2 ms·
> The short term solution was to isolate at-risk populations. We didn't know who they were. Even as it became clear, as with most things in life, it was gray,
by PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago
> The short term solution was to isolate at-risk populations.
We didn't know who they were. Even as it became clear, as with most things in life, it was gray, not black and white, and there was a gradient of risk, as well as pools of individuals who for reasons unknown were above-expected risk. Look at the death counts by age cohort. Sure, the elderly are up there, but it's not as if Covid killed just 1M old people in the US.
Your position is essentially a cost-benefit analysis, just like all the others, with the difference that you think that the cost of attempted to limit disease spread throughout the entire population was higher than any benefits accrued. It's likely not just Weiss who might disagree with you, but most of the relatives, friends, colleagues and neighbors of the million dead people. That doesn't mean you're definitively wrong (far from it), but the point is that nobody is "wrong" or "right" in this: everyone's doing cost/benefit analysis and coming to different conclusions.