2 ms·

what is the point of dismissing someones Autism purely based on a single blog post and one person you knew? Are you actually trying to convey something helpful

by shlant 4y ago

what is the point of dismissing someones Autism purely based on a single blog post and one person you knew? Are you actually trying to convey something helpful here?

denton-scratch 4y ago
I'm not dismissing anyone's anything. I believe autism exists. > one person you knew? I've only known one person who was diagnosed autistic. It's a rare condition; I've known a dozen people with bipolar, and half-a-dozen diagnosed schizophrenics (either I'm attracted to psychotics, or they're attracted to me!) My point was simply that author's account could be anyone's account, apart from the author's self-identification as autistic. Without that, this entire thread would just be about how to deal with a crap boss.
- musingsole 4y ago
  >I'm not dismissing anyone's anything. >>I didn't see anything in author's prose that suggested autism You very much are dismissing someone's something. Worse, I don't think the author explicitly stated they were autistic in the piece...So, you're assuming someone's something just so you can dismiss it?
  - denton-scratch 4y ago
    > I don't think the author explicitly stated they were autistic in the piece "I have read similar experiences by other autistic people" suggests that the author considers themself to be autistic. > You very much are dismissing someone's something. ...And that's that, I guess. Can you please clarify what I am dismissing, and how? I don't want to dismiss anyone's anything.
    - musingsole 4y ago
      >>I didn't see anything in author's prose that suggested autism
      - atq2119 4y ago
        This doesn't read to me as dismissing the author's autism. It reads to me as observing that a non-autist could have written substantially the same article (minus making it about autism), and they then went off to observe that this comment section would likely have looked very different in that case. It's an interesting thought experiment, and at least to me it feels like you're the one who is reading dismissal into it for no good reason.
- larve 4y ago
  It's not a secret that autistic people have trouble communicating in the workplace. This is not a post about my life's story and me self-diagnosing as autistic. This is me relating my experience explicitly in response to someone saying something about autistic people. Self-diagnosis is widely accepted in the autistic community for a number of reasons, I am also in the process of pursuing a more "traditional" diagnosis. It's great that you think this post applies to everybody, it however is very much in response to someone stigmatizing autistic people.

by shlant 4y ago

what is the point of dismissing someones Autism purely based on a single blog post and one person you knew? Are you actually trying to convey something helpful here?

denton-scratch 4y ago

I'm not dismissing anyone's anything. I believe autism exists. > one person you knew? I've only known one person who was diagnosed autistic. It's a rare condition; I've known a dozen people with bipolar, and half-a-dozen diagnosed schizophrenics (either I'm attracted to psychotics, or they're attracted to me!) My point was simply that author's account could be anyone's account, apart from the author's self-identification as autistic. Without that, this entire thread would just be about how to deal with a crap boss.

musingsole 4y ago
>I'm not dismissing anyone's anything. >>I didn't see anything in author's prose that suggested autism You very much are dismissing someone's something. Worse, I don't think the author explicitly stated they were autistic in the piece...So, you're assuming someone's something just so you can dismiss it?
- denton-scratch 4y ago
  > I don't think the author explicitly stated they were autistic in the piece "I have read similar experiences by other autistic people" suggests that the author considers themself to be autistic. > You very much are dismissing someone's something. ...And that's that, I guess. Can you please clarify what I am dismissing, and how? I don't want to dismiss anyone's anything.
  - musingsole 4y ago
    >>I didn't see anything in author's prose that suggested autism
    - atq2119 4y ago
      This doesn't read to me as dismissing the author's autism. It reads to me as observing that a non-autist could have written substantially the same article (minus making it about autism), and they then went off to observe that this comment section would likely have looked very different in that case. It's an interesting thought experiment, and at least to me it feels like you're the one who is reading dismissal into it for no good reason.
larve 4y ago
It's not a secret that autistic people have trouble communicating in the workplace. This is not a post about my life's story and me self-diagnosing as autistic. This is me relating my experience explicitly in response to someone saying something about autistic people. Self-diagnosis is widely accepted in the autistic community for a number of reasons, I am also in the process of pursuing a more "traditional" diagnosis. It's great that you think this post applies to everybody, it however is very much in response to someone stigmatizing autistic people.