4 ms·
one way to fight back is to make requests to remove the Bible and other Holy Books, since they contain the same themes from other works of fiction that are requ
by yieldcrv 4y ago
one way to fight back is to make requests to remove the Bible and other Holy Books, since they contain the same themes from other works of fiction that are requested to be banned
all paths probably result in simply defunding though, but there is more introspective potential from pointing out the holes in the arguments for banning books with "confusing" themes
- axblount 4y agoI appreciate the thought, but there's no way a request to remove the Bible would have any impact. The request would be discarded immediately.
- yieldcrv 4y agoand then you challenge the discarding and other bans on equal protection grounds (14th amendment)
- phailhaus 4y agoThat doesn't help, it just antagonizes the people you need to be on your side.
- plantwallshoe 4y agoYou only need these people on your side if their opinion is actually the majority opinion. Often minority opinion groups get their way because they turn out and vote in outsized numbers.
- armchairhacker 4y agoIt’s also morally wrong, like why should i care if someone has access to the Bible? And even if you don’t care about morality, but just being the majority opinion - the majority tends to swing back and forth and there are a lot of people who constantly switch sides. When you make inflammatory actions like banning the bible, or proposing to ban viagra (as some democrat did more as a symbolic gesture for banning abortion), you’re actually pushing away undecided voters and giving fuel to the “radical leftists” theory a lot of right-wingers seem to think is the entire left.
- phailhaus 4y agoThis is a really good point. They don't see those inflammatory actions as satirizing them, they see them as serious policy beliefs. "See? They want to outlaw us!" You can't respond with satire because it will be taken literally.
- wahern 4y agoI've heard this dynamic mentioned many times by politician and pundits, regarding reactions by groups to satire that could only be construed as the group being completely oblivious to the satiric character. It seems a sizable fraction of the population doesn't get satire. In this current epoch they also seem to skew conservative, but certainly there are many who lean in other directions and likewise aren't capable of recognizing satire. (We might say they choose not to see it, but I'm not sure that's a meaningful distinction at the end of the day.) The apparent conservative bent might simply be because satire is usually employed by cultural and academic elites, who skew liberal by a significant margin these days. In any event, it seems to be a real and important dynamic, and for anyone earnestly advocating some policy, satire is best confined to narrow audiences, or preferably not at all given how difficult it is to choose your audience in the information age.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- zorpner 4y agoAudre Lorde's quote is relevant here: ---------- For the master’s tools will never dismantle the master’s house. They may allow us temporarily to beat him at his own game, but they will never enable us to bring about genuine change. ---------- The reason these tools are used by those who use them is because they exploit existing imbalances and biases -- attempting to use the same techniques angled disfavorably against that bias will not be effective.
- eggsmediumrare 4y agoThere's a solid argument for keeping those books for their historical value. Like how Mein Kampf is in a lot of libraries, but not the lunatic ravings of some modern equivalent.
- hiram112 4y agoInterestingly enough, Christianity, the Bible (as anything other than a historical text), etc. were systematically stripped from most schools, libraries, gov't buildings over the past 50 years. The right obviously wasn't pleased about it. But the lawsuits were made, and the courts established the precedents. And now I don't think the left is going to be happy when they're on the receiving end, and the same courts force them to take down the rainbow flags, remove all the Kendi books, cut out the BLM activism and pride curriculums. Because at this point, there is little difference between traditional religions and the newer "woke" ones being pushed. They've both got their dogmas, moral codes, icons, rituals, systems of punishments for heretics, etc.
- slt2021 4y agoto read Bible they go to church, not library, and I'm sure most parents in that town have their own multiple copies of the Bible if they are religious.