4 ms·
Will Cloud Computing Make Everything (and Everyone) Work Harder?
- mark_l_watson 15y agoI was thinking about this myself: people become more machine-like, being more fully utilized. The article resonates with me because I work from home for several customers and I always have work tasks queued up. It takes some discipline to take time off.
- patio11 15y agoA lot of things which we think are laws of nature, such as "people need to have A Job", are in fact just effects of a peculiar-to-one-time-in-history economic phenomena, like "transaction costs and overhead in arranging employment so dominate returns to labor that it is more efficient to maintain simultaneous overstaffing and underutilization of almost the entire professional work force than it is to fill orders for work like we fulfill orders for pizzas." Tech has a wee bit of an effect in changing these economic underpinnings of how the culture works. So do economic arrangements, social pressures, the health of the alternative models, etc. (For a few decades there it was more economical in Japan to buy/sell labor in fifty year blocks than it was to buy it in two week chunks, like it is bought in America. That system is no longer healthy, which makes the two week chunk option more appealing.) Anyhow, it is by no means a given that the net result of increasing efficiency is working harder. The Internet makes it really efficient for me to negotiate I've-got-brains-you've-got-money-lets-trade relative to the traditional employment system in this neck of the woods. This caused my economic output to go waaaay the heck up and my hours worked to crater.
- tomjen3 15y agoThe problem is that even after it no longer makes much economic sense, people continue to follow it and the government makes laws based on the assumptions that was current 50 years ago. So it actually becomes a law of nature.
- nickik 15y agoClassical Self-fulfilling prophecy.
- itmag 15y agoIdeas on ways to disrupt this?
- jchrisa 15y agoGet rid of debt / interest based money http://www.realitysandwich.com/money_and_crisis_civilization http://www.realitysandwich.com/money_and_crisis_civilization
- itmag 15y agoSounds interesting. Can it be done by entrepreneurs, though? One idea: find some way to turn the economy into an MMMORPG. Ie 3d printing where the designs are created by Warcraftesque guilds and the profits are shared. Google "john robb open source ventures".
- jellicle 15y agoThe reason employers exist is they represent accumulations of capital. McDonald's provides free grills, fryers, cash registers, storefronts, uncooked hamburgers, lettuce, buns and ketchup to every employee. Not every person wants to assemble all the capital equipment necessary to sell hamburgers; those that don't can walk into a place with all the capital already provided and settle down to do what might be their optimal specialty, producing burgers. They don't get as much return, but then they don't have capital invested either. The minimal capital investment, even for these supposed "borderless" technology jobs, is several thousand dollars. For every person in the world that doesn't have several thousand dollars (which is to say, the majority of them), employers who provide capital equipment will continue to exist. Employers aren't going away.
- patio11 15y agoYou can provide capital to people who are not your employees. See: Uber (dispatching system + installed customer base = capital), any crowdsourcing company, and BCC (when I hire freelancers to write bingo cards). With specific regards to minimal capital investments to do knowledge work: I think that this will soon be the cost of a handset, which is lower bounded by ~$5 at the moment and has no reason to stay that high, either. (The greater problem is that in a perfectly efficient worldwide marketplace for information work, poor people in Africa -- and poor people in America, for that matter -- generally have nothing that I want to buy, at any price.)
- nickik 15y agoIf think Society is changing and we have to change radicaly to not end up in big social troubles (class wars ...). ------------------------------------------------- (Im talk about a system for Switzerland) I propose a "basic income" no strings attached (Everybody gets X$ per month and all wages are reduced by X$ is the short version of how it works) with this we replace all the diffrent social systems we have nowdays (money for kids, unemployment, AHV (money for the retired ...). This will liberate people in the sence that they don't have to hang on to there jobs even if they are badly treated, they wont be social outcasts if they dont have a job. instead give them insentives to improve there education (and thereby you could then get a job in a high tec economy), to be more entrepreneurial (find out what people really need and trie to provid it). A more importend example for the people here is app marked development. App marked made it possible to start a project in a small team and make money relativly fast. The insentive to trie something like this is much greater and you can't fall that far. It may not be the best model in pure economic groth terms but I hope it is a good model for a sustainable healthy society in a world where it is very hard to have full employment (because the economy changes to fast).
