6 ms·
The free market is modelled around the fact that we are greedy. Communism assumes that we are (or can be made) purely altruistic ("From each according to his ab
by mseebach 18y ago
The free market is modelled around the fact that we are greedy. Communism assumes that we are (or can be made) purely altruistic ("From each according to his ability, to each according to his need" collapses if there is just a single selfish, greedy actor present).
That's why free markets work remarkably better than communism.
- walterk 18y agoThankfully, however, we're not actually forced to choose between laissez-faire capitalism and communism.
- unalone 18y agoYeah. I know neither side thinks compromise is a good solution, but: considering that each extreme is half the world's nightmare, being somewhere in between is a good way of giving everybody a chance to alter things. I think that being black-and-white in terms of your personal self is always a good way to be: if you always try to do the right thing for yourself regardless of what other people choose, then you're to be completely respected. But people who take that attitude and then try to cast it over an entire society (like Ron Paul, or Ayn Rand - though I think that the latter didn't actually think an entire society could work like that) ignore how incredibly complex any collection of people becomes, and how disastrous a black-and-white worldview would become.
- mseebach 18y agoThere is a considerable span between free markets and laissez-faire capitalism. Most modern "left" political movements accept free markets as a good thing, and mainly differ with the right on the level of regulation. I mainly read Ayn Rand as a criticism of the "truths" of the left wing, not as a very useful proponent of a laissez-faire society. Anyway, free markets "punish" greed, by forcing those who want material wealth to work for it, instead of leeching of others. The reason taxation and politicians is a problem in free markets is exactly greed: anybody on the receiving end of public funds have little rational motive to seek to end that stream.
- stupiduser 18y ago"Free markets" are a disaster; without protectionist measures the United States would still be pursuing its comparative advantage against Great Britian--we'd be selling them beaver skins and acorns in exchange for their manufactured goods. All of the protectionist Asian countries have done gangbusters in the last half-decade or so; meanwhile all of the countries that have had "free markets" forced on them (which certainly does NOT include the United States) have in comparison done terrible (think Africa, Latin America).
- unalone 18y agoShe's not somebody to be taken entirely practically, no. However, she's invaluable in that she teaches that man should exist for the sake of himself, and in that she writes in a captivating manner that has drawn millions of people in. I would never call myself Republican (I hate social conservativism with a passion) nor libertarian (I hate that they've made such a mockery of themselves), but Rand certainly showed me that the far left was as crazy as the far right. I think that free markets go too far in their "punishment" when they start punishing companies who ARE working for their wealth. As things stand right now, one side isn't being punished enough, while the other site is being punished too much.
- netcan 18y agoYou know, I never thought that free markets vs Communism made very good polar opposites. They don't cover the same sort of ground. They clash terribly over invisible hand vs command but Communism also covers a 17th- 18th centuryish theory of history at its core. What do free marketeers have to say to that? The command vs freee hand, particularly for physical goods production has been largely decided. I think very few politicians left that would directly control production in a red sort of a way. They might for micro political reasons, but probably wouldn't try to control the economy some other way. Marx got moulded into a religious figure. But read in a similar context as Kant, Bentham, or even Ayn Rand, it's definitely interesting.
- nazgulnarsil 18y agoyou're right. marxism is intertwined with the idea of a class struggle throughout history. I would say the free market version would be considered aristocratic: that it has been a small handful of entrepreneurs in each age that has advanced things. This in spite of the petty concerns of the proles, not because of them.
- netcan 18y agoThe idea of class struggle & the idea that history is a process with a beginning & an end.
- eru 18y agoNo, elitism and free market do not have to go hand in hand. For example look at the "I, Pencil" essay (http://www.econlib.org/library/Essays/rdPncl1.html http://www.econlib.org/library/Essays/rdPncl1.html) that argues that no single person knows how to make a pencil, at least not effectively. People of all walks of live contribute to our economy in varying degrees. The history of science and technology is still told as the history of great men. Just look at the wealth of independent re-inventions, to see that seldom does progress hinge on individuals. I still admire entrepeneurs and great scientists as great role models.
- nazgulnarsil 18y ago
- jacobolus 18y agoBoiling down a complex and varied set of ideologies into one oversimplified exaggerated statement FTW!