2 ms·
The lack of political will you speak of is better seen as a reaction to the deeper problem that there is no political will for protections that would go against
by mindslight 4y ago
The lack of political will you speak of is better seen as a reaction to the deeper problem that there is no political will for protections that would go against commercial desires. Social security numbers were created solely to facilitate social security but had no legal protections enforcing this, and thus are now being widely abused by private companies. The same with driver's license numbers. Without a US GDPR that gives me the right to delete my permanent records from corporate surveillance databases, I am dead set against government mandates that would create even more vulnerabilities for unaccountable surveillance companies to exploit.
- pessimizer 4y agoOr vulnerablities for fully accountable governments to exploit, either. Governments may be accountable to their supporters, but they're not necessarily accountable to me. They could decide tomorrow that it's illegal to be Jewish or to have been descended from Jews, and they have before.
- mindslight 4y agoThat's a much stronger argument, that I'm indeed sympathetic to. But I don't think it will ever win in the courts of public opinion or practicality. In general, governments are always going to demand some way to identify and enumerate their citizens, and so making that a deliberate thing rather than an emergent thing allows it to be better constrained. If involuntary storage of personal information were limited to bona fide government purposes then, for instance, we could politically complain when the government wanted to catalog everyone's ethnicity/religion in their databases. As it stands currently, the government itself doesn't need to abuse the vulnerabilities like in your example, because at any time they can get that information from companies who have done so for them.
- pessimizer 4y ago> In general, governments are always going to demand some way to identify and enumerate their citizens I think that this is something that has only become insisted upon in very recent history (when it was seen as a technical and social possibility), and that governments functioned just as well without. Ways of identifying strangers should be annoying, tedious, and expensive. edit: When I was a kid, you could spend a week in jail and be released without the justice system having any way to verify who you were. edit: What I'm really saying is that the "national identity verification type service" is as much a problem as the corporate databases, which it's also not really distinct from (the corporate databases work as a national identity verification service.) The problem is this desire to account for and control everything. Everyone with a little power is overcome with data FOMO.