4 ms·
Debit cards and credit cards are very different things, functionally, legally, and practically, though they can be implemented similarly on a technical level.
by gamblor956 4y ago
Debit cards and credit cards are very different things, functionally, legally, and practically, though they can be implemented similarly on a technical level.
Debit card transactions, legally and financially, withdraw money from the associated bank account at the time of the transaction. The only limit on the amount that can be debited is the amount of money in the associated bank account. If there is insufficient money, the transaction fails. The debit card user is at risk for losses due to fraud or payment disputes. Basically, a debit card is the same as cash but in a convenient thin plastic card form.
A credit card transaction, legally and financially, withdraws money from the issuing bank, who then adds that amount to a debt ledger of money owed by the card user to the bank. The transaction only fails if the transaction would exceed an arbitrary credit limit as determined by the bank. The credit card user pays back the debt at the end of the month, or over time, based on the terms of the credit card agreement. The issuing bank is at risk for losses due to fraud or payment disputes. Basically, a credit card is the same as a short-term instantaneous loan agreement, but in the form of a single convenient thing plastic card instead of a dozen or more paper loan agreements.
- Nextgrid 4y agoWhat you mention are all policy/regulatory differences, which can be made to apply to debit cards if there's will to do so. My point is that the credit card concept now survives because there's no will to kill it off since it's a convenient way to siphon money from the pool/less-financially-savvy to the well off.
- gamblor956 4y agoNo, you're still not getting it. They aren't simply policy/regulatory differences. They are fundamental differences in what debit cards and credit cards are. One is a cash equivalent and one is a loan equivalent, and no amount of handwaving are going to make those the same thing. My point is that the credit card concept now survives because there's no will to kill it off since it's a convenient way to siphon money from the pool/less-financially-savvy to the well off. This is simply false and indicates a lack of understanding in what loans are or how credit cards work. Credit cards survive just fine in Europe without the points and other benefits.