3 ms·
I really can't see any other outcome besides Musk getting his ass handed to him by the Delaware Court of Chancery. It's always important to look at incentives
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
I really can't see any other outcome besides Musk getting his ass handed to him by the Delaware Court of Chancery.
It's always important to look at incentives and motivations when trying to read the tea leaves, and if you look at Delaware's incentives, it's very clear. The whole reason everyone incorporates in Delaware is because they have centuries of handling business cases and have built out a clear set of rules and procedures. That is, businesses go to them more for stability and predictability than anything else.
Musk signed a contract. The BS reasons he is trying to use to back out of it are borderline laughable, and even he knows this, so if anything is just really trying to negotiate better terms. The Delaware Court has every incentive to hold up the established rules of contracts, especially business acquisition contracts, and I'd be pretty shocked if they ruled in favor of Musk on any of his claims.
- SilverBirch 4y agoActually I have to take you up on this, people who run large corporations say that it's the strong legal regime they have. In reality, it's a tax shelter. The only question is "How much does Delaware care about their status as a real legal regime vs their actual purpose: a tax haven". They know it's difficult to defend "We're a tax shelter sucking revenue out of the rest of the union", so they argue "We have strong legal structures" but we all know that Coca Cola wouldn't be incorporated in Delaware if they could save a cent by being incorporated in Georgia.
- FrobeniusTwist 4y agoWhat tax, specifically, is Delaware a haven from? Incorporating in Delaware doesn't get you out of Federal income taxes, or state income taxes (to the extent your operations, which are probably not based in Delaware, subject you to income taxes from various states), or sales taxes, or property taxes, etc., etc. There are some taxes that are avoided by incorporating in Delaware, as opposed to some other jurisdiction, but they round to zero when compared with taxes imposed without regard to where you happen to be incorporated.
- sudosysgen 4y agoI think it's both. Many states could compete with Delaware by also becoming tax havens. They can't anymore, because there is now more to it that simply being cheap.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoThis isn't really true, for the simple reason that where a company is incorporated has little impact on the tax a company pays. Yes, there are some business tax benefits for being incorporated in Delaware, but they're negligible for a large corporation, and for a smaller business will probably end up costing you more. I mean, if your headquarters are in California, you have employees in California, and you get lots of revenue from California, the California government doesn't care much where you are incorporated - they'll get their pound of flesh regardless.
- palmetieri2000 4y ago> That is, businesses go to them more for stability and predictability than anything else. You really think this is the reason and not the extraordinary removal of income taxes for companies and shares?