4 ms·
A Lagrangian is like newtons equation, its a description of the system, you don't have any mathematical definition for it since it is a law of physics and not m
by Jensson 4y ago
A Lagrangian is like newtons equation, its a description of the system, you don't have any mathematical definition for it since it is a law of physics and not maths.
Edit:
> but each subsystem's world line curves to achieve SOME property. What is this property?
You have to provide that as a part of the explanation of the system. Lagrangians are just dumb functions, you have to be smart about how you choose them, there is no magic here you just have to understand the physics and construct the Lagrangian that has whatever properties you want.
- sixo 4y agoI'm pretty sure you're answering a different question. I'm saying: - it appears that the "stationary action" is the same as "worldline follows a geodesic of the spacetime metric" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relativistic_Lagrangian_mechanics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relativistic_Lagrangian_mechan...). I first heard this from a particle physics professor in undergrad. - for a compound system, the individual elements follow worldline geodesics, with the other particles factored out into a "potential" / as force terms in E-L equation. These represent how 1 particle, when distorted from its non-interacting trajectory, trades off against the other particles distorting from their OWN free trajectories. It's analogous to how heat energy flows between two systems to maximize their joint entropy; here, the particles' trajectories distort each other via forces to minimize their joint spacetime arc length. (As measured, presumably, in ANY reference frame) - yes, in any specific context, the Lagrangian represents HOW those things trade off, in the same way that in any specific thermodynamics scenario the microstate structure can tell us d(entropy)/d(energy) and let us compute the equilibrium state. - but how to complete the analogy to thermodynamic equilibrium--what is the "temperature", exactly, what is "heat"? In a QFT context, the interaction is ITSELF a particle, and has its own contribution to the Lagrangian and action, but how to think about it classically? It has always seemed to me that this line of thinking is the most natural way to express "Stationary Action".