3 ms·
Does the Maximalist Novel Still Matter?
- darkerside 4y agoA maximalist novel reminds me a bit of brutalist architecture. I'm the right place and time, there could be nothing more impressive and imposing, but you need to be pretty full of yourself to think that is worth putting your reader through something like that. On that note, the ideas and the payoff had better be worth it. Otherwise, If you don't have the content to warrant it, you're abusing your reader. A maximalist novel is actually laziness in some ways (see the Mark Twain line about writing a long letter). When I read the quotes from Mount Chicago, I'm rolling my eyes. They come across as trite, reheated leftovers, served in a Michelin star package. Likely these are cherry picked examples, but they are part of the author's published book. He needs to own them. I will say, the article is worth reading, or at least skimming, for the Seinfeld quote at the end alone. It may have singlehandedly changed my mind about some aspects of modern comedy.
- bambax 4y ago> see the Mark Twain line about writing a long letter Do you mean Pascal? It was Blaise Pascal who wrote, in 1657, that his letter was longer than usual because he lacked the time of making it shorter. After looking up the Quote Investigator [] it seems that sentence from Pascal has a long history of being quoted and appropriated by many authors in English; and in 1975 "an article in the “Chicago Tribune” of Illinois about writing postcards attributed a version of the saying to Twain". But the originator is French philosopher and polymath Blaise Pascal ;-) [0] https://quoteinvestigator.com/2012/04/28/shorter-letter/ https://quoteinvestigator.com/2012/04/28/shorter-letter/
- teakettle42 4y agoI wonder why Jonathan Russell Clark, the author of this article, feels entitled to a platform as a yet another “cis white male”? Is it just because he uses his platform to undermine other “cis white males”? This article pretended to a broader point, but it was really just another painful exercise in self-flaggelation from a cis white male that refuses to volunteer their own platform to a “marginalized group” while asserting that other “cis white males” ought to do the same. As Jonathan Russell Clark himself states in his bloviatingly maximalist essay: > “This is the bitter pill many white men find difficult to swallow. In order for space to be made for others, then space that before was given to them must be relinquished or shared.” To which I say: you first! Recuse yourself to make room for others. Anything else is rank hypocrisy. Or, make the simple admission that this is all horrifically invidious and nobody’s work should be judged on the basis of the color of their skin or what’s between their legs.
- istinetz 4y agotl;dr author was rejected from a publisher for being a white male, then writes a book in which a character is also rejected for being a white male, and has a bunch of interactions with crazy woke people. Therefore outrage? Why am I supposed to care about that? Is it a true picture of the world? It very much is, according to this very article. So why are you complaining, Esquire? Yeah, he might be acidic in his writing. That's what happens when you ruin a person's livelihood because of his race and gender. >This is the bitter pill many white men find difficult to swallow. In order for space to be made for others, then space that before was given to them must be relinquished or shared. Moreover, equality isn’t just about replacing X amount of men with Y amount of women—or white people with POC, or cis people with trans people—but about deliberately carving out space that is entirely theirs. This stuff is why Trump was elected.
- prvc 4y agoMaximalist book reviews are really where it's at.
- jaqalopes 4y agoI feel like I read a completely different article than some other commenters here. This article is a clear and persuasive statement on how unoriginal "critiques" of wokeness are, as well as on the irony of a white man complaining about how hard it is to get published... even though he just got his book published! There's no question that today space is being made in publishing for "other voices." But this article in no way says that is a bad thing, or agrees with the book author's implication of the same. To the contrary, it explains in a useful way (imo as a white man who might want at some point to publish a book) what white men can do to stay competitive as modern reading audiences change. Books are a business. If you can't get with the times, whose fault is that, really?
- teakettle42 4y ago> This article is a clear and persuasive statement on how unoriginal "critiques" of wokeness are God forbid critiques of your own normalized racism and sexism be unoriginal and boring to you. That says more about you than anything about the critique itself. > as well as on the irony of a white man complaining about how hard it is to get published... even though he just got his book published! Where’s the irony in an established successful author facing discrimination, and — unlike the many authors that will never have the opportunity due to said discrimination — using their slightly more privileged position to call it out?
- jaqalopes 4y agoWhat discrimination did he face? Surely you aren't arguing that his book—which, crucially, did ultimately sell and get published—being initially rejected by a couple of publishers constitutes "discrimination." Books, as I said, are a business. When you write a manuscript, chances are that it will be rejected by at least a few publishers before someone decides it fits their business goals. That's not discrimination, it's how the world works. I haven't seen any data showing that the percentage of new releases by white men is somehow less than the percentage of white men in the country. What I have seen is a lot of anecdotal complaining by people who are no longer benefiting from the obsolete modes of discrimination that they formerly rode to success.