12 ms·
GitHub suspends Tornado Cash developer account
- marcell 4y agoContract is accessible via generic tools like Etherscan, eg.: https://etherscan.io/address/0x722122df12d4e14e13ac3b6895a86e84145b6967 https://etherscan.io/address/0x722122df12d4e14e13ac3b6895a86...
- timcavel 4y ago
- rvz 4y agoA great time to finally consider self-hosting.
- jeffbee 4y agoIf you're an international criminal conspiracy you should definitely consider it.
- capableweb 4y agoWhat if I'm just a OSS author? Do I need to consider it too? Judging by what's happening right now, if I'd live in the US, I'd definitely be concerned right now. I hope I'm not gonna be put on a list of sanctions just because I chose to publish my software as MIT and some criminal happens to use it.
- hnthrow1010 4y agoAre you making software that has the explicit stated purpose of facilitating illegal money laundering, like these crypto mixers openly say they do? If not, then you don't have anything to worry about from these sanctions.
- Jabrov 4y ago“Are you doing anything illegal? If not, then you don’t have to worry about surveillance.”
- kevingadd 4y agoThis isn't warrantless surveillance, it's people breaking the law in the open. You can believe tornado cash should be legal but still, be realistic: Most OSS doesn't have tornado cash's risk profile
- capableweb 4y agoTornado Cash has never been for the "explicit stated purpose of facilitating illegal money laundering" but for being able to remain private about what transactions you make on the blockchain. As long as you file your taxes correctly, it wouldn't be illegal to use services like Tornado Cash. Plenty of people use services like that to move funds from their cold wallet to their hot one, in order to not make visible to the public how much funds they have. Again, as long as you properly file taxes, this should not be a issue. And yeah, some people do work on privacy-preserving services that can and will be used for bad purposes. Anything involving E2E encryption is usually made for privacy reasons, is this bad enough for you to say the same thing about it? What about things that can be used to skirt copyright like youtube-dl, do they deserve the same treatment?
- tablespoon 4y ago> Tornado Cash has never been for the "explicit stated purpose of facilitating illegal money laundering" but for being able to remain private about what transactions you make on the blockchain. Isn't that literally what money laundering is? > As long as you file your taxes correctly, it wouldn't be illegal to use services like Tornado Cash. IIRC, money laundering businesses pay their taxes too (e.g. the Breaking Bad car wash pretended the drug profits came from washing cars, and paid taxes those "car washing" profits).
- carlosdp 4y ago
- froh_away 4y agoActually you can just hide it in another repository. Steganography makes fools out of infotyrants.
- rvz 4y agoYou do realise what you have just said was incredibly silly? I hope you weren't part of the 'criminals' crying about youtube-dl being suspended by GitHub in 2020: [0]. So GNOME [1], WireGuard [2], The Linux Kernel [3], Mozilla [4] and ReactOS [5] and Tor Project [6] are all 'criminals' for self hosting their own projects on their own servers rather than being forced to host it on GitHub? Surely they all know that GitHub can take their repositories down for any reason. If they all announced that they are going all in on GitHub, what is the whole point of supporting 'free software' in the first place? [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24872911 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24872911 [1] https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME [2] https://git.zx2c4.com/ https://git.zx2c4.com/ [3] https://git.kernel.org/ https://git.kernel.org/ [4] https://hg.mozilla.org/ https://hg.mozilla.org/ [5] https://git.reactos.org https://git.reactos.org [6] https://gitlab.torproject.org/tpo/web/tpo https://gitlab.torproject.org/tpo/web/tpo
- viro 4y agoDo you understand how long, you can go to jail for violating sanctions?
- emmab 4y agoThere's no disobedience like civil disobedience. All the best things in life are illegal. Long live anarchy! Fire to the prisons! Information wants to be free! ACAB! Eat the police!
- albatross13 4y agoWho are you gonna call when someone comes to eat you? Surely not the police.
