5 ms·
The machines may be rigged to explode, flood, or otherwise hose themselves, but active sabotage is largely unnecessary. If China takes Taiwan by force, two thi
by CamperBob2 4y ago
The machines may be rigged to explode, flood, or otherwise hose themselves, but active sabotage is largely unnecessary. If China takes Taiwan by force, two things will happen: 1) the US will heavily sanction anyone who trades with them, so even if they manage to keep the TSMC fab online it won't do them any good in a commercial sense; and 2) without ongoing service and support from ASML and many other Western vendors, the equipment will work for about as long as the leased aircraft that Russia stole from Airbus's and Boeing's customers.
They might get six or twelve months of production out of TSMC's facility, and then things will start to break that they will not be able to fix easily. Invading Taiwan will cause economic damage measured in hundreds of billions of dollars at a bare minimum, and much of that damage will be suffered by China.
Bottom line, it would be insanely stupid of China to attack Taiwan. Of course, many people (including myself) said the same thing about Putin and Ukraine, so...
- whatever1 4y agoApple produces almost 100% of their processors at TSMC (Samsung was making some previous gen if I recall). If Taiwan falls, Apple falls. The US economy will be in ruins, and nothing can stop a large scale military conflict.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dirtyid 4y ago>and much of that damage will be suffered by China Signiciantly more will be suffered by US/west whose advanced industries extracts disproportionate patent fees and have extreme reliance on TW semi for short to medium term. We're talking trillions in knock on effects. Proximity of semi production / supply chain concentration in TW and broader east Asia is PRC's trump card in war. During peace US has trump card in sanctions / tech control, but during war PRC has leverage of simply setting the advanced economies back 30 years which will actually close relative gap. PRC might even pull ahead if they manage to mass rollout of 28nm indigenous fabs and complete indigenous semi supply chain before anyone else. That's without mentioning during war, PRC has incentive to attack SKR/JP fabs to draw US into first island chain where they're weakest to honor security commitments. If things ever get heated with US, it would be insanely smart for China to threaten TW/JP/SKR as well. And if PRC attacks TW, I surmise there's going to be three way side deal between PRC, US and TW leadership to maintain TSMC production continuity in exchange for evacuations for TW leadership to US who would otherwise get the noose for treason. Which itself makes the notion that TSMC is rigged to blow counterproductive - surival of TSMC is TW elites golden ticket off the island - US isn't going to look kindly to a TW admin that explodes US economy and tech lead.
- credit_guy 4y ago> Significantly more will be suffered by US/west People can live without smartphones, but can't live without food. In case of war, westerners will need to postpone buying some electronics or clothes, but the Chinese will resort to severe food rationing.
- Jensson 4y agoThat is old data, today China produces more than enough to feed its population. They produce 650 million tons of grain a year which is more than enough for their population, and is a net exporter of meat. To make it easier to understand, total world grain production is about 2250 million tons for a population of 7.8 billion. At worst China would need to ration more expensive meals, but people wouldn't starve.
- dirtyid 4y agoSomeone else addressed per capita self sufficiency below. But operationally, this strategy is likely only if US has ability and appetite to enforce blockade from other producers. And likely only viable short term before PRC finishes conventional deterrence. As we can see with UKR, most of the world ignored sanctions on food and energy, including west. Keep in mind PRC is buying a lot of ag products from US because of Phase One trade deal. Medium long term, they'd rather decouple and build up other producers. Another Q one should ask is how vunerable US is to comparable counter action. Because US agriculture is highly industrialized and automated whereas PRC ag is in the process of automation and still reliant on labour. Sufficient cyber attack on US ag infra during harvest season and US is forced to ration. What happens to automated John Deere tractors when they have no GPS to harvest. Same with familiar threats of embargoing PRC oil because US is self sufficient on the metric that there's enough fossil fuel resources in the ground. US is only as self sufficient as how much it's 130 refineries can produce. If US interdicts PRC energy, don't be surprised if PRC takes down comparable levels of production state side.
- CamperBob2 4y agoAbandoning trade with China will hurt us, certainly. But unless the Xi regime is overtly suicidal, that's all that will happen, and we'll eventually get over it. As for cyberattacks from China, those can only do so much, and in any case they can be mitigated by cutting the fiber. OTOH, shooting down GPS sats will lead to war. They know better than that. I hope.
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- dannyw 4y agoThe US heavily sanctioning China would basically be the end of America's economy, it isn't a realistic option. There also won't be enough public support for it as long as conflict is contained to the APAC region. Furthermore, it probably also means the disintegration of US global sanctioning power. Europe would rather trade with China than the USA, assuming it's mutually exclusive.
- NLPlatypus 4y agoI’m not so sure about Europe siding with China. Values come into play. https://www.usnews.com/news/world/articles/2022-07-30/swiss-set-to-match-eu-sanctions-if-china-invades-taiwan-agency-chief?context=amp https://www.usnews.com/news/world/articles/2022-07-30/swiss-...
- CamperBob2 4y agoInterestingly, the press is starting to float trial balloons along those lines: https://www.reuters.com/article/germany-economy-china/trade-war-with-china-could-cost-germany-six-times-as-much-as-brexit-ifo-idUSL8N2ZK1KI https://www.reuters.com/article/germany-economy-china/trade-...
- foobarian 4y agoPick any Walmart, Target, or other big box store and see how much of their stock is not Chinese made. Cutting trade would basically shut all of them down and there would be a revolt.
- jason-phillips 4y ago> 2) without ongoing service and support from ASML and many other Western vendors, the equipment will work for about as long as the leased aircraft that Russia stole from Airbus's and Boeing's customers. They might get six or twelve months of production out of TSMC's facility, and then things will start to break that they will not be able to fix easily. Right. Fab tools require constant maintenance. I'm sure they keep a stock of repair kits and spare parts, but probably no more than a few months supply. Their supply chain ops (procurement and engineering) sets min/max stock levels of these parts, but I'm willing to bet that there's no more than a few months supply on hand. And then equipment gets dirty, wafers get scrapped, yield plummets, etc.