4 ms·
I also started as CS, and stuck with it all the way to PhD. I think that CS, CPE and EE are different than the rest of STEM that students get to start playing
by scott_s 15y ago
I also started as CS, and stuck with it all the way to PhD.
I think that CS, CPE and EE are different than the rest of STEM that students get to start playing in their discipline much, much earlier. I know from experience that CS majors are writing code their first semester. Continually creating new things in your discipline sets up a feedback-loop that keeps you interested. I don't think this was true for engineering programs like civil, mechanical or aerospace.
For science, the payoff is much more abstract, since you don't actually do science as a science undergrad. You learn about science.
There are, of course, undergrads who get involved in research projects or extra-curricular activities centered around their major that allow them to actually play around in their discipline early on. But I think those are edge cases.
- pnathan 15y agoThat is a very good point. I am sure that if all I had done was read about programming and see people scribble on a blackboard about it, I would quit and go be a jazz musician. I know I liked the computer as a teen because unlike chemistry, biology, or physics, I could do really cool stuff without putting together a lab. That's an AMAZING advantage of the computer. The chemistry student I know has been involved in her university's chemistry research labs since freshman year. Mechanical engineer students here frequently do projects, there is a ME lab for them to mess around with. Biology students have some opportunity (unsure how much) to participate in the university's activities. But, maybe this University is more hands-on than other places.
- scott_s 15y agoI think most schools have those opportunities, but it's something the students have to seek out. I could be completely wrong here, I'm basing this observation off of my understanding of what curriculums I did not go through were like.
- aswanson 15y agoNah, EE's dont. They get divorced theory and math most of the first few years. When we do actually get to build circuits early on, they are to mintutiae-focused on some slew-rate characteristics of an op-amp at a given frequency rather than systemic perspective thinking that is needed in the real world with real applications. To much focus on analysis, nowhere near enough on synthesis. A modern EE education is geared toward training autistic, perspective-deprived drones.
- Maven911 15y agoYes incredibly accurate and its a shame. I did have labs working on breadboards and even IC design but it was literally just following a well defined procedure so you dont screw it up
- wiredfool 15y agoAs a civil engineer, we were building stuff early on. (and typically destroying it too). I remember towers on the shake table, bridges, and connection testing (including arc welding). There was still about a 50%washout rate.
- scott_s 15y agoThanks for saying so. For the record, my CS undergrad had similar attrition, but it was during the dot-com boom. I was a freshmen in '99 and there were 500 other CS freshmen. The typical number of students at a given level is, I think, roughly 1/5 of that now.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]