3 ms·
A general trend in economics has two sides. Side A is the irritating number of amateur economics players (me!) and the desire to engage in this topic, because
by ggm 4y ago
A general trend in economics has two sides.
Side A is the irritating number of amateur economics players (me!) and the desire to engage in this topic, because its both fascinating and important
Side B is the extent of "you're wrong" put downs from either other amateurs, or professionals, which is entirely understandable given that the Side A players make collossal mistakes, but which also masks the divides in economic theory: Some people are pretty partisan in the trench warfare across the battlezones here.
So it's foolish to bring maths to the table, because you will be faceplaned by anyone who prefers more complex maths, or who wants to nitpick your maths, or who wants to attack your school of philosophy because they stand on a different hilltop.
Does it mean "mistakes" are acceptable? No. But people can be a bit kind about it, because in the end, we're all talking about the same thing.
Well.. mostly. Not me. I'm stuck in the labour theory of value. all this money stuff is just nonsense.
- skybrian 4y agoI never really got the labor of theory of value. It seems like the idea is that value comes from working hard, regardless of whether you actually accomplished anything? What does the labor theory of value have to say about bullshit jobs? How do you decide what efficiency means if you measure value based on inputs rather than results?
- ggm 4y agoIt's a bit of a throwaway/joke line because the Labour theory of value does not inform any aspect of modern economic theory on value as exchange. They're probably orthogonal concepts. That said I wouldn't discount that there is a very fine thesis in analysis of bullshit jobs. Particularly the extreme amount of organisationally justified middle management which inserts mindless beaurocracy into creative acts. Think not just lawyers, but the oceans and oceans of ink applied by junior law clerks to pad out the billable hours and get to the million dollars in costs, but for virtually everything we do now. You think all those 150,000 google employees are creating value? As a position of quasi religious faith, I think the property of value latent in made things vests in the labour to make them not the priviledge of the capital invested. The alternatives are very ugly: slavery would be the highest form of profitable enterprise when in fact I believe the evidence is strong the other way: you need to pay workers to get value from them. Why? Because they create the value. Invest in slaves, it's less outcome for more expenditure.
- skybrian 4y agoIt seems like the ugly alternative is that immoral people can profit by not paying expenses that legally and morally, they should pay. But even if it's ugly, that seems about right? They wouldn't do it otherwise.
- ggm 4y agoThe ugly reality (if I can riff on your language) is that exploitation and expropriation has been normalised, since we invented feudalism and before. All that changed over time, is how much we understand about the value being made, as it happens. Most economics is about the practical: if we adjust interest rates this way, what will people do with their money (value) and how does it alter the current balance? They don't much go to the moral side: should we do this. Some do, and typically its in public utility function because in times past, we funded this as tax and spend to common good, eg the build out of power, water but in times recent we've sold this capital investment off, to get short term money, in a belief somehow it will be "better" because "competition" which (again, in my opinion)_is just bogus. There is a heap of economics in health. Pretty much all the worlds developed economies see that it's better done as a public good, except the USA, and now we have specialist health economists in the USA who work to maximise profit for medical investment. Everyone else can get to "tax is better" but thats not an acceptable truth in the USA. Nothing to do with labour theory of value. If you think an iPhone is worth $1300 because Jony Ive said so, through Apple, then the cost of inputs come as a bit of a surprise. Why is the use function of a device like this so far removed from its actual input costs, labour included? "rational" economics goes to "it's not worth $1300" very fast because a $25 phone does most of "it" fine. Of course, thats a kindergarden level lie because even ignoring irrational desire, iPhones are a value beyond the cost of inputs, its a classic n-Squared proposition of being able to do iPhone-y things with your fellow iPhone holders. Yet apple stock is worth astronomically more than otherwise productive endevours in mining, engineering, housing. For what? How does apple increase or decrease US GDP in a meaningful way? How does Apple or Google add or subtract from the overall US economy, from CPI, from wages, and cost of housing. Great questions (if you ask me) If you don't believe in the labour theory of value, then a good thought experiment is to send all the undocumented mexican labour home and see what happens to the US economy. I've read of 10% minimum drop in production across the board, and a massive rise in CPI to deal with food shortages. Thats a pretty high value on labour right there.