10 ms·
Stringbike: Benefits (2020)
- Someone 4y agohttps://www.stringbike.com/stringbike_asthemagicworks.html https://www.stringbike.com/stringbike_asthemagicworks.html shows the mechanism. Looks nice. There will be a lot of pressure on a relatively small wheel there, so I wonder what dust or a grain of sand would do there. I would guess making sure the mechanism near the pedals stays operating smoothly takes more maintenance than with normal bicycles. I wonder whether they considered exchanging rotary motion of the pedals for up/down movement so that they could get rid of that complex shape. Also, given that they sell a “seatpole spare string holder“, those strings don’t seem to last as long as a traditional bicycle chain.
- kazinator 4y agoAny serious cyclist carries a chain link tool for fixing a broken chain, along with a couple of spare inner tubes. Breaking a link doesn't happen often, and you'd typically not let a chain get so old that it happens from age; that will trash the sprockets. I've had breakage happen, though, and was glad to be able to get going again, in minutes. Since you can't fix a broken string just by removing a link and closing it, the only protection against string breakage is to carry a full spare.
- adrianN 4y agoCycling is essentially the only mode of transportation that I use but I never carry any spare parts or tools with me. Not even a pump. The only tool I carry is some cash and a credit card.
- elliottkember 4y agoA spare string weighs a lot less than a chain. They provide a spare string in the seat pole apparently. Edit: there's also two strings, one on each side. So if one snaps, I think you can ride home with the other
- kazinator 4y agoRight; I've never met anyone who carries an entire spare chain. It would not even slightly make sense. If you put a new chain on old sprockets, it will likely skip, particularly on the rear cassette. This will go double if you're someone who allowed the chain to wear for so long that it just broke. That chain will only work with the sprockets that it is on and vice versa. If you damaged a newer chain due to some freak accident (like cross chaining while shifting under load or something: shouldn't happen on a quality, well adjusted drive train) you probably don't want to replace it; aside from the bent/broken link, it is good. Splice the damaged link out and get moving. Swapping in a new chain could be extra work. It likely has excess links which you have to remove and set aside, and may have stuck links that have to be identified and massaged into releasing.
- tetraodonpuffer 4y agoI just have a couple powerlinks in my bag when riding, which take very little space. It is also unlikely to have a chain break while riding, however having a chain breaker tool and spare links comes in handy if your rear derailleur gives up the ghost (due to a fall etc), as in that case you can bypass it entirely with a shortened chain.
- FridgeSeal 4y agoMountain biker chiming in: have broken chains, friends have broken chains. It’s not a common occurrence, but basically ever has a chain breaker and spare links in their bags. MTB also admittedly puts a lot of components under far more wear and tear than other disciplines. For MTB especially, it’s not the fact that there’s probably better drivetrain options, but the fact that the current options will happily take a beating, and still let you ride back out. I’m sure the string is real nice and quiet, and has a nice internal hub, but my chain, mech and cassette will get whipped into trees and rocks, will have sand, water, grit ground through it for ~20kms, sustain impacts from going off drops and jumps and they’ll continue to work. I’ve bent mechs, hangers, dinged cassettes, ground chainrings, and they’ll put up with an astounding amount and still get you home. Once home the ease of access make maintenance a lot simpler, everything gets a clean and lube and it’s happy to go again.
- loeg 4y ago> Any serious cyclist carries a chain link tool for fixing a broken chain Your definition of "serious cyclist" excludes a lot of serious cyclists. Precisely because it happens so rarely, carrying a bulky tool for a rare problem isn't worth it to everyone.
- rtlfe 4y agoYeah "serious cyclist" feels so impossible to define that it's meaningless. If I ride to work every day but go to a shop for maintenance instead of buying my own tools am I not serious?
- kazinator 4y agoI'd say you're not serious about being able to back on a working bike in almost any conceivable breakdown situation.
- loeg 4y ago> serious about being able to back on a working bike in almost any conceivable breakdown situation We've seriously shifted the goalposts from "serious cyclist."
- kazinator 4y agoNot really; a serious cyclist is someone who depends on and is invested in cycling as a mode of transport, who is not able to meet commitments if their bike breaks down without an real-time remedy.
