3 ms·
Because we have to be honest with ourselves. Don't tell the crystallographers they're no longer necessary for structure determination. If people flee the field
by echelon 4y ago
Because we have to be honest with ourselves. Don't tell the crystallographers they're no longer necessary for structure determination. If people flee the field and ML doesn't pan out, then we're worse off.
Treat this as it is. An exciting approach that may help some now and yield fantastic results in the future. Don't count the chickens before they hatch.
Even if the structures were entirely correct - and they're definitely not - there's a massive complex metabolome to figure out.
Google is certainly milking the PR as much as they can, and that can be dangerous to the laymen approving research budgets.
- tigershark 4y agoAlphafold demonstrated beyond any reasonable doubt that crystallography by itself is useless in certain circumstances. There are plenty of research groups working on crystallography that found the correct solution only combining their data with Alphafold data. In the last competition, if I remember correctly, there was one protein that escaped crystallography for many years until they used Alphafold predicted structure. I’m not really sure how can you simply discount these really groundbreaking results when crystallography provided much less wins in many more years.
- l33tman 4y agoYou are aware of that almost all known protein structures come from crystallography?
- pas 4y agoHow much of the AlphaFold training data is from crystallography results?
- evouga 4y agoThe crystallographically-determined structures are the ground truth! [1] Saying that AlphaFold makes x-ray crystallography useless is like saying DALL-E makes photography useless or Copilot makes GitHub useless. You've got the dependency chain backwards. [1] (Or at least, they're treated as the ground truth---they don't necessarily predict the conformation of proteins in solution, but that's a separate topic for another thread).