3 ms·
“Gender Queer” is an unfortunate example of the broader movement for sex positivity creating unnecessary headwinds for LGBT rights. What’s most notable about th
by rayiner 4y ago
“Gender Queer” is an unfortunate example of the broader movement for sex positivity creating unnecessary headwinds for LGBT rights. What’s most notable about the book is the graphic depictions of underage sex that most parents would find objectionable regardless of the gender identity of the children involved: https://www.ibtimes.sg/texas-school-sparks-outrage-after-mom-finds-gender-queer-book-sexually-explicit-cartoons-library-60974 https://www.ibtimes.sg/texas-school-sparks-outrage-after-mom....
It doesn’t help that the American Library Association gave it their Alex Award, recognizing books for children 12-18 year olds: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_Queer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_Queer. That resulted in the book being placed in numerous middle and high school libraries.
We’re a country where a supermajority of Americans supports same sex marriage and legal protections for LGBT people: https://www.hrc.org/press-releases/icymi-bidens-bostock-eo-rated-most-popular https://www.hrc.org/press-releases/icymi-bidens-bostock-eo-r... (“According to polls analyzed by FiveThirtyEight, President Biden’s most popular executive order thus far was his order prohibiting workplace discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity earning 83% in support.”)
We are also a sex negative country, one where a decisive majority of people, especially parents, and a third of self-identified “liberals,” believe teenagers having sex is immoral. https://news.gallup.com/poll/235415/four-say-teen-sex-morally-acceptable.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/235415/four-say-teen-sex-morall...
I don’t think folks realize the harm they’re doing by trying to yoke unpopular sex positivism to movements seeking rights for sexual minorities. It’s not just GOP yokels in Michigan. The book generated a firestorm in northern Virginia as well, which is full of upwardly mobile Hispanic and Asian immigrants.
- tptacek 4y agoThe book, as it pertains to the story we're commenting on, was in the adult section of the Jamestown library. Your comment repeatedly uses the word "parents" as if the Jamestown library was promoting it to children. Another book that is promoted to children that includes explicit discussion of sexuality, and that has been challenged by the parents you're talking about, is the Diary of Anne Frank. I don't think "Gender Queer" belongs in school libraries. I do think the Diary of Anne Frank belongs in school libraries. Can you offer an argument that acknowledges that? I'm skeptical.
- rayiner 4y agoThe American Library Association promoted it to children through their Alex Award for kids 12-18, what they call “young adults”: https://www.ala.org/yalsa/alex-awards https://www.ala.org/yalsa/alex-awards (2020) As to distinguishing the two, the issue is what message is conveyed to children from authority figures. In my view, parents have a legitimate interest in the party line from adults to children being “no teenage exploration of sexuality for anyone.” The diary of Anne Frank has historical value, and the sexual exploration is incidental. In Gender Queer, it’s quite central to the book. I don’t think a library should be defunded over it, but I do think it’s counterproductive for folks to close ranks around defending it. It reminds parents that folks at the ALA probably don’t share their values when it comes to sexuality among “young adults,” and unnecessarily tethers an unpopular liberal position (sex positivity) to a popular one (acceptance of trans kids). A problem with progressive advocacy in general is that progressives have a bunch of unpopular beliefs (about sexuality, American history, etc.), and at the organizational level, can’t help but inject those beliefs into their advocacy for popular positions (be kind to people).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 4y agoI'd love to find a way to dunk on this, but, fair enough. I did a bunch more reading on this title; the consensus seems to be that it's a very well-written book that's appropriate for mature 16-17 year olds, but the ALA only has the 12-18 category, and I couldn't fault any parent for having a problem with this book being promoted by a school to a 12 year old. Again: the library we're talking about here had the book originally shelved in an adult section, and later behind a desk available on request.
- koheripbal 4y agoThe librarian that resigned was holding talks with school children about being LGBT and pointing students to various LGBT books. That's what triggered the whole drama.