3 ms·
Dum Dums Lollipops Drop-Shipping Hustle on Amazon Costs Spangler Candy Millions
- ignorantguy 4y agoI ordered a longboard on amazon and the shipping came from costco. checked costco and the price was 25$ cheaper there.
- cable2600 4y agoSam's is a wholesale club known for marking down prices. Amazon.com is a retail store. I wonder how many other businesses this effects?
- Ekaros 4y agoAre they losing money or just not making as much as they could? In this scheme it seems they provide product to certain retailers for cheaper and drop shippers use this to arbitrage a profit. Are they providing products to these stores for less than it cost to make them? The solution to me seems to be to raise the price on these retailers...
- an1sotropy 4y agoThe article says Sam's Club "rewards its members by selling a deeply discounted 500-pack for about $15". If Sam's Club decides to make Dum Dums a loss leader, even if they're paying Spangler the same price as other retailers, you're saying its Spangler's problem if they don't additionally jack the price for Sam's Club?
- Ekaros 4y agoIf Sam's Club pays same as other retailers, it is Sam's Club losing the money. So clearly Spangler is in that case losing no money, or actually making more. And if they are giving a discount to Sam's Club, they can solve problem by ending that discount.
- an1sotropy 4y agoSorry, I should have thought and explained more. I agree that it's not Spangler's problem that Sam's Club makes Dum Dums into a loss leader; you're right that Spangler is getting paid for whatever leaves their factory regardless of what happens downstream. The problem is the Amazon drop-ship hustle is generating revenue, from the flow of Dum Dums, which is not reaching Spangler, but arguably should. When a drop-shipper buys from Sam's Club, paying the artificially very low price of that loss leader, but then turns around and sells on Amazon at a tiny bit under Spangler's price on Amazon (the article says $25 vs $26), then people will end up buying on Amazon from the drop-shipper instead of from Spangler. Spangler points to this and says: look, there's demand on Amazon for our product, and we should be getting the revenue from meeting that demand, but instead some of that demand is being met by drop-shippers making huge profits. I think you and I may be disagreeing on whether the drop-shippers gain is actually Spangler's loss. I think Spangler has a legit complaint, and that's probably why Amazon says the practice is against the rules (while sucking at enforcement).
- an1sotropy 4y agoWell there you go: > The Dum Dums racket doesn’t appear to hurt Amazon because it still makes a commission on each sale even if the product is sourced from Sam’s Club. But earlier: > Amazon spokesperson Nathan Strauss said the company has long banned sellers from shipping products from other retailers to customers. “We monitor a variety of data and signals to detect, investigate and enforce violations of this policy,” Strauss said. Uh huh. I'm sure you put your best interns on that, while you have a massive computing infrastructure running ML models to optimize traffic and profits. Amazon does not care about individual retailers surviving, because they win either way.