3 ms·
No, in a different sense, because the right to not have other people's choices imposed on you is a made-up right. The rights you have were decided upon by peopl
by pessimizer 4y ago
No, in a different sense, because the right to not have other people's choices imposed on you is a made-up right. The rights you have were decided upon by people who aren't you, and imposed on you.
I'm theoretically sympathetic to your wanting to opt out of public services, but it's too onerous to have to maintain lists of houses not to put out if they're on fire.
- zmgsabst 4y ago> the right to not have other people's choices imposed on you is a made-up right You just said the right to not be a slave is a made-up right. > it's too onerous to have to maintain lists of houses not to put out if they're on fire So don’t? — but you’re losing me at the point you go from “I save money by not tracking exceptions” to “I have the right to make you participate because I want your money”.
- pessimizer 4y agoIf you consider obeying the law equivalent to slavery, then I absolutely am saying that. The law is other people's choices imposed upon you.
- zmgsabst 4y agoSure — as is slavery. Which is my point: you’re not differentiating between the two, while asserting that you don’t have the same rights in one case. Slavery was also the law.
- tremon 4y agoI'm less sympathetic: I wouldn't want to live next to a house that has opted out of sewage service.
- trashtester 4y ago> because the right to not have other people's choices imposed on you is a made-up right I agree with this statement. Actually, I consider this more of a principle than a right. Society should aim to minimize the degree to which it imposes the will of the government on the citizens, not fundamentally because freedom is an a priori right, but because it leads to a more peaceful society. A society where the citizens do not tolerate would be tyrants that want to excessively dictate how people live, tends to be (EDIT) more stable, innovative or economically competitive over time. Citizens of a freedom-loving society may not all understand this from first principles. Even if most believe they have such a right somewhat dogmatically, it may still have the same outcome. Dogmatism may come with the downside of seeing people with different opinions as evil, though, and may sometimes lead to needless conflict.