- kixiQu 4y agoSo... no one within range of being able to catch a bus is a serious cyclist because they have an out? No one who can call a friend for a ride can be serious about cycling? I don't think this is typically what people would mean by that phrase.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- switchbak 4y ago"Serious" cyclists are often using newer chains like those from SRAM. Many of these newer ones don't use spare links, you'd carry a quick link and remove a portion of the chain to get yourself riding again. Small distinction I agree, but you come off a little arrogant with such a strongly worded statement.
- NegativeLatency 4y agoI don't carry a chain link tool, too heavy/bulky. Been using a single speed with the same chain for about 13 years now.
- xupybd 4y agoI used to bike a lot when I was young. I took no spares. Worst case I walked my bike home.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bootlooped 4y agoI consider myself a "bike ride enthusiast" to get out of these ridiculous standards and expectations.
- askvictor 4y agoThere's a spare string provided in the seatpost; claims to take 10 minutes to replace and no tools required. But as with all riding, it depends on use-case. For remote cycling, you'll be carrying more spares than commuting, where worst-case you can walk the bike home.
- analog31 4y agoI've been cycling for 50 years. When I got a job where I could start riding to work, I carried an inordinate amount of stuff, including full rain gear, all the time. Gradually, I started leaving most of it behind. The reason was that I developed a better sense of the actual risks of breakdown, and the resources at my disposal should something happen, based strictly on my own circumstances. This is also kind of how I live my life. The people I know who've had breakdowns tend to be physically a lot stronger than me, and more "adventuresome" in their choice of riding conditions. For instance I expect my mountain biking friend to have a new story of destruction every few weeks. In some cases, I suspect that neglect or lack of maintenance skills played a role. I bring more spares and stuff when I go on really long rides, or if my family travels to some remote place with the bikes.
- feb 4y agoAbout longevity, on https://www.stringbike.com/stringbike_support_questionsandanswers.html https://www.stringbike.com/stringbike_support_questionsandan... they say strings last between 500 to 1500km. Bike chains supposedly last from 500 to 5000 miles (https://www.bikeshepherd.org/how-long-do-bike-chains-last/ https://www.bikeshepherd.org/how-long-do-bike-chains-last/) depending on usage and maintenance.
- ElijahLynn 4y agoThe maths: 500km == 310.68m 1,500km == 932.05m 500m == 804.67km 5,000m == 8046.72km
- swznd 4y agoI got confused a second. you should write "mi" not "m", m symbol for meter.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rcoveson 4y agoIt might cost more to manufacture in the USA, but that 61% increase to minimum longevity sure would be nice.
- gnopgnip 4y agoWith this string design the end of the string is fixed to the freewheel. So they don't have wear related issues that regular chains have like skipping gears, dropping a chain
- calvinmorrison 4y agoSeems cool. On the motorcycle side, I enjoy having a bike without a chain. Instead my BMW has a shaft that runs from the transmission to the rear wheel. Maintenance over 75K has been occasionally lubing the rear splines. There's been some attempts at a shaft driven bicycle but the downsides seem to come from the tighter tolerance, harder disassembly and overall heavier frame construction required. still cool from a longevity POV.
- feb 4y agoTransmission via shafts is also less efficient. It doesn't matter much on a motor bike where there's plenty of power. But on a human powered bike, every watt counts. See for example https://www.cyclingabout.com/chainless-shaft-drive-bicycles/ https://www.cyclingabout.com/chainless-shaft-drive-bicycles/ for more information.
- Rnonymous 4y agoI went down the same path owning a BMW shaft drive motorcycle, doing my own maintenance. I decided i had enough of re-tensioning the chain on my bicycle (Living in Amsterdam) and got a second hand Brik shaft bicycle. Indeed maintenance is harder, but i have far less maintenance. So instead of ~twice a year giving my chain bike some love, i now bring the Brik to the shop once every 2-3 years. I still ride a normal chain bike regularly, and I can't say i find the Brik heavier to ride. It all seems negligible compared to the watts wasted by the sitting position of a city bike.
