4y agoThe most amazing feature of Blockchain is the anonymity provided by monero/zcash/tornado etc. However it's being banned by governments because it can be used to launder money.
- drewcoo 4y agoNo. It's being banned because it threatens governments. Governments don't really care much about laundering money.
- est 4y agomerkle tree is the underlining technology of blockchain And the most popular usable of merkle tree? Git.
- drewcoo 4y agoFor decades we've had cipher block chaining. Decades! I don't know why it's so special now. Please do not use authoritative use of git as a proof for the value of "crypto."
- jnwatson 4y agoDigital signatures is the underlying technology of blockchain. And the most popular use of digital signatures? Application integrity and authenticity. Git is a perfect answer why blockchain is almost never the answer. It implements an immutable distributed log, just without the mutually distrusting part, and does it for a millionth of the computational resources.
- waspight 4y agoWhat if bitcoins got disallowed as a currency in most places where you can use it to buy things. Would ransomware go away in that case? I imagine that if the possibility to have anonymous payments disappear, it would be much harder to target regular people with ransomware as well.
- bjarneh 4y ago> What if bitcoins got disallowed as a currency in most places where you can use it to buy things. Places where bitcoin is rarely accepted as currency (like Norway where I'm living), does not make it "unpopular" for ransomware (or other anonymous digital payments). As long as someone accepts it as payment, it will always be popular in that type of scenario. I dislike the idea that anonymous digital payments are inherently bad; since they can be used for criminal transactions; which I often see here at HN. Being anonymous should not be a crime.
- khazhoux 4y agoAt our startup we use a hybrid mechanism. Whenever a user makes a transaction on our app, it gets processed on our standard AWS-hosted postgres database, but then one of our engineers gets into his old truck and drives around the block for an hour or two. This gives us the fast, cheap, and reliable performance of a regular database, with comparable energy usage to a blockchain.
- zhdc1 4y agoThis comment shouldn't be flagged. The OP makes a very valid point with satire which, in this case, is relevant. Proof of work blockchain is horribly energy-inefficient. It's hard to justify it - on a number of grounds - as a solution for a large majority of legitimate use cases.
- koonsolo 4y agoBurning coal is also not really nice for the environment, so maybe we should all stop using electricity? I hope you get my satire as well.
- zhdc1 4y ago> Burning coal is also not really nice for the environment, so maybe we should all stop using electricity? We should, in fact, consider phasing out coal power generation. Which is what almost every OECD country has been doing for more than a decade: https://ukcop26.org/end-of-coal-in-sight-at-cop26/ https://ukcop26.org/end-of-coal-in-sight-at-cop26/.
- koonsolo 4y agoSo why are we still talking about PoW then? It seems you didn't get my point.
- zhdc1 4y ago> So why are we still talking about PoW then? Outside of speculation and regulatory evasion, has there been a sufficient use-case for Bitcoin and other proof of work chains that justify the costs, inconvenience, and disruptive impacts that go along with it?
- olalonde 4y agoIt's weird to see such a widely used technology dismissed as not being useful (it seems we get those articles weekly on HN). There are literally millions of users and billions of dollars worth of value transacted daily[0] but this is just not good enough evidence for the critics. If they can't find a use case that satisfies them, then surely everyone else using it is just wrong. [0] About $3.5B daily for Bitcoin.
- zhdc1 4y agoThere are $146B USD of daily transactions that go through the automated clearing house (ACH) system. While Visa doesn't give a daily transaction amounts, going off of sources online, in 2018, it looks like they processed around or slightly more than 1B credit and debit transactions with an average value of $80. $3.5B in daily transactions is nothing to sneeze at, but it's a relatively (very) small slice of the monetary system.
- olalonde 4y agoIndeed, Bitcoin is still relatively small. Its money supply (aka "market cap") isn't even 2.5% of the USD M1 money supply. Not to count all other fiat currencies.
- zhdc1 4y agoThat it's even grown to be even that large is surprising.
