3 ms·
When looking at this Huawei server, one should not forget that it no longer represents the best that the Chinese can do in servers. Now the best Chinese server
by adrian_b 4y ago
When looking at this Huawei server, one should not forget that it no longer represents the best that the Chinese can do in servers.
Now the best Chinese servers are the Alibaba Yitian 710, which have 128 cores per package implementing the Armv9.0-A architecture and also other modern features, e.g. PCIe Gen5 and DDR5 memory, exactly like the future AMD Genoa and Intel Sapphire Rapids.
The Alibaba server CPU, judging from its name, appears to use Cortex-A710 cores, which is a little weird, because ARM also offers a derivative of the Cortex-A710, i.e. Neoverse N2, specifically intended for servers, but it seems that Alibaba did not choose that.
Currently, the Alibaba Yitian 710 has the best SPECrate2017 integer result per socket of any CPU, beating easily AMD Milan or Ampere Altra, and it will remain the best until AMD Genoa will be launched (with 96 cores/192 threads per socket).
Of course Alibaba did not submit results for floating-point SPECrate2017, because there the ARM cores cannot beat the Intel/AMD CPUs with AVX/AVX-512, but for a cloud company the floating-point workloads are not a priority.
For now the best ARM-based server CPUs are the Amazon Graviton 3 CPUs (Neoverse V1 cores) and the Alibaba Yitian 710, but neither of them will be available for sale or for independent testing, as they are intended only for internal use, for cloud implementation.
The choices of Amazon and Alibaba have been different, Alibaba uses medium-size ARM cores, which have a performance intermediate between a thread on an Intel/AMD core and a full Intel/AMD core, so that 128 ARM cores are needed to beat easily a 64/128 cores/threads AMD CPU.
On the other hand Amazon has chosen big ARM cores, which have a performance similar with older Intel/AMD full cores, i.e. they are not so fast as AMD Zen 3 or Zen 4 or Intel Tiger Lake/Alder Lake/Sapphire Rapids.
Using big cores has forced Amazon to implement only 64 cores per package. For some well optimized programs that use all the resources of the CPU, a big core may have up to a double throughput compared to a medium-size core, so for such workloads Amazon Graviton 3 can match the throughput per package of the Alibaba CPU, but for more typical programs, where the execution units are not busy all the time, the Alibaba CPU with a double number of cores will have a higher throughput.