5 ms·
"Like most people, questions about the existence of God and all things spiritual plague me frequently. I want to believe in such things, especially when it come
by jgrahamc 15y ago
"Like most people, questions about the existence of God and all things spiritual plague me frequently. I want to believe in such things, especially when it comes to continuity of my consciousness. I don’t like the idea of disappearing when I die."
One way to address this is to deal with these thoughts rather than entering a philosophical rat hole of trying to simulate our existence and find an analogy to the computer. Once you accept that an outside meta-influence is possible then you don't have to worry about all this "is there a God or not?" If God exists then God has powers that make Him imperceptible; if God doesn't exist then He's imperceptible. You can't tell the difference.
Oh well.
Better to live a life of good deeds and actions then worry about what's next.
- euroclydon 15y agoGreat point up to the last sentance which, whether you intended to or not, draws a line between the worlds major religions and quasi-endorses those on one side.
- eggnet 15y agoWhat major religion doesn't endorse good deeds?
- euroclydon 15y agoSend me an email and I'll explain.
- acuozzo 15y ago> If God exists then God has powers that make Him imperceptible; if God doesn't exist then He's imperceptible. You can't tell the difference. This is the omnipotence paradox[1]. I often help friends and relatives understand why my religion (or lack thereof, actually) is `Tooth Fairy Agnosticism' by asking them whether or not God can create a stone that He can't lift. > Better to live a life of good deeds and actions then worry about what's next. I agree. This is how I try to live my life, but it's hard to stop worrying when you have severe thanatophobia[2] like I do. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omnipotence_paradox http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omnipotence_paradox [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thanatophobia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thanatophobia
- TheRevoltingX 15y ago> This is the omnipotence paradox[1]. I often help friends and relatives understand why my religion (or lack thereof, actually) is `Tooth Fairy Agnosticism' by asking them whether or not God can create a stone that He can't lift. Lol, I've heard little kids ask that at church. Never heard an adult seriously ask that though, usually just as a gag.
- acuozzo 15y ago> Lol, I've heard little kids ask that at church. Did you happen to overhear any of them getting an answer? I'd love to read about how some church-going parents (guardians?) explain the omnipotence paradox to youngsters. In my experience, at least, I find that Jews treat the matter gracefully while managing to `uphold the faith', if you will. > Never heard an adult seriously ask that though, usually just as a gag. You don't know many Tooth Fairy Agnostics, do you?
- wbhart 15y agoOmnipotence means God has limitless power (or better, his power cannot be improved), not that he can do anything, whether logically impossible or not. This argument is a cavil, not a sound philosophical argument. Consider the set of natural numbers. You (given enough time and patience and brainspace) may have the ability to count up to any specified natural number. That does not imply you have the ability to count all natural numbers. Once you start dealing with infinities, your intuition goes out the window. The natural numbers can be algorithmically generated. Consider streams in Computer Science, for example. But note that the existence of streams does not imply the existence of an actual infinity in the computer's memory, only an algorithm to reach any finite member of the infinite set. As mentioned elsewhere. If God is the first cause of the physical universe, then his existence is necessary (in the philosophical sense) and therefore changeless (in the philosophical sense) and therefore eternal (as his existence is necessary - and he exists entirely apart from time). Once you start to enter into a discussion of infinite things like omnipotence, omniscience, necessary existence, etc, you enter the realm of infinite cardinalities, transfinite induction, the axiom of choice, Hilbert's Hotel, Russel's paradox, and so on. Philosophers have understood the issues regarding God's natural attributes for thousands of years, but only in the last 100 or so years have we had the mathematics to start saying things about infinities that are not nonsensical. Consider that, as a human being, you are only aware of the present. You remember the past, and you have no knowledge of the future. Now imagine a being who is as aware of the past as He is of the present. This is one who calls himself "I am". He says, "before Abraham was, I am". Or, he calls himself the "Alpha and Omega, the Beginning and the End". We aren't talking about a being with changing state and an awareness only of the present, as you or I. We have to be very careful with our intuition when examining such a subject. Only the most rigorous and methodical mathematical argument can hope to establish anything positive or negative about such an entity.