- ctdonath 15y agoMost people, given a no-strings-attached basic income, will NOT use it as an opportunity to educate themselves and become entrepreneurial; instead, they get LAZY and fiercely protective of that state. Not having a job isn't about being a social outcast, it's about not producing enough value/wealth to exchange for the cost of continuing existence. As an old book famously observed, "He who does not work, neither shall he eat"; that's not punitive, that's the economics of biology.
- pi18n 15y agoWhat happens if you make the stipend contingent on educating yourself somehow?
- randomdata 15y agoEducation is a symptom of value creation, not the cause of it. In other words, education alone brings no value to society. If there is no incentive to create value, because you are already given an income with no strings attached, that education will not be put to any meaningful use. It seems to me that the stipend would need to be based on a plan to create value for society. If some level of education is required in order to proceed with that plan, it could be granted as part of the implementation. This reasonably mirrors the way entrepreneurs operate, which is essentially what we want to duplicate. The dream always comes before the education. The education is only a means to an end.
- rmc 15y agoThis kind of machine-made urgency to utilize everything, creating lower prices (and for many, lower wages) Lower Prices = good for the common person. I don't think this would cause lower wages per se, if more people are doing less work (and getting less total pay), then this will lower the average wage. However that's not too important. More people have more money! yay!
- tomjen3 15y agoWhat it will properly do is to make it so that the same person gets different wages based on which part of the job he is doing. For example as a software developer you may make $50/hr at your main job but at your weekend call center spare time thing you only make $10/hr. This will not drive your wage down but it will drive your average wage down.
- ianso 15y agoI think the article is about squeezing out inefficiencies all over through centralized IT systems, but only if you see our free time as "inefficient" would you extend this idea to our personal lives. The problem is that in a global economy one could argue that American workers are competing with Chinese workers that do work 7 days a week and have no free time. Personally I think that there are plenty of places where the effect the article documents could be productively put to use for the benefit of everyone. e.g. most commuter cars have one person each. A giant centralized database of everyones commutes could make carpooling as easy as pushing a button on your phone over breakfast and seeing "be outside in 3 minutes" in response. That's just one example. I'm sure there are others, "think smarter not harder" should be the idea in general.
- PakG1 15y agoThe issue I have with this type of question is that it assumes the transaction costs to switch between tasks is 0 or minimal. If so, then yes, huge efficiencies can be gained by figuring out where people are underutilized when and making use of that capacity. If the tasks are all similar and easy to switch contexts (i.e. the call centre in the article is probably a good example?), then OK, makes sense. But for a lot of things, switching contexts is expensive. Productivity drops, and any cost savings can be easily nullified. One may argue that the capacity wasn't going to be used anyway, so it's a waste if not used. But I find the calculations used to estimate capacity assume that transaction costs for switching contexts is 0 instead of some large number. Thus, they actually overestimate capacity, thereby causing not only lowering productivity because they jam too many contexts into the space that still need to be handled on time, but also lower job dissatisfaction.
- jellicle 15y agoThe average wage on Mechanical Turk is $1.40/hour. If we delete the "cloud computing" buzzword and instead insert "crowdsourcing labor to the lowest cost source worldwide", and for "everyone" we substitute "U.S. workers", then yes, it's clear that over time this will accelerate the wage depression in the United States which has already been occurring.
- notatoad 15y agothis is the most flagrant abuse of the word "cloud" i've seen yet.
- tryitnow 15y agoTo answer the question posed by the article's title: No. It will provide people with the opportunity to work harder if that's their preference. As for downward pressure on wages. That's only a bad thing if there is no proportionately downward pressure on prices. Many of these services make markets more competitive (LiveOps versus traditional call centers, AirBnB versus traditional accommodations). So prices will probably drop more than wages. This also benefits people in economically weak areas. Not just globally but also in the US, e.g. Deep South, Rust Belt, etc.