2 ms·
To repeat my comment on the earlier now-buried post: Companies definitely should disobey the law by refusing to comply with a valid search warrant in cases whe
by kragen 4y ago
To repeat my comment on the earlier now-buried post:
Companies definitely should disobey the law by refusing to comply with a valid search warrant in cases where someone is being prosecuted for having an abortion. Obeying the law in this case is clearly immoral!
This does not entail that obeying the law is always immoral, or even that breaking it is always moral. You can come to the conclusion that it is okay for companies to break some laws but not others in at least two perfectly reasonable ways: you can believe that breaking laws is not in itself a bad thing (but that actions that break some law may be bad for some other reason, such as harming people), or that it is a bad thing but in some cases the lesser of two evils.
However, in practice it may be difficult for a company to organize such disobedience, particularly since, for example, Facebook cannot avoid hiring employees from religious groups who are in favor of these laws, and also because the court order may not inform Facebook what the case is about. So, a more practical approach is to avoid being in the position of surveilling people's private communications in the first place, so that no employees at the company have access to the information the police seek. End-to-end encryption is a crucial structural protection against this kind of pervasive surveillance, because it prevents intermediaries from having the private information in the first place. Pseudonymity is another one: the teenager should never have given Facebook her legal name, but unfortunately Facebook has extensive policies in place to extort legal names from its users, making them vulnerable to such abuses.
Of course talking about encryption always brings out the knuckledraggers who link to XKCD 538 and talk about hitting people with $5 wrenches. Hopefully this example clarifies why encryption sometimes defeats a $5 wrench: neither Celeste Burgess, the Nebraska teenager, nor the Facebook employees were ever at risk of being beaten with a wrench in this case.
(originally https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32402302 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32402302, edited a bit)
- lmm 4y ago> Companies definitely should disobey the law by refusing to comply with a valid search warrant in cases where someone is being prosecuted for having an abortion. Obeying the law in this case is clearly immoral! I like living in a country where it's illegal to kill babies on a whim, thank you very much. So no, while you might disagree with this law, it's not at all "clear". > Of course talking about encryption always brings out the knuckledraggers who link to XKCD 538 and talk about hitting people with $5 wrenches. Hopefully this example clarifies why encryption sometimes defeats a $5 wrench: neither Celeste Burgess, the Nebraska teenager, nor the Facebook employees were ever at risk of being beaten with a wrench in this case. Facebook employees who refused to comply with a warrant would absolutely be thrown in jail once they ran out of lawyers and money (admittedly a process that would probably take years). Just look at the ProtonMail guy.
- kragen 4y agoProbably many things are clear to me that are not clear to you. Some of them are things I'm wrong about. Others are things I know more about than you do. In yet other cases, the difference in perceptions stems from other causes. It sounds like abortion is in the second category. You might want to consider that the kind of inflammatory language you're using tends to make productive argument much less likely. > Facebook employees who refused to comply with a warrant would absolutely be thrown in jail I think it is very unusual for employees to end up in jail because their corporate employer was found guilty of contempt of court. In particular, I don't think any ProtonMail employee has ever been thrown in jail. We know about cases where companies have successfully refused to introduce cryptographic backdoors into their software; even in the case of the unnamed climate activist https://www.techdirt.com/2021/09/10/protonmail-turned-over-french-activists-ip-address-to-law-enforcement-following-request-swiss-authorities/ https://www.techdirt.com/2021/09/10/protonmail-turned-over-f... ProtonMail was only ordered to provide his IP address, not inject backdoored encryption into his browser to steal his email. We also know about cases, for example in Germany, where police have injected malware into customers' devices, and as I understand it, companies are required to assist in this. This is not the established law in Nebraska, although it is surely happening covertly in the US in some cases.
- lmm 4y ago> You might want to consider that the kind of inflammatory language you're using tends to make productive argument much less likely. You might want to consider the same about statements like "the law is clearly immoral". I don't think my response was disproportionate. > I think it is very unusual for employees to end up in jail because their corporate employer was found guilty of contempt of court. Unusual, yes, but far from unthinkable; there simply aren't many cases where both sides fight to the bitter end, because the threat doesn't have to be carried out in order to have power. And of course if you can make someone unemployable then you don't need to jail them directly. > We know about cases where companies have successfully refused to introduce cryptographic backdoors into their software We do? When?
- 4y ago
- abigail95 4y agoWhy is all abortion law immoral? Why can't we draw a line somewhere before 28 weeks and say that if you want an abortion, you have to decide before 7 months have gone by? I can't imagine thinking that it should be legal to kill a full term fetus as it's being delivered solely because it hasn't been born yet.
- kragen 4y agoFirst, as to the abortion question, I'm interested to hear what you think about https://spot.colorado.edu/~heathwoo/Phil160,Fall02/thomson.htm https://spot.colorado.edu/~heathwoo/Phil160,Fall02/thomson.h... (exegesis in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Defense_of_Abortion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Defense_of_Abortion). As for "legal to kill a full term fetus as it's being delivered", of course that is not what is alleged to have happened in this case, and it is wrong, but most people who ever lived disagreed with me about this; as https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infanticide https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infanticide helpfully explains, "Most Stone Age human societies routinely practiced infanticide, and estimates of children killed by infanticide in the Mesolithic and Neolithic eras vary from 15 to 50 percent. Infanticide continued to be common in most societies after the historical era began, including ancient Greece, ancient Rome, the Phoenicians, ancient China, ancient Japan, Aboriginal Australia, Native Americans, and Native Alaskans." However, surely even if you and I disagree on which acts are real crimes, we can agree that pervasive surveillance by Facebook aids in the prosecutions of many real crimes. But that is not enough to show that it is desirable; it also enables unjust government persecution of people who are doing things that are illegal, but should not be, and this must also be weighed in the balance. From my point of view it is evident that this is such a case. Perhaps your example would be something different: Christians being persecuted for holding worship services in their homes, for example, or the Righteous Among the Nations secretly protecting Jews in their houses during the Holocaust. In short, totalitarianism is not transparently the best form of government, and for many of us this case illustrates the dangers to liberty from Facebook's pervasive surveillance.
- abigail95 4y agoYou are taking this so far off the rails. We know what Nebraskans think about abortion - they made a 28 week abortion illegal. No mesothilic civilisation is relevant here. If you think a 39 week abortion is wrong, as you say - at what point between 28 and 39 does the abortion become wrong, using the facts of this case? You've already moved the goalposts away from all abortion law is immoral to agreeing with my example.