4 ms·
The library in question had plenty of Christian-life material, it's just that the people voting against it didn't care about having both sides. What they wanted
by vkou 4y ago
The library in question had plenty of Christian-life material, it's just that the people voting against it didn't care about having both sides. What they wanted was to not have the other side.
- slt2021 4y agoif they are paying for it from their taxes, I guess it is consumers choice then. would you complain that Fox News/Breitbart viewers refuse to read some ultra radical left wing news? (for purposes other than making fun of other side)
- tjohns 4y agoYou can't compare a for-profit corporation with a public library. You also can't compare a TV station (which offers fixed programming) with a library (which allows users to browse titles on request). Libraries are not supposed to editorialize their collection. Consider the library as a physical version of the internet. Nobody is forcing users to read a specific page online, but we generally agree that ISPs shouldn't censor content that the user has requested.
- slt2021 4y agoI'd like to pushback against your argument. Librarians absolutely do curate content, it is their main responsibility. The main principle in curating library content is adding value. If content does not add value to readers, it is useless. "Give the people what they want" is another principle (https://www.forbes.com/sites/avaseave/2014/01/17/the-process-of-curating-for-curators-who-do-librarians-consult/?sh=409b1df26696 https://www.forbes.com/sites/avaseave/2014/01/17/the-process...)
- MichaelCollins 4y agoOne one hand, it seems impossible to run a library without curation. If nothing else, space is limited. On the other hand, the American Librarian Association's Library Bill of Rights says that libraries should have books presenting all points of view on current and historical issues, neither proscribed nor removed because of partisan or doctrinal disapproval. https://www.ala.org/advocacy/intfreedom/librarybill https://www.ala.org/advocacy/intfreedom/librarybill List of document interpreting those rights: https://www.ala.org/advocacy/intfreedom/librarybill/interpretations https://www.ala.org/advocacy/intfreedom/librarybill/interpre... Some choice quotes from https://www.ala.org/advocacy/intfreedom/librarybill/interpretations/politics https://www.ala.org/advocacy/intfreedom/librarybill/interpre... : > Thus there is no justification for the exclusion of opinions deemed to be unpopular or offensive by some segments of society no matter how vocal or influential their opponents may be at any particular time in any particular place. > A balanced collection need not and cannot contain an equal number of resources representing every possible viewpoint on every issue. A balanced collection should include the variety of views that surround any given issue. It all seems broadly reasonable; a library need not and cannot give equal shelf space to both sides of every issue. Nevertheless, a library should not categorically exclude one side of an issue, no matter how offensive.
- jmfayard 4y agoVery few issues have both sides. Booleans yes, they have exactly two equally valid values. Coins also have both sides. But most issues are neither coins nor booleans.
- hereme888 4y agoSo you're comparing Christianity (and by extension of similar standards and ways of living also Judaism and Muslims) to trans-gender ideologies?
- vkou 4y agoI'm noting, quite correctly, that the overwhelming amount of opposition to LGBTQ life in the US comes from modern Christian doctrine. As of 2022, there aren't a lot of secular thinkers/thought leaders/morality preachers in our culture who are telling people to stop being gay/trans, or equating being LGBQT with being a groomer or a child predator. So, yes, having a few books on LGBQT life (both religious and secular), and a few hundred books on Christian life (some of which happily and loudly condemn the former) in your library is a pretty good proxy for covering a wide range of viewpoints on the question of whether or not it's OK to be gay. But if you do want to thoroughly all-sides this question, there's also nothing that stops you from throwing in some secular, or Islamic, or Hindi anti-lgbqt literature onto the shelves. I'm sure it exists, but it's not a major axis of thought in this country, at the moment.
- hereme888 4y agoChristians happen to be the most vocal because this country has a very large population of such, and was founded by such as well. I mean, the rights of individuals in the US is legally guaranteed because of belief in God, and the nation still stands under God. 74 million people voted in 2020 for a loudly Christian president and vice president. From that pool, a large percentage would have defunded the library as well. But not all were Christians. So the library probably represents a similar demographic, and why not provide towards a demographic, which likely included the Muslims, Jews, Hindus, secular conservatives, etc. I disagree the major axis of thought in this country is pro-LGBQT by number of people, but would totally agree it's the presiding trend in most of the media, and maybe more than half of politicians, thereby seemingly being the major axis of thought. As for secular morality preachers, I didn't know they exist. I wonder how they deal with moral standards if they're not set in stone, as they're believed to be in the Bible. Tomorrow killing Jews might become the moral thing to do. Who's to say otherwise? The Nazis thought it was moral.