3 ms·
Google has a lot of POI data, but it's not necessarily good data. What POI data do you find missing in Apple maps? Most of the recent issues with retail estab
by kube-system 4y ago
Google has a lot of POI data, but it's not necessarily good data. What POI data do you find missing in Apple maps? Most of the recent issues with retail establishments changing hours has also affected Google Maps in my experience.
- jeffbee 4y agoIt wasn't hard to find an example. The restaurant nearest my house that I could think of which closed most recently was Cesar in Berkeley. Google has it listed as permanently closed and does not draw a POI for it. Apple says it will be open today at 4pm.
- kube-system 4y agoGoogle has most of the restaurant times around me correct, but the map is also littered with a bunch of businesses that don't exist. Their small-business data is a mess. It looks like a lot of independent contractor hustles that people have are incorrectly listed as brick and mortar businesses. There's at least a dozen in just my neighborhood -- single family homes incorrectly listed as things like night clubs, schools, retail stores, a church, etc.
- em500 4y agoAnd outside of the US it only gets worse. Apple only lists about half of the stores in a shopping mall near where I live in Amsterdam. They still list a bank branch as open that has been closed for around two years now. Amusingly they also list the department store that replaced it (correctly at the same address). Both the bank and the department stores are from about the largest chains in the country, not obscure mom and pop stores.
- clairity 4y agoliterally every time i go to search for anything--a restaurant, a venue, a specialty shop, etc.--apple maps returns an arbitrarily limited and often unrelated/nonsensical results set. it also has a habit of zooming me to an entirely region/country, when it knows my exact location right now, because the data is so sparse and incomplete. i'm not saying google results are perfect, far from it, but they certainly don't typically do the above.
- smeyer 4y agoFor what it's worth, I also get annoyed with how often google thinks I want "Foo Cafe" in Atlanta when I'm really looking for "Foo Restaurant" two blocks away from me in Boston.
- kube-system 4y agoDealing with that is enough to make you want to go to "Foo Bar"
- clairity 4y agorandomly, i tried "king and i", which was my favorite thai place in boston (way back in the day), and it did find one nearby me first. the search ahead list did show the one in boston too, further down (i'm super happy they're still around btw). but yah, foo anything is like a box of chocolates. you just never know what you're gonna get!
- dkjaudyeqooe 4y agoDitto when you're specifying a target for routing: "Ok lets just zoom you out a hundred kilometers..."
- dont__panic 4y agoDoesn't matter how good their POI data is if they pollute the search results with Dunkin Donuts, Arby's, Burger King, McDonald's, and any other godforsaken chain restaurant who pays to be first in line. Especially on mobile, I find it very, very difficult to look through restaurant matches that search my criteria because: - Maps won't show all of the results in the map view - Maps prioritizes these kinds of chains that pay good money over more relevant restaurants (for instance, I searched "Cafe" in Boston last week, and both McDonalds and Dunkin Donuts were among the top 5 results. Not exactly the most relevant results) - no matter how much you zoom in, Maps just won't show you certain businesses. I'm not sure if they haven't payed up enough protection money to Google, or if the business listing isn't optimized, or what... but it's a crap experience when I know there's a great business in a general area but every time I search, Google zooms me out to shove Wendy's in my face Do other people experience these same issues with Google Maps? Am I somehow using the product wrong? I've been trying to contribute to OSM and use it instead when possible, but the POI data just isn't quite complete enough... and businesses almost never update their own hours on OSM.