2 ms·
There's a ton of great quotes in this piece, so it's hard to pick just one, so I'll juxtapose two. > We love the narrative of rugged individualism, the freedom
by kelseyfrog 4y ago
There's a ton of great quotes in this piece, so it's hard to pick just one, so I'll juxtapose two.
> We love the narrative of rugged individualism, the freedom to help ourselves out, choose our own way, and make a future.
> When we choose to go through a life transition without the help of others, we steal away from those around us the profound joy of building up a future – real acts of hope, faith and love in the world.
As someone who started out on a major life transition just a year ago with the explicit advice to deliberately form a supportive network, this rings resoundingly clear. Most people want to do good by helping, but sadly the opportunities to do so are abstractly detatched from day to day experience. I know there will be people who will want to respond with, "you know you can just volunteer," but the emotional texture of volunteer work is qualitatively different from being asked, "I'm going through something hard. Can I count on you for support?"
The individualism described in the article contributes to the atrophy of emotional vulnerability and forming support networks is an antidote. I hope in some small way the article inspires someone to do the same.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- xyzzy123 4y agoI agree but the main criticism I have of the article is that tornados don't challenge anyone's world view and that is often the problem that individuals face. An Amish person getting support via well worn community norms is one thing. But so much of the change that people find hard is when they discover that their identity or community doesn't fit them quite right anymore. How supportive are the Amish if you decide you want to live a different life? Changing politics, gender, religion, social class (income shift), other identity values or moving a long way - these are often "out of context" problems for the community and friends you have. The article's not "wrong" but life is nuanced. It's not easy to build new networks.
- kelseyfrog 4y ago> The article's not "wrong" but life is nuanced. It's not easy to build new networks. Couldn't agree more. Forming support networks is swimming upstream against our social currents. But, rising against default mode social relations is inherently liberatory at the same time. Or in words more friendly to the audience, working harder (powering through individually), doesn't always trump working smarter(building support networks).
- vorpalhex 4y ago> When we choose to go through a life transition without the help of others, we steal away from those around us the profound joy of... There is no work that does not contain an iota of it's author. To allow others to be involved with you is also to allow them to change you - and you to change them. This is both a threat and a promise. If your identity is intimately aligned with the people who are helping you, this is great. If your identity is not aligned, this is terrible. Individualism is an alternative, and it's an alternative to collectivism. One of the things collectivism depends on is a unified identity, often times touching the religious, cultural and familiar. Thus collectivism works well for the Amish who don't tolerate breaks from their hegemony - even choosing a different barn design can become a pitched cultural battle.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoThis framing, individuality or collectivism, is a false dichotomy created to reenforce the idea of the superiority of individuality. It's an malignant simplification that requires the effort of critique to realize how it functions as part of a larger assemblage of social machinery. Nearly all of us operate in a patchwork plurality of social relations formulated on any number of identity perspectives. Sure, some people may read this and go full Amish, but the call to action doesn't seem to be that. The call to action is to take a risk, reach out to that acquaintance when the time is right, and ask, "I know we aren't that close, but I might need some support. Can I count on you?"