2 ms·
The frustration with Citizens is that it accorded a right that a lot of people believes is a function of natural personhood to a corporation. More fundamentall
by PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago
The frustration with Citizens is that it accorded a right that a lot of people believes is a function of natural personhood to a corporation.
More fundamentally, the first amendment is not a law, and the Constitution in general does not make the distinction that you are referring to. I am fairly certain that had the law in question for Citizens made the distinction you are referring to, the legal challenge would still have made it to the SCOTUS, and they would still have ruled the way they did.
- kube-system 4y agoI agree that it's a problem. The solution is not `rm -rf corporate_law`, the solution is to `git add amendment_34 && git commit -m 'fix citizens united' ` And yes, the Bill of Rights is law, and as such it is within the legislative's power to change.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoMy proposed solution is to restrict Citizens to non-profit corporations, thus leaving it in place for PACs, advocacy groups, lobbying groups and others, but removing speech rights from corporations explicitly created to facilitate the generation and distribution of profit.