- olalonde 4y agoHonestly, when I first heard of it in ~2011 I never expected it to grow as much as it did. I thought it would probably remain a small experiment confined to nerds and hackers. When it first started hitting mainstream news a few years later I was quite amazed. And while I'm here amazed at how far it got, critics are dismissing it because it hasn't replaced USD yet...
- 5350-uiop-1130 4y agowasn't the original purpose of BTC blockchain made as decentralised payment gateway? since, that failed, or became impractical it seems people now trying to come up with contrived use-cases as a means to dump a bunch of shitty tokens on greedy retail investors if vitalik wanted he could create a new chain buterinchain, press a single keystroke to mint 1,000,000 tokens and those tokens would instantly be worth 10s or 100s of $, without any use-case. it's just a joke.
- timdaub 4y agoPeople here on HN are such NPCs when it comes to blockchain. Yaah sure cite another times that VISA has more tx volume or whatever. I've been working more than seven years in this tech and don't let yourself be deceived - wide scale PKI and immutability of storage is very useful for lots of things. Sure, 99% of all projects are shitcoins. But it changes nothing about the core tech. E.g. there are people building quietly the new software supply chain package managers with fully content-addressable and re-producible builds where all hashes are stored onchain to be immutable. But yeah, it's not a VC funded milliondollar project so people can't be happy/angry about it
- actionfromafar 4y agoI want to be happy/angry about it, it sounds actually exciting. Tell me more. Reminds me of how Phoenix BIOS was reversed engineered from the IBM BIOS, and the documentation between documentation team and programmer was entirely written and attested, for legal purposes.
- timdaub 4y agoHappy that you're interested. Sadly though, as this community has decided to not have a neutral stance towards new technology, I doubt these efforts will ever be talked about. Instead, the algorithm will serve up a few more NPC-compatible "blockchain is bad" posts. Bon appetite
- mkl95 4y agoThe blockchain as understood today is a sloppy idea plagued with even sloppier implementations. 100% of the blockchain's legit use cases can be solved with free software that predates it.
- timdaub 4y ago- OFAC just sanctioned Tornado Cash which enabled truly private digital cash equivalent - HN: "There aren't that many uses for blockchain" - Is privacy considered not a use case anymore? Who here is still following PG advice? Has anyone talked to *their users* recently? Because privacy is a pretty good use case!
- lern_too_spel 4y agoIt sounds like privacy isn't a good use case because it can be shut down so easily.
- syl_sau 4y agoIt seems to me that this whole issue is fairly simple: does the blockchain technology solve any real-world problem that people have? A mere analysis of its logic says it does not, actually, solve any meaningful problem whatsoever. Secure transactions are already feasible, it doesn't prevent mischief and the way to settle a dispute is always the same (through the legal system) and decentralization prevents it from scaling. C. Muratori puts it more elegantly than I do: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kbYutOsrpvs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kbYutOsrpvs
- koonsolo 4y agoHere is a recent post on HN where the person requires crypto donations. If you have a better solution, please let us know. If not, then I guess crypto does have a use-case. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31996612 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31996612
- syl_sau 4y agoI agree, it's probably the one use-case where it can be useful and ease the process: funding things anonymously as to circumvent the scope of the law/avoid the eyes of the authorities, far easier with Monero really. This includes funding politically persecuted individuals as well as buying drugs or other things. After all it's mostly what it's been used for (if we ignore speculation), though so far mostly through BTC and the dark web networks of obfuscation.
- zmmmmm 4y agoFound this less convincing than expected. They seem to mostly base the criticism on (a) it's cheaper to use non-blockchain equivalent for the use cases they could think of, and (b) some point in the blockchain equivalent process generates a need to trust another party. It seems to me that block chains will win at the things they are good for a bit the way git won at version control: decentralised systems just require lower overheads and less barrier to entry in general, so people just automatically use them. It's fine to point at legacy use cases where all the trust relationships are already established. Those are living off fully amortised costs. But new systems do not have that benefit and for that context, you are faced with a proposition of having to set up a whole lot of new trust infrastructure and associated processes. So for example, if you were setting up a library today and there were no pre-existing library systems out there. You might want to maintain a history of who borrowed each book, so you know who last had it. You will either have to establish a whole legal entity to become the owner of the books, electronic systems to track them and administer everything, and everyone will have to agree on its governance, who controls it and most importantly, trust them implicitly not to tamper with the transactions. It'll be a whole lot of work. So why would you do all that work when you can opt for a block chain with literally no overheads?
