2 ms·
> Aren't we more than that? I don't think so. I think that we're a brew made of very simple ingredients that results in something that strives to live and repr
by pessimizer 4y ago
> Aren't we more than that?
I don't think so. I think that we're a brew made of very simple ingredients that results in something that strives to live and reproduce. That's the main missing ingredient in AI for me; desire, or preferences. We just show them a bunch of things in turn, and tell them if they're right or wrong with some reduction of those things. They don't even desire our approval, we've built systems that process, they don't desire.
I think it's because we've nearly figured out cognition (which is ultimately simple), but not the desire to live or to reproduce (which as people we half the time think of as sinful desires), which we probably have deeply hardcoded within ourselves. The desire to emulate others derives from those more fundamental desires (without which we each wouldn't have existed in an unbroken lineage from the first cell), because we can look at others as experiments to model ourselves after, or when we see them fail, make guesses as to how they may have been mistaken in their choices.
We're physical things. The really mysterious part of our situation imo is how our perspective (for lack of a better word) attaches to our bodies (and minds.) Why am I me and not you? Why am I physically located in this mind? Would a perspective attach to a machine with cognition and desires? Would there be any physical way to prove that one hadn't, so would we morally just have to accept a machine's experience as similar to ours? We can't prove other people aren't machines, so we (generally, with extreme difficulty with people very unlike us) just take them at their word.
That's actually a reason I'm against full AI, because it involves creating a bunch of machines that we wouldn't have the moral authority to shut down. Especially if we haven't refined the technology and it's just as power-inefficient as what we have now. Sparking neural networks where electricity isn't used for the signal, just as a potential within the cell walls, and the spark is a little cough of neurotransmitter that is immediately sucked back in. That's just unbelievably low power (even though iirc it's still half or more of the calories you eat.) And brains are so space-efficient. I could cram 100 people in a room full of one AI, and the 100 people would consume fewer calories.
We're accidental automatons that are very cool and very difficult to reproduce, and still very mysterious in a fundamental way.