3 ms·
I don't think it's so trivial, and it can easily be made much more complicated. Suppose sanctioned party A pays B, a citizen of Indonesia who lives in Indonesi
by kragen 4y ago
I don't think it's so trivial, and it can easily be made much more complicated.
Suppose sanctioned party A pays B, a citizen of Indonesia who lives in Indonesia, $X. B's chain analysis decides that $X is "not material", so they continue using the account, and then transfer C $Y < $X. C's chain analysis decides that $Y is "material". What happens now?
The first question is whether C delivers B the goods B was paying for without demanding an additional form of payment. If so, they have exposed themselves to sanctions from the US, potentially a large problem if they are a US person.
If not, the second question is, do they refund the payment or not? If not, they have defrauded B; if so, they have potentially exposed themselves to additional sanctions from the US.
The third question is, what if A decides to only spend "not material" amounts? They spend a small amount on extra transaction fees, but the sanctions become ineffective.
All this uncertainty about where exactly the line is seems like it could put significant stress on Ethereum's fungibility.
To make it more complicated, consider that we're talking about US$400M here that the OFAC is trying to freeze. That's enough to transfer US$11000 to each of 36000 different accounts, or, more practically, random numbers of thousands of dollars to tens of thousands of different accounts over the next year or two. If the would-be sanctions evaders (who, as R. Nikhil points out in https://rnikhil.com/2022/08/09/tornado-cash-block.html https://rnikhil.com/2022/08/09/tornado-cash-block.html, could include anyone who doesn't want their medical insurance provider to know what OTC drugs they buy, doesn't want their employer to know everything they spend their money on, or wants to donate to a political cause they don't talk about) are willing to spend 30% of their money to unfreeze the rest, they could get a pretty interesting number of people sanctioned with "material amounts of wealth".
By the way, I still remember your grilled portobellos decades later. I'm glad to see you're still out there, and I appreciate the chance to discuss things like this with you.
- asah 4y agoWhoa! Sent you email. ;-) Back to the thread, I believe "material" is defined by the amount of the source wallets not the destination wallet. But it's also risky to accept large amounts of money from strangers because of the reasonable presumption of a transaction, and best practice to make a good faith effort to return or dispose it (same qty minus transaction costs), which seems trivial in this case. (But IANAL and we're getting a bit arcane...)