- rvz 4y agoGitHub understands that and they are within their right to take down repositories that are violating sanctions. So you're talking to projects like Tor, Signal (who repeatedly attempted to violate sanctions [0]) Matrix, etc which have been used to evade sanctions. For any project that is self-hosting, like Tor which allows criminals, scammers and money launderers to access the internet and the 'dark web' and bypass sanctions with high anonymity and are self-hosting at [0]. Perhaps the FBI should 'take them down' immediately? What are they waiting for then? [0] https://signal.org/blog/looking-back-on-the-front/ https://signal.org/blog/looking-back-on-the-front/ [1] https://gitlab.torproject.org/tpo/web/tpo https://gitlab.torproject.org/tpo/web/tpo
- wyxuan 4y agoTornado Cash repo+website taken down as well[0], and so have many of the GH accounts that were contributors to the repo[1]. [0] https://twitter.com/w_y_x/status/1556716055296294914?s=21&t=3ce_KjS5AwTb-SP9hiqF-Q https://twitter.com/w_y_x/status/1556716055296294914?s=21&t=... [1] https://twitter.com/bantg/status/1556721709931175937?s=21&t=3ce_KjS5AwTb-SP9hiqF-Q https://twitter.com/bantg/status/1556721709931175937?s=21&t=...
- altairprime 4y agoRelated, today: “U.S. Treasury Sanctions Virtual Currency Mixer Tornado Cash” https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32386189 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32386189 Specifically: > all property and interests in property of the entity above, Tornado Cash, that is in the United States or in the possession or control of U.S. persons is blocked and must be reported to OFAC.
- capableweb 4y agoThis is the first time open source tool/software (not even a business) has been put on the SDN list. Previous entries have all been either people or businesses. I don't live in the US, but if I were, I'd reconsider publishing OSS right now. I don't know all the users of my software, and I wouldn't want to risk being put on any lists like the SDN.
- kevingadd 4y agoBe realistic here, are you distributing oss that exists for the sole purpose of money laundering? I don't have a strong opinion on whether tornado cash should be allowed to exist, but it's obvious that it violates US law. Similarly if you distribute OSS viruses don't act shocked if people want to harass you over it - distributing viruses is illegal in some places
- capableweb 4y ago> Be realistic here, are you distributing oss that exists for the sole purpose of money laundering? I am not, and neither are the authors of Tornado Cash. There is legitimate purposes to use privacy-preserving services. As long as I file my taxes correctly, I should be able to use them as I wish. > but it's obvious that it violates US law Since they got added to the SDN list, it's obvious yes. But before that, why it is obvious? Again, as long as I file my taxes correctly with the IRS, there shouldn't be a problem with using services like this.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pearjuice 4y agoWondering when majority of KYC-enforced exchanges also start banning and seizing assets of all users who ever interacted with tornado cash. Then, if you relay someone Ethereum via tornado cash you can potentially blacklist their public facing wallet without them ever giving consent. Going to be a regulatory nightmare.
- miohtama 4y agoThey have been doing this for long time. However Tornado Cash came with a compliance tool that allows you to disclose your transactions to third parties and prove they are clean. Similar with Monero, ZCash.
- londons_explore 4y agoSuch a tool seems like a bad idea for the same reason you aren't allowed to take photos of your ballot paper in an election... If you did, then someone can blackmail you to see said paper.
- jakelazaroff 4y agoIf that tool doesn't exist, how will you respond when the government tells you to prove the source of funds you got from Tornado Cash?
- londons_explore 4y agoSame way you do when the government asks you to prove the source of a pile of actual paper cash. You have an invoice or receipt or bill to show. And the government could go ask the person who wrote said invoice/receipt/bill to confirm its legitimacy.
- Animats 4y agoThat's bad. Lock it against changes, maybe. But not take it down. Now we need to keep local backups of every library we use, just in case.
