3 ms·
If think Society is changing and we have to change radicaly to not end up in big social troubles (class wars ...). --------------------------------------------
by nickik 15y ago
If think Society is changing and we have to change radicaly to not end up in big social troubles (class wars ...).
-------------------------------------------------
(Im talk about a system for Switzerland)
I propose a "basic income" no strings attached (Everybody gets X$ per month and all wages are reduced by X$ is the short version of how it works) with this we replace all the diffrent social systems we have nowdays (money for kids, unemployment, AHV (money for the retired ...).
This will liberate people in the sence that they don't have to hang on to there jobs even if they are badly treated, they wont be social outcasts if they dont have a job.
instead give them insentives to improve there education (and thereby you could then get a job in a high tec economy), to be more entrepreneurial (find out what people really need and trie to provid it).
A more importend example for the people here is app marked development. App marked made it possible to start a project in a small team and make money relativly fast. The insentive to trie something like this is much greater and you can't fall that far.
It may not be the best model in pure economic groth terms but I hope it is a good model for a sustainable healthy society in a world where it is very hard to have full employment (because the economy changes to fast).
- ctdonath 15y agoMost people, given a no-strings-attached basic income, will NOT use it as an opportunity to educate themselves and become entrepreneurial; instead, they get LAZY and fiercely protective of that state. Not having a job isn't about being a social outcast, it's about not producing enough value/wealth to exchange for the cost of continuing existence. As an old book famously observed, "He who does not work, neither shall he eat"; that's not punitive, that's the economics of biology.
- pi18n 15y agoWhat happens if you make the stipend contingent on educating yourself somehow?
- randomdata 15y agoEducation is a symptom of value creation, not the cause of it. In other words, education alone brings no value to society. If there is no incentive to create value, because you are already given an income with no strings attached, that education will not be put to any meaningful use. It seems to me that the stipend would need to be based on a plan to create value for society. If some level of education is required in order to proceed with that plan, it could be granted as part of the implementation. This reasonably mirrors the way entrepreneurs operate, which is essentially what we want to duplicate. The dream always comes before the education. The education is only a means to an end.
- nickik 15y agoWell education by itself creats value for you and the people you talk. It not socialism, when you acctully learn something/do something you will be able to get more.
- ctdonath 15y agoYou have to want to create value. As a teacher, I am amazed at how many students lack the will to create, to do the work - and they fail at great cost.
- chc 15y agoThen you get a rush on Underwater Basket Weaving 101. California allows young adults to continue getting their parents' benefits until their late 20s if they're in school. This does not actually encourage people to get a useful eight-year education.
- jerf 15y agoThen it will be gamed, with whatever minimal thing will satisfy "the system". And that's the answer to pretty every other "well, what if we put this requirement in" question, because the root problem is that you've created an incentive to put whatever minimal work will make the system happy, even if it means breaking the putative formal rules. People are smart, and you can't create a system with bad incentives and then just legislate the bad incentives away, because the mass of people you're trying to legislate is smarter and has way more time than you do. I am intrigued by the question of how income would be distributed in a still-hypothetical post-industrial world, but I fear the easy answer of just giving people a certain minimal income can't be made to work, which is unfortunate because I haven't got a better answer any more than anybody else does....
- nickik 15y agoWell see (at least in Switzerland and other European Staats) we allready giving people money if the dont have a job and we make them do stuff like "send in 20 application" or force them to go into some stupid class where you have to learn something you don't like doing for a week and then you can go back home and chill. I am pretty liberarian but just like Hayek I think one function of the state is help pure people. You could never get a law past that basiclly says "He who does not work, neither shall he eat". Here in Switzerland pretty much everybody agreeds that helping the pure threw the staat is a good thing. The system im proposing would at least be (a) fair (b) be much much much less complicated does getting read of a lot of human workforce that is no bound up in stupid jobs pushing around papers. I would say the insentives to work are still there, this is not sozialim, im not taling about a basic income of min. wage or something.
- ideaoverload 15y ago"I propose a 'basic income' no strings attached" Karl Marx would be happy to hear that. If you implement your idea then small fraction of society would use their free time to learn, read books, follow their passion or improve the world. Much larger fraction would concentrate on pleasant but much less challenging aspects of life like partying/booze/drugs/sex/good food/watching tv/browsing net. [Edit:spelling]
- chc 15y agoI think in practice this wouldn't look all that different from the way things are today.
- nickik 15y agoI think he would not be happy about that because marx thought that all money is only there to dominate the proletariat. Im not proposing giving everybody tonnes of money. Im talking about a effective system to help the poor. I and most other people think that one of the things the stat has to do is to help poor people. Nowdays we do this in a really bad way and we make it really hard for them to get out off the system. Why would somebody that is unemployed talk a low paying job? He would because its not worth it if you get only a little be more money then when you stay unemployed and if they loose the job it talkes more then a month to get money again. Its economicly speaking extremly stupid way to do welfair. Friedmans negativ income tax was much better because you allways have more then you would if you didn't work but that system has some other problems. If you can come up with a better system tell it to me. If you think that the state should not be doing that at all say so. Dont tell im a marxist when I acctually stated that the idea is partly dirived from hayek. Hayek wrote one of the most inflential books against socialist ideas (the road to serfdom).