14 ms·
It seems like the ugly alternative is that immoral people can profit by not paying expenses that legally and morally, they should pay. But even if it's ugly, th
by skybrian 4y ago
It seems like the ugly alternative is that immoral people can profit by not paying expenses that legally and morally, they should pay. But even if it's ugly, that seems about right? They wouldn't do it otherwise.
- ggm 4y agoThe ugly reality (if I can riff on your language) is that exploitation and expropriation has been normalised, since we invented feudalism and before. All that changed over time, is how much we understand about the value being made, as it happens. Most economics is about the practical: if we adjust interest rates this way, what will people do with their money (value) and how does it alter the current balance? They don't much go to the moral side: should we do this. Some do, and typically its in public utility function because in times past, we funded this as tax and spend to common good, eg the build out of power, water but in times recent we've sold this capital investment off, to get short term money, in a belief somehow it will be "better" because "competition" which (again, in my opinion)_is just bogus. There is a heap of economics in health. Pretty much all the worlds developed economies see that it's better done as a public good, except the USA, and now we have specialist health economists in the USA who work to maximise profit for medical investment. Everyone else can get to "tax is better" but thats not an acceptable truth in the USA. Nothing to do with labour theory of value. If you think an iPhone is worth $1300 because Jony Ive said so, through Apple, then the cost of inputs come as a bit of a surprise. Why is the use function of a device like this so far removed from its actual input costs, labour included? "rational" economics goes to "it's not worth $1300" very fast because a $25 phone does most of "it" fine. Of course, thats a kindergarden level lie because even ignoring irrational desire, iPhones are a value beyond the cost of inputs, its a classic n-Squared proposition of being able to do iPhone-y things with your fellow iPhone holders. Yet apple stock is worth astronomically more than otherwise productive endevours in mining, engineering, housing. For what? How does apple increase or decrease US GDP in a meaningful way? How does Apple or Google add or subtract from the overall US economy, from CPI, from wages, and cost of housing. Great questions (if you ask me) If you don't believe in the labour theory of value, then a good thought experiment is to send all the undocumented mexican labour home and see what happens to the US economy. I've read of 10% minimum drop in production across the board, and a massive rise in CPI to deal with food shortages. Thats a pretty high value on labour right there.
- skybrian 4y agoIf you think of value as being determined by the prices people are willing to pay and not necessarily the actual prices, it’s not much of a surprise that often we pay less for things than their value to us. Paying the full value for essentials like food and water would be very bad and it’s fortunate that they can be delivered for a lot less. (Though, sometimes prices are too low, given the damage that supply chains do.) In your thought experiment, if the cost of labor rose due to stricter enforcement of immigration laws, we would see what luxuries people can cut back on and what essentials they won’t give up. But the pandemic showed some of this already. Lots of money is spent on luxuries like eating out and travel. (And, yes, iPhones.)
- ggm 4y agoThe disconnect between cost of production and price willing to pay for masks and toilet paper brought some of this into sharp focus for me. We're still playing around the edges of almost survivalist levels of concern for things which are not really that hard to source, but somehow have become scarce. And, simultaneously, the lack of cohesion between (almost warring) states means we realize price alone is a poor basis of planning for strategic supply chains: Having every hospital in the USA depend on two factories in China for masks in a pandemic, was no more or less silly than having every computer in the world depend on TSMC in Taiwan and Thai hard drive factories, or Samsung for screens. We depend on two or three mainly chinese sources of rare earths because the "price" of rare earth mining didn't justify the investment to exploit the other sources we know exist. It will take years to build around this. In the end, we directed labour to try and solve some of this. (masks) The only people who can be directed these days are either prisoners, or troops. Nobody much likes depending on either to solve labour problems.