- thraxil 4y ago> It seems to me that block chains will win at the things they are good for a bit the way git won at version control: decentralised systems just require lower overheads and less barrier to entry in general, so people just automatically use them. Git really only had an inflection point of adoption when Github came out and offered a really compelling centralized service. Before Github, there wasn't a huge drive to move away from SVN (there was some but it was more because the new decentralized ones were better in other ways besides being decentralized and fixed some annoying bugs that SVN had) and it was much less certain that git would win out over mercurial or bazaar or one of the others. My experience at the time was also that the decentralized nature of git/hg/etc was arguably a barrier to their adoption. Existing teams were used to a workflow with a central repository and it wasn't clear how you would replace that with these decentralized tools. You had to do a lot of work to come up with a new workflow for your team or you made a central server somewhere and tried to make them work as similarly as possible to a centralized system. I remember a lot of pushback on moving to git from people who didn't understand the whole decentralized thing and found it more confusing than what they were used to. And with Github, that seems to be the approach that the vast majority of the world has gone with. Yeah, you can use git as a fully decentralized tool and there are people who prefer that to using Github, but that's pretty uncommon compared to how many teams just centralize with Github.
- anm89 4y agoThis is like saying there aren't many uses for computers, they just manipulate 1s and 0s very quickly. It's true but it fails to understand why that's enough. Blockchain enables digital peer to peer trustless exchange of money (and various other things of which the utility can be debated, many of which are low value) but that's enough. That's a lot Saying that blockchain is bad at being a database for all of these other things is like saying a cpu is bad at heating your home. Again, technically true and not particularly insightful, because they happen to be really good at manipulating 1s and 0s
- yashg 4y agoA very good explanation of why Blockchain is useless for anything else other than storing speculative tokens. A public, permission-less and trust-less ledger of transaction that uses proof-of-work as a consensus mechanism to add new transactions to the ledger is expensive and slow by design. It's a feature not a bug. That makes it unsuitable for any real world use case at scale. In order to make it fast and cheap - a private, permissioned, trustful blockchain kind of defeats the purpose and thus pointless.
- kordlessagain 4y agoBlockchains can encapsulate identity and payment in a single transaction. If someone were to tie these to HTTP requests (the 402 response, for example) then they would have micropayments for Web requests (API requests). People always focus on the speculative trading of the assets, but the real killer use case is stuff making calls to other stuff to do more stuff. AI models paid for with micro transactions is going to be a thing. It's just going to take time to get there.
- yashg 4y agoI am sorry, I didn't understand anything of that. You are jumping from HTTP requests to AI models to micro transactions. Real world is much more than API calls.
- margoguryan 4y agoThere are plenty of uses. They will change everything, but we are just in the stone ages.
- trhway6552 4y agoIt doesn't look like the author knows what Bitcoin is... They state that "Bitcoin transactions usually cost 1-2%" (sic) which is factually incorrect. I do believe that "there aren't many uses" for blockchains, but this sound more like an inaccurate, unoriginal and badly researched opinion piece.
- djupblue 4y agoMy problem with blockchains is that they AREN'T decentralized. If controlling a blockchain becomes valuable enough then it's a matter of time before someone will figure out how to profit from it and invest the required resources. Decentralized in my mind means there is not one single source of truth.
- Ferret7446 4y agoDo we even have an established definition for blockchain? My understanding is that a blockchain is just a data structure. Saying there aren't that many uses for blockchains is like saying there aren't that many uses for tries or red-black trees. Blockchains don't have to be decentralized for example.