4 ms·
As a blogger whose articles occasionally become popular on HN, my main complaint is that HN commenters don't apply the same guidelines to article authors that t
by lapcat 4y ago
As a blogger whose articles occasionally become popular on HN, my main complaint is that HN commenters don't apply the same guidelines to article authors that they do to each other. There's a double standard. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
Of course HN commenters don't always follow the guidelines with each other either, but it's at least an aspiration, and the moderators will step in if there are major violations. But there seems to be no such protection for article authors.
I've found that the best way to keep HN commenters from becoming too dismissive and/or vicious is to step in and reply myself to comments on my articles. It shouldn't have to be that way, but that's the way it is now.
[Edit] Example here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32401086 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32401086
- dang 4y agoWe definitely try to moderate the same way. For example personal attacks on authors are no more ok than personal attacks on fellow commenters; shallow dismissals of other people's work are not ok (regardless of whose work it is), and so on. The limit on this is just that (many) people don't follow the guidelines in either case, no matter how often we repeat them. I do think you're right that there's an tendency to be harsher on authors, though—because it feels like they're not "in the room". It's like gossip: we're all looser-lipped when someone's not around. That would explain your observation that the comments change once you show up as a commenter in the thread about your article. Gossip mutes itself when the person being gossiped about walks in. The trouble, of course, is that on the internet this is an illusion. The author is "in the room", or soon will be after they track the referring URL of all the traffic. Then they show up and get to hear all the things people were saying when they "weren't there".
- nicbou 4y agoAnd you're doing a fantastic job at moderating this place. Even when I got flagged, I had to concede that it was well-deserved. What's surprising is that you managed to do this without fueling a constant meta discussion about how bad the moderators are. You somehow manage to please everyone. As a former community mod, I'm impressed.