- kazinator 4y agoI like how the front pulley acts as a 2X gear ratio. For every distance x the pulley moves, it draws 2x string. That means you don't need a ridiculously small rear sprocket diameter, or make the front lever ridiculously large, to get a conventional high gear (like 52x12).
- dang 4y agoRelated: Stringbike – A Chain-less Bicycle - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11515123 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11515123 - April 2016 (6 comments) Stringbike: Chain-free bike - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1716002 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1716002 - Sept 2010 (47 comments)
- BugsJustFindMe 4y agoThis looks weird and interesting and the price of the single speed version is actually not bad. The string is just simple dyneema cord with crimped ends, so you could probably even make them yourself from bulk and carry a dozen spares for basically no extra weight. The prices on their different lines seem way out of whack though. Carbon and Aluminum cost basically the same? Aren't carbon bikes usually much more expensive than others? Single speed is _way_ cheaper than the rest. Like unexpectedly so. Are they saying their adjustable gear mechanism accounts for $2000 of the price? And Designer is in the middle? I really don't understand the pricing scale here.
- rich_sasha 4y agoYou can definitely find two fairly priced frames, where the better/pricier one is made of aluminium and the cheaper one is carbon. It helps carbon fiber prices have gone down substantially in the last decade. Still, it is a bit odd...
- flicken 4y agoWhat prices are you seeing? For me in Europe, the single speed is only €240 cheaper than the cheapest Aluminum bike. €3990-€5200 Carbon €1590-€1990 Designer €1490-€1990 Aluminum €1250 single speed
- InitialLastName 4y agoIn the US: Carbon: $3478-$4553 Aluminum: $3100-$3800 Designers: $1386-$1909 (many priceless, presumably expensive) Single Speed: $1090
- pavon 4y agoWow that is a big difference on Aluminum. I was looking at the US prices myself, and my first thought was I bet I could add shifter levers on that single speed myself and save 2 grand. The EU prices make much more sense.
- matsemann 4y ago
- russellbeattie 4y agoIt's weird they don't have an embedded video or at least a prominent link to their YouTube channel. Here it is below. Wish there was audio, I'm personally a little doubtful of the silence of the bike given the sorta clunky front gear system, but I'm sure it's quieter than a chain. It's odd that they muted it. https://youtu.be/-Qjf8Rnn1N4 https://youtu.be/-Qjf8Rnn1N4
- andrewflnr 4y agoMy guess is they used the wrong background music over the back half and had to mute it for copyright reasons.
- rich_sasha 4y agoI might have missed it but there's no info on efficiency. I can both imagine it's great and terrible. Dyneema doesn't really stretch so that's on the plus side. But surely there's a ton of friction in this system? And that's before you consider the gearbox; these tend to be somewhat less efficient than derailleur systems.
- digdugdirk 4y agoThis isn't really a gearbox in the traditional sense, they're just using the word because it makes sense to people. What their "gearbox" does is increase/decrease the lever arm acting on the string. This serves the same function, but the frictional losses would be mostly constant across all the "gears". There will absolutely be some losses due to rope deformation (squish, not stretch) and heat, but I imagine they would be relatively consistent across the lifetime of the rope - there's not any grease to degrade over time, for example.
- rich_sasha 4y agoRight, but the actual % efficiency does matter. Derailleur and IGH achieve easily 90+% efficiency with low maintenance. Is this in the same ballpark? 80% ? 60% ? Also the string will definitely pick up grime off the roads, especially when wet, so efficiency will almost certainly drop as a result.
- enragedcacti 4y agothe FAQ says the string is technically more efficient but in practice they are both extremely efficient when properly maintained so the difference is academic. They don't mention losses when the string is wet or dirty so I'm not sure about that. https://www.stringbike.com/stringbike_support_questionsandanswers.html https://www.stringbike.com/stringbike_support_questionsandan...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- floodfx 4y agoCurious how a string drive would perform on a mountain bike especially considering climbing advantages and easier shifting?
- klyrs 4y agoThey look well suited to road riding. Sounds like mud and grit fouling the string would wear them out quickly. Replacing them seems simple enough, but I do wonder if anybody has tried using a nylon belt instead. And then there's the bearing surface of the pedal-gear-thingies. I'd bet a little grit in there would sound and feel like nails on a chalkboard.