- kevingadd 4y agoYou already should be vendoring your own libraries for safety and build reliability.
- dcow 4y agoIf the code was released in the public domain instead of a under a permissive license, could it still be argued that it is the property of the sanctioned entity?
- scoopertrooper 4y agoTo my understanding, the only way for a work to be truly public domain is for the copyright to expire. Anything else is just a permissive license.
- blooalien 4y agoI believe the copyright holder can willingly relinquish their copyright to a thing by explicitly declaring their thing to be "cc-0 licensed" or "public domain", or other explicit declaration of giving it away entirely and completely "no strings attached" thereby giving the thing freely to "the commons" to be used by anyone as they see fit.
- Ndymium 4y agoDedicating work to the public domain is not possible in many jurisdictions, which is the reason for CC-0 and similar licenses. They're "close enough" for practical purposes but they're not the same thing. Even if you use CC-0, you will still have the copyright of the work in such jurisdictions, because it is only an attempt to give up as many rights as possible.
- ehathaway 4y agoIt's frustrating to hear crypto twitter talk about how the contract is neutral and "just tech". It marginalizes the fact that there is active governance of the code and smart contract. People are in control of these things and their objective can be misaligned with society. Nothing guarantees that the tech is neutral.
- carlosdp 4y agoThe Tornado Cash contract is immutable, there is no active governance component for that protocol. It isn't possible to stop it from functioning after deployment, except to stop the chain it is running on. The governance you are referring to is some auxiliary support stuff, like anonymity mining.
- ehathaway 4y agoThat doesn't seem right. They link this diagram in their docs that show the parts of the contract that can be controlled by governance: https://viewer.diagrams.net/?highlight=0000ff&edit=_blank&layers=1&nav=1&title=tornado-cash-contract-overview.drawio#Uhttps%3A%2F%2Fraw.githubusercontent.com%2FRezan-vm%2Ftornado-cash-edu%2Fmain%2Ftornado-cash-contract-overview.drawio https://viewer.diagrams.net/?highlight=0000ff&edit=_blank&la...
- carlosdp 4y agoI don't know when or where that is from, all I know for certain is that for at least 2 years now, the contracts have been immutable and non-upgradeable, by anybody. Edit: also idk where you're seeing the governance component in that flow you linked, there doesn't appear to be one...
- lizardactivist 4y agoAt this point there is a real risk he will become a target of made-up charges, and that the US gov will attempt to have him extradited and jailed just to send a message. He is writing fin-tech FOSS, but because that software and the space it targets is not fully under US gov control, his well-being and entire future is now at risk. This is not the freedom the US keeps talking about. It is tyranny.
- WheatM 4y ago
- viro 4y agowhat use outside of money laundering did this tool have?
- luxuryballs 4y agomaybe some government could use it for doing secret spy stuff
- ragona 4y agoThere are entities other than the government that you might want to hide money from.
- jedimind 4y agoFor privacy. It's like asking what SSL is good for other than criminal activity. Vitalik himself used tornado cash for private transactions. Do you think that Vitalik openly launders money?
- ShaneMcGowan 4y agoA tool that could be used for laundering money was used for laundering money. Developer is shocked that the US Government doesn’t like this
- DennisP 4y agoMeanwhile a hammer was used to bash someone's head in.
- viro 4y agowhat use outside of money laundering did this tool have?
- ShaneMcGowan 4y agoAnonymising the purchase of hammers
- carlosdp 4y agoHaving private transactions using a public blockchain ledger. It's the same as asking "why do people need E2E encrypted chat," because they want to and there's nothing wrong with them not wanting you to read their chats, that's why.
- kevingadd 4y agoThat is a reason to launder money, it's still money laundering. It's valid to believe that this justifies money laundering and to believe that money laundering should be legal, but it is what it is.
- carlosdp 4y agoMoney laundering is the act of hiding the source of funds from *illegal activity*, all my funds that I want to privately transact with are legitimately earned.