4 ms·
I think the real innovation will come up from small sizes, drone to urban air taxi to regional island hopper. Those seem to have a bit more room to throw out t
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
I think the real innovation will come up from small sizes, drone to urban air taxi to regional island hopper.
Those seem to have a bit more room to throw out the rulebook and try some crazy stuff to take full advantage of electric motors.
Meanwhile the long range jets are likely to use a blend of e-kerosene made from green hydrogen in the short to medium term as it lets you gently reduce carbon without going too crazy.
Worth noting that for the medium range, hydrogen burning jets and e-kerosene have non-carbon GHG issues too, so scaled up small electric with hydrogen range extenders seems like a contender for the medium range because they avoid that.
Some of the interesting side effects of this transition are from moving from a hub-spoke model to a short hop network.
- jillesvangurp 4y agoExactly. The main reasons for the way aviation works today are economical. Large planes are more fuel efficient and fuel is very expensive. When fuel becomes very cheap (for example because of dramatically lower electricity prices), this changes dramatically. Large, complicated, expensive planes stop making sense. For short hops, battery electric is going to dominate. It's the simplest and the cheapest to implement. And unlike jets, smaller is more efficient for those anyway. Instead of carrying people in batches of a few hundred, transporting them in small groups would be both cheaper and more flexible. More runways / pads that you can fly to. Cheap manufacturing cost and mass production. Low complexity. And if we automate the need for human pilots away, these things will basically fly at a very low marginal cost (kwh of electricity + inspections/maintenance). IMHO for longer ranges, there may need to be some fuel cell or combustion engine based alternatives. Hydrogen is one option. A more logical option would be methane. Much easier to handle, only slightly worse energy density (and well offset by the lack of a need for heavy tanks), easy to source both the traditional way or by synthesizing it. Can work in both fuel cells, piston engines or jets/turbo props. Even synthetic kerosene might be better (there are companies working on that). The key challenges all of these share currently is 1) availability: lots of prototypes but no volume production of anything yet 2) logistics: most airports are not equipped for this 3) access to cheap renewable energy to synthesize the fuel or power the batteries.