4 ms·
News flash: Consumer Reports is not a cheerleader for the top selling products. They are an organization concerned over what you get in actual fact for your mon
by kstenerud 15y ago
News flash: Consumer Reports is not a cheerleader for the top selling products. They are an organization concerned over what you get in actual fact for your money.
Consumer Reports is read by people who want to know all of the quality issues and hard facts about a product before making a purchasing decision. Such consumers always have, and always will be, a small market segment.
This "credibility rant" reads like a sycophant lamenting those who don't heap lavish praise upon the popular kids.
- j_baker 15y agoI don't think the author ever said that Consumer Reports should be a cheerleader for top-selling products. Rather, the author says that Consumer Reports doesn't seem to have much influence over what sells. It sounds to me like you agree with the author.
- kstenerud 15y agoCR has plenty of influence over what sells to its target market. If this weren't so, it would be impossible for them to turn a profit. The author is claiming that CR is irrelevant and out of touch, and "demonstrates" his point using a market that CR doesn't even cater to. You might as well argue that Techcrunch is irrelevant because it doesn't cover the latest in housing and furniture.
- bryanlarsen 15y agoI love Consumer Reports. I won't choose my phone based on their reviews, but they did save me over $500 on a vacuum cleaner.
- jseliger 15y agothey did save me over $500 on a vacuum cleaner So what did you get? Sorry to threadjack, but I don't have one and may need to buy one shortly.
- bryanlarsen 15y agoHoover Windtunnel. Am very happy with it.
- jseliger 15y agoLooks great, and it's much cheaper than Dyson et al. Thanks for the tip.
- dubya 15y agoCR definitely does have an affect on the market for some things, but maybe not such a large effect for phones and computers. Try ordering their top-pick refrigerator or washing machine about a month after the review comes out to see.
- PotatoEngineer 15y agoUntil I saw this article, I never realized that CR reviewed computers. It makes sense (they review everything else), but I turn to CR for appliances and cars, not computers and smartphones. There are plenty of other sites that are better for reviewing computers and computer-like entities.