- egypturnash 4y agoHuh. Interesting, very interesting. Usually links to bikes here are just nonsensical overcomplicated bullshit IMHO, but this is close to the simplicity of the $300 bike I’m constantly riding around town. I’m trying to figure out what’s going on with the pull-back motion of the strings. Is there a spring in the hub? Are they stretchy cords that are going to snap someday? How easy are they for a passing asshole having a bad day to cut?
- digdugdirk 4y agoIt looks like they're juuuuuuuuuust the right length so they perfectly match up to pedal stroke. i.e. - Your push stroke unwinds the string to its max extension length, and then the rotational inertia of the wheel does the job of winding the string up again. EDIT: Scratch that, disregard the above. Looks like they're using a spring to wind up one side while it freewheels. As for assholes? Yeah, they're going to be able to slice those with a pocket knife in a few seconds. Even Dyneema and the like would likely be quickly frayed with a few good knife swipes to the point of being in danger of snapping from a hard pedal push when taking off from a stoplight.
- kretaceous 4y agoFrom their FAQ page[0], What happens if the string snaps? It takes 10 minutes to replace, by the rider. No specialist knowledge required, worth watching the tutorial on the website. No tool required, no need to remove the rear wheel, or other parts. Spare string is provided, and neatly stored in the seat pole. The spare comes with instructions to install. 0: https://www.stringbike.com/stringbike_support_questionsandanswers.html https://www.stringbike.com/stringbike_support_questionsandan...
- echiuran 4y agoI'm no mechanical engineer, but this looks way more complicated than a traditional chain/derailleur drivetrain. Especially the two contraptions, one on each side of the bottom bracket. Instead of a continuous circular motion, the rear hub is constantly having to freewheel, on one side or the other. What's the efficiency loss there? How does the overall weight compare to a traditional drivetrain with the same range of gear ratios? Have they measured the difference in efficiency?
- digdugdirk 4y agoI am a mechanical engineer, and I'm 50/50 on it. The rear hub contraptions aren't too different from the freewheel that's already in a regular bike hub, it just has an extra spring to wind it back up. The super funky gearbox contraption though? That's a different story altogether. You have a continuously varying normal force on the lever arm throughout the rotation, and I have no idea how long it would last compared to a traditional derailleur setup. Here's the patent, for those interested: https://patents.google.com/patent/WO2010084363A1/en https://patents.google.com/patent/WO2010084363A1/en
- kretaceous 4y agoTheir FAQ Page[0] and How it works page[1] provide a lot of information and answers to the question raised in few of the comments. 0; https://www.stringbike.com/stringbike_support_questionsandanswers.html https://www.stringbike.com/stringbike_support_questionsandan... 1: https://www.stringbike.com/stringbike_asthemagicworks.html https://www.stringbike.com/stringbike_asthemagicworks.html
- digdugdirk 4y agoHere's the patent, for those interested: https://patents.google.com/patent/WO2010084363A1/en https://patents.google.com/patent/WO2010084363A1/en
- eckza 4y agoDo you know what else is nearly whisper-quiet and grease-free? Degrease your bicycle chain with kerosene or some other solvent, and submerge it in molten paraffin for 20 minutes. I have been doing this to my bike chains for almost a decade now, and it makes a big difference.
- loeg 4y agoAka, "wax." I use these products[1][2], but plain paraffin (the main ingredient) works fine. There are also drip-on wax products[3] that can be applied to a clean or previously waxed chain, without removing the chain again. Totally agree that waxed bicycle drivetrains work very well, are quiet, and avoid the mess of oil-based lubricants. [1]: https://moltenspeedwax.com/ https://moltenspeedwax.com/ [2]: https://silca.cc/products/secret-chain-wax-blend https://silca.cc/products/secret-chain-wax-blend [3]: https://www.ceramicspeed.com/en/cycling/shop/ufo-products/ufo-drip---new-formula- https://www.ceramicspeed.com/en/cycling/shop/ufo-products/uf...
