3 ms·
> I just want to emphasize that robotics in uncontrolled environments is very very hard. I'm not sure what convinced you I was making this argument. My exampl
by godelski 4y ago
> I just want to emphasize that robotics in uncontrolled environments is very very hard.
I'm not sure what convinced you I was making this argument. My example was illustrative as a counter to *your example* of determining a specific dog breed. I'm trying to show an easier problem. But "easier" is comparative and doesn't mean the problem is "easy." I'm guessing this is the confusion? Let's be real, figuring out the dog breed by determining dog hair from other debris is substantially harder and I'm pretty sure you'd need a DNA scan. It would be near impossible (probably entirely) to differentiate hair of any type with current sensors. I don't actually think the shoe example is extremely hard considering these robots have lidar on them. Lidar can in fact tell you that something is roughly shoe shaped, so I'm not sure what your gripe is. No need for DNA scanning. No need for cameras or microphones. The problem is likely solvable given *existing instruments on commercially sold products.* This, again, doesn't mean the problem is "easy" though. Just that it can be solved.
> How much money will you make improving shoe rack recommendations by 2.5%?
Okay, but I'm assuming there's more than exactly one singular problem that the mapping can be solve. So I'm not sure what your point is.
Let's try a trivial example. One that *is easy* and will demonstrate that we can sell things beyond shoe racks with said data. Knowing the (approximate) square footage of your house is useful. For example, if you live in a 500sqft place, you can tell a lot about income because we know this is likely a small apartment. You probably can't afford a lot of stuff and Amazon probably shouldn't advertise luxury goods to you, especially large ones.
> Now, imagine putting the same number of statistics people, such as yourself, on a team in Amazon Healthcare.
I'm not sure why you're pigeon holling me and making this a zero sum game. I'm actively arguing an "and" position, not an "or" position. Yeah, health care is lucrative. But Amazon has an insane amount of wealth, more than they actually know what to do with. They are perfectly capable of being able to hire more than 200 positions for their robotics department, which is what they advertise on their robotics site. They are perfectly capable of increasing this number without taking away any funding from their health care side (not a zero sum game). I'd also assume that there's a significant amount of domain overlap considering that Roombas. Mapping warehouses is a pretty similar problem to mapping houses, so I'm not sure what the problem is.