3 ms·
“Will solar panels be as available as they are today” Already installed solar obviously has zero dependency on China. In the steady state you need to replace
by Retric 4y ago
“Will solar panels be as available as they are today”
Already installed solar obviously has zero dependency on China. In the steady state you need to replace around 3% per year to keep up with panel degradation, but a dependable solar grid has significant excess production so you have wiggle room to build up domestic manufacturing. And you can ramp up alternatives like wind.
Nuclear has more significant systemic risks, which are less obvious. Over half of Frances’s Nuclear powerplants are currently offline for deferred maintenance. If they where nearly as dependent on Nuclear as often reported they would be having real trouble right now.
- goodpoint 4y ago> Already installed solar obviously has zero dependency on China > Over half of Frances’s Nuclear powerplants are currently offline for deferred maintenance There is more. Nuclear power requires continual availability of skilled technicians and engineers, replacement parts that need advanced manufacturing, water and other material, access to road and infrastructure. And a stable socioeconomical and political and legal system. And military defense. For some developed countries it can already difficult to provide all these things with 100% reliability. Today, before the bigger impact of climate change. And what about the remaining 50% of human population? Do you see South American, African and middle-eastern countries being able to run nuclear plants? And they do, what about plutonium and nuclear proliferation?
- inglor_cz 4y agoIf Bulgaria and Ukraine can run their nuclear plants, why not Brazil or Argentina?
- Retric 4y agoUkraine has a poor history of running nuclear power plants. They recently had one suffer a large scale military attack and are of course managing the aftermath of Chernobyl.
- inglor_cz 4y agoThe Chernobyl explosion happened during Soviet times, 6 years before Ukrainian independence. So I wouldn't blame Ukraine as such for it. The fact that an aggressor chose Ukrainian nuclear plant as a target and impromptu military dump isn't Ukrainian fault either. This could have happened to Finland or Sweden, too, in case of a Soviet/Russian attack. (Neither country was under NATO's protective umbrella.)
- Retric 4y agoActually attacking it is on Russia. However, placing troups inside the nuclear power station is on Ukraine. It’s for similar reasons that you don't station troups inside a school, which apparently Ruissa has been doing.
- pdabbadabba 4y agoSure, there have been these two incidents. But whats the real argument here? Do these indicents mean that Ukraine has an intolerably poor track record? I don’t see how it does—especially since one occurred when Ukraine was part of the USSR, which was actually the nation operating the plant, and the other was caused by a neighbor’s aggression. And the actual point here was about Latin America. Ukraine was just an example. Is it really so implausible to think that, for example, Brazil and Argentina could not safely operate nuclear plants?
- Retric 4y agoThe point is if you want to consider how successful a major infrastructure project then you should base things on similar countries. Brazil has multiple nuclear reactors though South America has very few. If the history of nuclear incidents should tell us anything it’s the importantance of understanding failure modes. To use a Brazil example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goiânia_accident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goiânia_accident Massive complex infrastructure projects in poor countries often fail to finish or suffer from substandard construction etc.
- belorn 4y ago
- goodpoint 4y agoBecause if they do some other country up north might get skittish and stage a coup or a little war.
- MichaelCollins 4y ago> And what about the remaining 50% of human population? Do you see South American, African and middle-eastern countries being able to run nuclear plants? This is hard to read charitably. It seems like a racist remark, not least because there are nuclear power plants in South America, Africa, and the Middle East. Maybe you aren't racist yourself, but you presume nuclear power proponents to be racist? The ends justify the means, so you can play into the racial biases of those you oppose? I don't like this.
- Retric 4y agoSuggetsing countries like Afghanistan that have had difficulty maintaining basic infrastructure would have more difficulty safely maintaining more difficult infrastructure like nuclear power plants seems reasonable. There is nothing racist about suggesting South Africa which is the only Africa country with nuclear power might have better odds than Sudan. Similarly Brazil has safely operated nuclear power plants for decades, but nuclear has faced real logistical issues in South America.
- goodpoint 4y ago> seems like a racist remark It is the very opposite. I'm stating that the global south is being exploited and denied access to technology (and more). If anything, it is racist to NOT acknowledge the problems that the global south is facing. Besides, I clearly wrote "countries" obviously referring to the political entities, not the population. > Maybe you aren't racist yourself, but you presume nuclear power proponents to be racist? Now you flipped 180? > The ends justify the means, so you can play into the racial biases of those you oppose? What does this even mean?
- cesarb 4y ago> Do you see South American, African and middle-eastern countries being able to run nuclear plants? South American here. We do have a couple of nuclear plants, and they run fine.
- natmaka 4y agoRussia and its allies are major providers of uranium. This impacts even the US: https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/exclusive-us-utilities-push-white-house-not-sanction-russian-uranium-2022-03-02/ https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/exclusive-us-utiliti... Kazakhstan is the main uranium provider of France.