- convolvatron 4y agoI use carnauba wax for finishing metal and have heard about using it on chains. right now about every two weeks I clean the chain with a light mineral oil, then a day later I clean again and put down heavier oil. keeps the mud away. would be I happier if I just cleaned the chain and dropped it in a pot of hot wax? is there anything to look out for?
- eckza 4y agoProbably; you wouldn't have to do so much maintenance. Wax fills in all of the voids between the bushings, roller pins, etc - so it physically prevents dirt from getting into your chain. And since there's no oil to cause the dirt to stick to your drivetrain, your gears don't wear down as quickly (as oil / grease + dust is abrasive; each rotation wears the chain and rings down ever so slightly).
- loeg 4y ago> would be I happier if I just cleaned the chain and dropped it in a pot of hot wax? Quite possibly. Chains stay clean and efficient for longer without intervention. And can be handled without dirtying your hands. It's nice. Other drivetrain components wear slower because there's less grit and the chain stretches more slowly. > is there anything to look out for? Main downsides: * For bicycles, a lot of chains (Shimano, KMC) come in some kind of factory oil/grease. Stripping that off takes time and working with solvents. Fine if you have time and a garage, less great for busy people in apartments. I think some manufacturers sell dry chains (I've heard YBN does). * Heating wax up is slow. I use a $12 crockpot and it takes a couple hours. Obviously, it's not like it takes any effort on your part, but there's some built in latency. ("Low" heat is about right in the steady state, but it melts faster if you use "high.") * Again for bicycles, some kinds of quick link / master link wear quite quickly and can only be reused a handful of times (e.g., Shimano 11 speed). So one surprising expense in repeatedly removing chains to hot wax is the consumption of quick links. Can be mitigated with different brands of quick link, and/or using drip-on wax a few times between hot waxes. * A freshly waxed chain will be stiff from the hardened wax. So a pre-install step is going through every link in the chain (on bicycles, typically ~110-120 links) and making sure each one rotates freely around the pin. This takes a few minutes.
- soared 4y agoWould a chain or carbon belt still work in this configuration?
- gaze 4y agoHow does this compare to a timing belt?
- Rackedup 4y agoA belt system is simpler and probably lasts longer (but not as long as a chain)
- forinti 4y agoI wonder how long the rope will last.
- jopsen 4y agoThe FAQ says 500~1500 km. Which is pretty short... You rarely break a normal bike chain.
- 14 4y agoI think it’s a neat design but the cost is way to much for the average user to adopt this. It’s certainly not geared towards casual riders like me and my kids. They are way to hard on bikes to justify something like this. So it looks cool and I would like to try it out but never would buy one at anything even close to the price they are offering right now.
- ok_dad 4y agoSame here, I am intrigued by it, and would plunk down $1k right now for something like this even, but $3k+ is wayyyyyyyyy too much for just a standard bike with a neat drivetrain. Plus, I am sure shipping it to where I live would be another few hundred. I do like the idea of this for low-maintenance though.
- tromp 4y agoThese Dutch rowingbikes have also had various forms of string drive for over a decade: https://rowingbike.com/en/modellen/ https://rowingbike.com/en/modellen/ with cables either in steel or in dyneema (polymer-based).
- jstanley 4y agoA 2012 review in Wired says it rides pretty much like a normal bike: https://www.wired.com/2012/02/stringbike/ https://www.wired.com/2012/02/stringbike/ Other than that I can't readily find any more reviews from anyone who claims to have ridden one. I wonder why, given that they apparently have been making them for 10 years?
- jackmott42 4y agoAlmost always the downside to a non chain drive is a loss of efficiency. A chain and cog setup is really really good, like 99% efficient with a clean lubed chain. Internal hub gears, drive shafts, strings, almost all of them have losses a bit worse than that, which sucks when you are a 0.5hp motor.
- cyberferret 4y agoInteresting - I was just having a discussion with my son the other day about the term "horsepower". Quick research showed that the average human can generate 1.2 HP in a burst, or 0.1 HP sustained. Is 0.5 HP the accepted measure for sustained output while riding a bike?
- desertrider12 4y agoDepends on how long to sustain - 0.5 HP is 373 watts, which is more than male pros sustain over a whole race stage but less than some can do for ~10 minute sections. [1](https://cyclingtips.com/2017/06/just-how-good-are-male-pro-road-cyclists/ https://cyclingtips.com/2017/06/just-how-good-are-male-pro-r...)
