3 ms·
I know so little about this but aren’t fighters much more ballistic in order to be nimble? My loose amateur sense is that a fighter pilot is always flirting wit
by Waterluvian 4y ago
I know so little about this but aren’t fighters much more ballistic in order to be nimble? My loose amateur sense is that a fighter pilot is always flirting with their plane no-longer behaving like a plane and more like a guided missile if they flew it just the slightest wrong (or right?) way.
- lmm 4y agoYou're thinking of something different. Modern (computer-controlled) fighters are aerodynamically unstable because that makes them more manouverable, but that's about being able to turn or spin rather than flying balistically. For traditionally-shaped planes (delta wings work differently) there's a fairly straightforward tradeoff between big wings to increase lift at low speeds and small wings to reduce drag at high speed. Flaps help but there's a limit to how much you can change the shape of a wing in flight. So if you build a plane to go very fast, you tend to end up with a plane that has a high minimum speed as well, which makes take off and especially landing difficult.
- Waterluvian 4y agoThank you. To simplify, are you basically saying that with more unstable wing configurations, at slower speeds the plane simply wants to fall out of the sky rather than glide? Is that sensible to imagine for this topic?
- lmm 4y agoIt's not "unstable", it's low-lift, those are two orthogonal concerns.
- WalterBright 4y agoIt's more likely to stall at the lower speeds and then fall out of the sky.
- mabcat 4y agoStability is how the aircraft reacts to disturbances (control inputs, turbulence, ...). Stable aircraft resist disturbances and settle into going where they're pointed at a predictable speed, so you can let go of the controls and attend to other pilot things. Unstable aircraft, when disturbed, go more and more in the direction of the disturbance. (e.g. a turn gets tighter and tighter, nose oscillates up and down more and more, ...) You need to correct this with more control inputs, but these will also have unstable results. So they only let computers fly unstable aircraft. A car has good stability in turns: it wants to go straight, if there's a bump or you jerk the wheel a bit it still goes straight. If you apply a control input and get a turn, it will let you maintain the turn but it also wants to unwind and go straight. This is stability but not aerodynamic stability. The reason one might want a less-stable aircraft is that stability is the opposite of manoeuverability. Super-stable aircraft like training gliders really resist turning and can feel too much like hard work. As another commenter mentioned the wings don't contribute much to stability. The two big fins at the back (the stabilizers) are the main source. (disclaimer: I fly fixed-wing acft and gliders, barely, and am no physicist.)