5 ms·
Actually, no, the jury verdict on punitive damages is $45.2 million, but that is certain to be reduced before Jones is ordered to pay (there seems to be some di
by dragonwriter 4y ago
Actually, no, the jury verdict on punitive damages is $45.2 million, but that is certain to be reduced before Jones is ordered to pay (there seems to be some dispute over whether a portion of the compensatory damages award is economic or not, and depending on the answer on that, the cap under Texas statutory punitive damages caps would seem to be somewhere between $750k and $1m; even if the plaintiffs succeed in their plan to challenge the statutory caps as unconstitutional and the cap that applies is 10× compensatory, as they have suggested it should be, that would cap punitive at $41 million.)
The $50m is adding the punitive and compensatory verdicts, neither of which are yet part of a judgement he has been ordered to pay.
On the other hand, this case involves 2 parents. There is a larger case in Connecticut that doesn't face Texas punitive damages caps that he has also suffered default on and will face damages, as well as another Texas case.
- hindsightbias 4y agoMaybe Abbott could redo his tort philosophy if he can shake down the tree owner more.
- aronas 4y agoI was wondering myself about that so I did some sleuthing. This law professor explains that the Texas Constitution provides for "the right of trial by jury to be inviolate": https://twitter.com/heidilifeldman/status/1555628079036391425?s=21&t=fNlS9AELlvbBwHRJ2U5PAw https://twitter.com/heidilifeldman/status/155562807903639142... The whole Twitter thread has more details but the TLDR is because of the Texas constitution, and the large amount of money at stake, this will almost certainly end up being resolved on appeal in the Texas court system. In particular, to answer the question if the Texas legislature's cap may inhibit the jury's ability to determine the punitive award amount, as the state constitution says they may.
- gpm 4y agoThe plaintiffs attorney has talked about this to reporters twice that I've seen Time 1: https://twitter.com/dansolomon/status/1555308565715451904 https://twitter.com/dansolomon/status/1555308565715451904 Time 2: https://twitter.com/averytravistv/status/1555692735906349057 https://twitter.com/averytravistv/status/1555692735906349057 In the first video (which was from before the jury announced what they though were appropriate punitive damages) says "10, 15 times" compensatory damages, $50m is below the upper end of that. The 10x you quote just seems to be the lower end of what he suggested the limit might be. The second video discusses what the statutory cap is (they think $750k per claim, $4.5m total)/that they don't think it's constitutional. Also that they don't think this will be directly litigated like it usually would, but be adjudicated by the bankruptcy court.
- roenxi 4y agoIf Jones can afford to pay any of these figures that it says interesting things about how ineffective deplatforming is and really rather undermines the "big tech is a monopoly!" argument. Most people can't make $4 million in a lifetime, let alone these figures.
- throwawaylinux 4y ago
- FireBeyond 4y agoHe claimed that a judgment of $2M would bankrupt Infowars. But emails revealed that, at times, revenue was $800K -per day-, and the judge asked him to explain how potentially less than 3 days revenue would have that effect.
- andrewljohnson 4y agoInfoWars made $800K in one day, not _per_ day. Jones claims that was their best day ever. Which makes total sense to me... businesses have huge boom days, and plaintiff lawyers will happily imply you should multiply that figure by 365 days.
- nkozyra 4y agoEven so, let's say that was a 10x day ... the question still has merit.
- Kaze404 4y agoIf you divide it by 20 before multiplying by 365, which is a charitable read to say the least, it would still be an insane amount of money.
- kube-system 4y agoIs 20x charitable? For many highly political topics attention varies wildly between times when it is topical and when it is not. And further, some big contributors may contribute zero on most days, and contribute huge sums on one day. Many political fundraisers bring in large fractions of their income on only during a few key days or events.
- zackees 4y ago
- tmaly 4y ago
- dragonwriter 4y ago> The Judge overseeing the Alex Jones case declared him guilty herself, skipping the Jury trial, by claiming that he didn't provide evidence of his financials. . Jones on air claims he submitted it twice, but each time the judge told him it wasn't in the correct format. On the second submission, the Judge didn't give him an opportunity to fix it, instead she found him guilty by default, skipping the Jury trial and going straight to the penalty phase. That's a nice story. Here's are the actual default judgement orders in the two Travis County cases. The current case is the Pozner case, where he never provided documentation, not the case where he eventually supplied limited at incomplete documentation. https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/21074211-alex-jones-default-judgment-orders-texas https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/21074211-alex-jones-...
- jjeaff 4y agoSounds like maybe the only research you did was listen to what the convicted liar is saying. The reality is that Jones was given ample opportunity to comply and blatantly refused to cooperate with lawful court orders. Add to that, some of that information that he claimed under oath didn't exist, was accidentally sent to the plaintiff's attorneys by Jone's attorneys in a subsequent trial thus providing proof that said information was being withheld purposefully. In other words, this is exactly what justice looks like.
- rtkwe 4y agoThe title of the linked article has been updated (or the original submission was editorialized against HN guidelines) to "Alex Jones must pay $50m for Sandy Hook hoax claim" which is at least accurate to reasonable levels of rounding. Caps on punitive damages have always annoyed me, especially for things like the Exon Valdeze or similar oil spills, where the companies nickel and dime out the compensatory damages over years and then with capped punitive damages it barely impacts their bottom lines.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoSure, the judge gets final say but they rarely change these things unless the jury awards something ridiculous like a billion dollars for a broken bone.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Sure, the judge gets final say but they rarely change these things unless the jury awards something ridiculous like a billion dollars for a broken bone. Or, say, if the jury orders $45 million in punitive damages when $0 of the compensatory damages were economic, and there is a statutory limit (that the jury is by law not informed of before deliberating) on punitive damages of $750,000 plus double the economic damages.
- dukeofdoom 4y ago
- Consultant32452 4y agoJones did not have a jury trial for determining guilt, the judge gave a summary judgement to the plaintiffs because Jones allegedly did not fully comply with discovery. She accurately explained, as a matter of law, that he was guilty. That had been determined at the point of the summary judgement. What happened recently and in the news was just the jury determining the size of the punishment.
- dukeofdoom 4y ago
- jwithington 4y ago…if someone doesn’t do what is required of them (participate in discovery), what would you have done?
- 4y ago
- seventytwo 4y agoWhat’s important about this, is that Jones is being sued in other jurisdictions that don’t have maximum punitive limits. So it sets an important precedent for Jones (and others), that doing this kind of thing can cost you up to $50 million. Even though Jones won’t actually have to pay that amount, an important example has been made of him.
- scarab92 4y agoJuries awarding excessive punitive damages was enough of a problem that many states capped it. Seems more likely to me that, in the long run, this will also occur in the remaining states.
- winternett 4y agoI'm floored by reports on how much money he has made alone, not even touching on the verdict or the case! It's pretty wild that that amount of money was generated by his news machine, it would be very interesting to see where it all came from... Subscriptions? Sponsors? Yeesh, that's a lot of income. Other podcasters are going to still commit the same offences if settlements continue to under-weigh the earnings like that.
- sneak 4y agoHe sells snake oil nutritional supplements and prepper crap, just like most niche male podcasters/personalities. You can't generally make that much revenue from content alone unless you are like the top .0001% like Joe Rogan.
- stouset 4y agoWho also sells snake oil nutritional supplements and prepper crap…