- _carbyau_ 4y agoI have never really looked up the details. But I watch MotoGP and figure if something was better they'd be using it. So chain it is.
- ben-schaaf 4y agoThis only really matters for sport. Hub gears and dynamos are less efficient but much more convenient for commuting.
- thomasfl 4y agoA bicycle is in my opinion one of mans greatest inventions. It empowers almost everybody to transport themselves five times more energy efficiently than walking. For two hundred years the bicycle has been improved by countless ingenious inventions. Cities where the majority commute by bicycle, are much better to live in.
- mrtesthah 4y agoBicycles are indeed the most efficient mode of transportation, but shouldn’t we be taking into account the energy cost of the entire paved system of roads needed to facilitate that rolling efficiency in the first place? Paving a road with asphalt is pretty resource intensive.
- bch 4y agoBicycles don’t need that, and it wasn’t made for them, so I don’t know why you’d charge “road cost” to the bicycle ledger when they’re such a distant second (at best) citizen on most roadways anyway.
- fanf2 4y agoRoads were originally paved for bicycles, before cars. https://www.cyclinguk.org/cycle/roads-built-cars https://www.cyclinguk.org/cycle/roads-built-cars https://www.theguardian.com/environment/bike-blog/2013/apr/16/roads-not-built-for-cars-book https://www.theguardian.com/environment/bike-blog/2013/apr/1... https://roadswerenotbuiltforcars.com/ https://roadswerenotbuiltforcars.com/
- googlryas 4y agoMaybe some roads somewhere were built for bicyclists, but I don't think you can generally say that when there are literally 6000 year old paved roads leading to Ur. Horse drawn carriages and wagons would benefit from roads and were probably much more common and important to business/transport than bicycles until the 20th century.
- 4y ago
- zerohalo 4y agoThis is fucking awesome (but way too expensive for me to consider)
- throw7 4y agoHmmm, the belt drives have longer estimated mileage (the gates drive is ~9000mi? i think from memory).
- sinab 4y agoOn the topic of low-noise bikes, why do some riders insist on having a loud freewheel? The clicking noise is unbearable in my opinion. Source: https://bicycles.stackexchange.com/questions/4606/what-causes-the-noise-that-race-wheels-make-when-you-are-not-pedaling#:~:text=The%20noise%20you%20are%20hearing,moving%20out%20of%20the%20way https://bicycles.stackexchange.com/questions/4606/what-cause....
- NoPicklez 4y agoIn group rides with expensive bikes its often associated with higher quality wheels. Friend of mine had Zipp wheels which had a distinctly louder freehub.
- renewiltord 4y agoI don't, but my Zipps are loud and I like them otherwise.
- digdugdirk 4y agoIt's not so much an insistence, more just where the industry is at. Those freewheel hubs are loud because that's generally the lightest, most efficient design - lots of teeth for immediate drive engagement, no extra grease that would lessen said engagement, no extra material for sound dampening. Clutch mechanisms are available, but these are slightly less efficient and generally more expensive. Basically... People love spending lots of money for the absolute highest quality components. How will other riders know how fancy your hubs are unless it broadcasts that fact to the world?
- gorgoiler 4y agoIt is just the fashion of our time. See also: gravel bike tyres with tan sidewalls, or if you’re old enough, bar ends.
- renewiltord 4y agoOnly single size? I would buy one right now if I could.
- huntsman2022 4y agoA stringbike has a completely different feel than a regular bicycle due to the energy storage in the spring. With a stringbike you don't encounter torque spikes going up a hill because the spring smooths them out.
- gorgoiler 4y agoI wonder what it would be like to independently adjust the leverage ratio on each crank? Maybe if you had one leg stronger than the other? Or you could maintain two gearings for different scenarios — left leg power, right leg torque? A silly idea, for sure, but fun to think about and a unique feature of a two sided drive.
- joshu 4y agofiltering vibrancy?
- waspight 4y agoBut who is this for? I have never had much trouble with a regular chain. Are they even solving a real problem?