4 ms·
It's been 45 minutes and I'm still waiting for my Bitcoin transaction to go through. BTC and Crypto at large don't seem like a viable alternative solution, or
by metadat 4y ago
It's been 45 minutes and I'm still waiting for my Bitcoin transaction to go through.
BTC and Crypto at large don't seem like a viable alternative solution, or even a solution to any real problem at all.
- xur17 4y ago> This sounds exactly why people like Jack Dorsey are pushing for bitcoin + lightning network adoption. The solution was in the message you replied to.
- anonporridge 4y agoDo we seriously still have to deal with this criticism in 2022? Come on man. Educate yourself about the bitcoin layer 2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7bOo3zLFhEk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7bOo3zLFhEk For small payments, lightning is instant and extremely low fee. For larger payments that you want certainty of settlement, even a few hours confirmation time is drastically superior to traditional settlement networks that take days if not weeks internationally. FYI, your credit card payments are instant, but not finally settled. That happens in periodic bulk batches between banks. https://www.swanbitcoin.com/a-look-at-the-lightning-network/ https://www.swanbitcoin.com/a-look-at-the-lightning-network/ Even the Fed is on top of trying to understand this, https://www.clevelandfed.org/~/media/content/newsroom%20and%20events/publications/working%20papers/2022/wp2219.pdf https://www.clevelandfed.org/~/media/content/newsroom%20and%...
- avianlyric 4y agoEh, in the UK I already have instantaneous bank transfers that are free for normal retail customers to use. Money arrives instantly, and as far as a retail customer is concerned, it settles instantly. Under the hood their regular batch settlement between banks, but that doesn’t matter to a retail customer, because the money is instantly withdraw-able, and covered by government deposit protection the moment the faster payment appears on your bank statement (which is milliseconds after the payment is initiated by the sender). Why would I want to mess around with Bitcoins, when I already have access to fast, secure, cheap, money transfers to any UK bank account?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lifty 4y agoWhat if you want to buy something from outside UK?
- ipaddr 4y agoSometimes you need to pay someone outside of the UK. Maybe you want to purchase something online. Perhaps you don't want to share your bank account with a stranger.
- ceejayoz 4y agoPeople did all this long before Bitcoin.
- tossl568 4y agoDigitally, without fees, with a fair exchange rate? With no limits on transaction sizes, with complete finality?
- ryan_lane 4y ago> Digitally With the exception of stores that are cash only, 100% of my money movements in the past 10 years have been digital, from my perspective. The actual money movement technology doesn't really matter to me, as long as I can do it online. Excluding settlement times (which I don't notice, unless I'm doing a wire transfer), as a consumer there's no difference. > without fees With bitcoin, you're paying fees per-transaction for bitcoin itself, and both parties are paying fees to move money to/from fiat. Wire transfers for large transfers may be slower, but they're absolutely cheaper than bitcoin. Bitcoin is considerably more expensive for small payments. > with a fair exchange rate With the fluctuations in price in bitcoin, the exchange rate is rarely fair and almost always worse than fiat. Note that there's lots of cards that don't charge foreign transaction fees, and have quite competitive exchange rates. To point it out again, using bitcoin requires two fiat exchanges, each of which charge fees and each of which has an exchange rate that the exchange is profiting from. If you're transferring fiat of the same currency, there's no fees and no exchange rate. Even if your transaction is between two fiat currencies, bitcoin is worse, because there's one extra layer of fees and exchange. > With no limits on transaction sizes I can't think of a time in which I've hit a transaction size limit. Who is this feature for? Transaction size limits exist primarily to protect people. If my card is compromised, it won't result in 100% of my money immediately (and irreversibly) being transferred away. > with complete finality This is an anti-selling point. If my money is stolen, I want to be able to get it back. If I typo an account number when I send a payment, I want to be able to reverse that payment.
- metafunctor 4y agoSellers obviously want certain settlement for all purchases regardless of amount. If bitcoin needs a similarly hierarchical trust-based settlement systems as banks, how is that different from traditional banking?
- kevinak 4y agoThat is not what the lightning network is though - it is trustless, just like the baselayer.
- hinkley 4y agoDo you seriously think that's an educational video? The second link follows the Wadsworth Constant in fabulous fashion. https://www.swanbitcoin.com/a-look-at-the-lightning-network/#Where-Most-Cryptocurrencies-Went-Wrong https://www.swanbitcoin.com/a-look-at-the-lightning-network/... is almost exactly 30% of the way down the page. > 1 hour 31 minutes read In rhetoric we call this 'assigning homework' and it's considered deflecting, aka, trying to get out of jail free, aka, poor form, aka, you lost the argument. I'm sure we can do better than either of these for educational material. If that's the best that exists, which I hope is far from the case, then this is essentially a "git gud scrub" situation and you have yourselves to blame for the unwashed masses still not understanding things.
- fshbbdssbbgdd 4y agoWhat factors are holding back adoption of lighting? I’ve come across Bitcoin as a payment option before when making some purchases, but I don’t think I’ve ever seen lightning.
- tossl568 4y agoExchanges are more interested in running their shitcoin casinos and making money off gambling trading fees. Some even skim off their users for withdrawal fees like crypto.com. There's not much incentive to implement something that won't make them money.
- jonathan-adly 4y agovery uninformed take - they specifically mentioned the lighting network where transactions happen as fast as VISA/Mastercard.
- metadat 4y agoWhat good is a transaction without guaranteed settlement?
- jonathan-adly 4y agoVisa/Mastercard are not guaranteed settlements…
- metadat 4y agoVisa/MC have phone numbers you can call for support and dispute resolution. What happens for BTC lightning?
- kelseyfrog 4y agoYou still call a number for support: 988.
- metadat 4y ago988 is the suicide hotline..
- kelseyfrog 4y agoAnyone who overcommits to crypto should have a crisis plan in place in the event of disaster.
- kevinak 4y agoSo… you want guaranteed settlement but at the same time the ability to reverse a transaction? How do you propose that would work?
- Melting_Harps 4y ago> It's been 45 minutes and I'm still waiting for my Bitcoin transaction to go through. At this point, and given HN's POV on BTC, I can't take these statements serious unless you are willing to post the tx hash? Most of these criticisms seem to be unfounded and only speculative, or you deliberately put a low priority mining fee and feel the need to blame the protocol for that. The truth is a 30 cent mining fee was clearing all day in the next block, so I struggle to see how this is the fault of Bitcoin mainchain. With that said, as someone already mentioned, LN txs are instant and near free.